sliderider wrote:TheMAN wrote:uhhh WRONG
you think upscaling a regular DVD makes it look just as good as the BD/HD version of the same movie? or how about exp […]
Show full quote
uhhh WRONG
you think upscaling a regular DVD makes it look just as good as the BD/HD version of the same movie? or how about expecting the DVD to be the same quality as "off the air" 1080i HDTV? THINK AGAIN... it is NO WHERE CLOSE
you won't be able to tell a difference if your TV was crap and/or settings way off
my mere "crappy" 60" sony xbr rear projection HDTV shows a clear difference between upscaling regular DVDs on my Toshiba HD-A35 HD-DVD player (was one of the best cheap upscalers in 2008) and HD-DVDs, and that's at a viewing distance twice the recommended (about 6.5 meters from the TV)!
so long as there are people who care about the full sensory experience of watching a movie, there will be demand for Blurays as the format further improves to larger and larger discs with more and more quality being put to it for quite a few more years
streaming videos are convenient and great, but there isn't enough internet bandwidth in the average household to allow the same quality a bluray can offer at this time, with 3D viewing requiring even MORE bandwidth... eventually we'll get there, and that is when you can declare optical media obsolete, but who knows... maybe by then, it'll be replaced yet again with a completely new format and we'll be back to square one again
3D is useless. Who needs it? It's just a way for Sony to unload all those BluRay players that nobody wants. Also, who is talking about streaming? You download the file then you watch it direct from your hard drive. That's how content will be accessed in the future. It will be like when you download a movie from XBOX Live!. If it's a rental the file has an expiration date and after that you won't be able to watch it anymore then you just delete the file because it's useless.
And seriously, if upscaled DVD isn't good enough for you, you really need to stop being so nitpicky and if you REALLY want the full experience, then you should be watching movies on a 75 foot theater screen and not on your 55" TV.
I'm not being "nitpicky", I am saying I CAN SEE A DIFFERENCE and you are just blind or have a shitty TV... the difference isn't subtle, it is huge
3D is a gimmick true, but some movies such as avatar were originally shot in 3D... I saw both 2D and 3D versions of this movie, there is no comparison.... 2D avatar just plain sucks, it looks dull, flat, and too animated.... the 3D version made something that was basically animated into something that is believably real... made it look like it was just filmed in a studio, almost
nobody wants to download movies with their crappy DSL or cable modem connection, no, not with current average speeds the household gets... you're forgetting that not everyone pays for anything more than the most basic internet... downloading a 30GB movie will take all day or more for them! You're forgetting that american consumerism demands instant gratification... they want to go to the store, buy or rent a disc, come home, stuff it into the player and just sit down and watch... you're also forgetting some shitty ISPs have download quotas monthly.... people are already running into issues because they got netflix, what makes you think downloadable movies is a great idea?
you got serious issues if you can't see a fucking difference between HD and SD video... nobody has to be a videophile or quality freak to even see the difference.... I bet you just love polishing turds in your house and think they are diamonds!
so now, do you have anything more stupid to say?