The motherboard is an Epox-8KTA (2, possibly)
And actually, this is the hard drive I've been using since the PC was built, so I know for a fact it works. There's an entire long sequence of events which led me to this point tho. I better relate a as-condensed-as-possible version.
Awhile ago I was trying to fix sound issues in a game that led me to trying to uninstall DirectX 9 (which I had tried to see if it would make another game work on Win98... it didn't) but in doing so I wound up messing something up and getting an invalid VxD bluescreen every time I booted up, which the BSOD itself said reinstall, and all the info I found on that issue online basically confirmed.
So I did, and THAT reinstall went fine. However then a few days ago the comp developed an issue of constantly rebooting or, if I started up in safe mode, giving me "Windows Protection Error, restart your computer" which I tried all sorts of things and eventually figured the install must be faulty and formatted the drive again before realizing the problem was that somehow the memory had become unseated (which I realized due to running memtest86 from a floppy... at first, it found errors every five nanoseconds, but after re-seating the memory it reported no problems. But the HD was formatted by this time).
Part of the reason this happened at all though is because, due to it being 80gb, I can only scandisk and defrag the drive by physically removing it and hooking it up (via adapters) to a USB slot on my Windows 7 laptop. It was after a round of this that the constant rebootings started, so this time around I went into that version of Linux and tried partitioning the drive (using Gparted) so it read as two smaller drives, but after that failed I tried different configs, most recently (just before making this post) I had tried allocating just 30gb and leaving the rest unallocated to see how that would work.
Not only did I still get the Disk I/O thing but... well, now its gotten worse.
So I went back into Linux, but now... well, its being weird with regards to the hard drive. The BIOS says its there, and Linux kinda-sorta says its there. But it says it isn't really. And now it won't let me change anything--gives me an error every time I try and says "See Details" but the "details" just consist of saying what it tried to do with an icon at the end that tells me freaking NOTHING.
I'm afraid I may have just borked this hard drive and now have to order a new one. =(
The theory I had intended to test was that maybe the partition had to be made with fdisk, so I had been intending to make a single 10gb partition that fdisk could handle, but this might have put the kibosh on that unless I can save it.
I'll try out this "DBAN" thing, I've also heard that there's a better version of Fdisk that isn't as stupid or limited.