Equivalency between Celeron/p4

Discussion about old PC hardware.

Equivalency between Celeron/p4

Postby Cobra42898 » 2018-10-11 @ 12:22

I've got a system with a genuine Intel (d865gbf iirc) motherboard, 1gb ram, and a Celeron 2.6ghz processor. Someone upgraded and I inherited it. I seem to recall the celerons were roughly equivalent, but crippled with smaller cache. Front speed bus was slower too I think. How slow does this make it compared to a normal Pentium 4? Same as a 2.0ghz? 2.4? Is there anything important that it won't do, or really is functionally different from? As with all my older machines, it's not running any really critical stuff that I'm panic stricken over. I'm just nosy. :-D
Cobra42898
Newbie
 
Posts: 26
Joined: 2018-8-11 @ 10:43

Re: Equivalency between Celeron/p4

Postby BinaryDemon » 2018-10-11 @ 12:42

Tough to make a generalized comparison because there are many different models of both P4's and Celerons. Also the comparison will differ based on the type computing workload you are doing. If you have a prescott based Celeron D, then it has 256kb cache - if its a Northwood Celeron it only has 128kb cache.

With all that disclaimer, I would generally say the difference is a few hundred megahertz - meaning I would guess your Celeron 2.6 ghz is roughly equal to a P4 2.0ghz.
Check out DOSBox Distro:

https://sites.google.com/site/dosboxdistro/ [*]

a lightweight Linux distro (tinycore) which boots off a usb flash drive and goes straight to DOSBox.

Make your dos retrogaming experience portable!
BinaryDemon
Newbie
 
Posts: 82
Joined: 2018-1-17 @ 00:35

Re: Equivalency between Celeron/p4

Postby weldum » 2018-10-11 @ 13:29

I agree with BinaryDemon
I have in my collection 3 s478 computers: Pentium 4 northwood 2.0, Celeron D 310 Prescott 2.13 and a Pentium 4 Northwood 2.26

in all the test's i've made, the celeron d comes out in last place, except when there's a software using SSE3 (which prescott supports, but northwood doesn't), also in gaming there's not so much of a difference, mainly because older games will run just fine in any of these.
later games will show more fps (just a bit more) on northwood due mainly to bigger cache

only far newer games (2007) will show a little improvement on the celeron over the pentium (but that's because of code optimized for SSE3), but still, these games are too new and they expect newer and more efficient processors, or at least older but faster processors (3.0GHz or more, hyperthreading in some cases and big L2 and L3 caches)

i know that these processors aren't the same and the comparison is a little bit wrong or unfair, but i'd say that, for S478 gaming you should go for the fastest p4 you can get, then a middle-tier p4 (2.26-2.8) and then you should look for celeron (preferably use celeron D)
With more than 15 computers, my room looks like a computer store :lol:
I believe that I like to write a lot of irrelevant content in my posts :happy:
386SX 25-PMMX 225-P2 466-C3 800-P3 900-Duron 892-Atom 1.6-P4 2.26-P4HT 3.0-i3 2.5-Celeron 3.5-FX 4.0
User avatar
weldum
Member
 
Posts: 246
Joined: 2016-2-16 @ 07:25
Location: Mendoza-Arg

Re: Equivalency between Celeron/p4

Postby zyga64 » 2018-10-11 @ 14:08

From my experience:
- Prescott Pentium 4 are not much faster than P4 Northwood with the same clock,
- Prescott Pentium 4 are more power hungry than P4 Northwood - Northwoods are much cooler,
- Celerons D (Prescott) are noticeably faster than Celerons Northwoood with the same clock (more cache, and faster FSB)

So I would say - for socket 478 - go for Pentium 4 Northwood.
Celerons D are not that bad anyway. Old celerons (FSB400/128kB cache) are worst desktop processors of its age, even worse than P4 Willamete.
TC430HX / P200MMX / 64 MB / Virge DX / YMF701 / DOS / Win98
BX Master / P!!! 450 / 256MB / Diamond Viper V550 / AWE64 / DOS / Win98SE
775i65G / E2160 / 1GB / Ti4200 / YMF724 / DOS / Win98SE / XPSP1
zyga64
Newbie
 
Posts: 90
Joined: 2014-3-12 @ 14:38
Location: Poland


Return to General Old Hardware

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: BLEXBot [Bot], keropi, walterg74 and 17 guests