First post, by Doomn00b
- Rank
- Newbie
EDIT2:
Updated with my build-plan and a list of games I'm interested in.
Build-plan:
--------------
OS: Dos 7.1, W98, XP, W10
MB: Portwell RUBY-9719VG2AR
CPU: Intel X5470
RAM: 8GB DDR2
GPU1 (DOS): Intel GMA X4500 (integrated)
GPU2 (W98): Radeon 9250 (pci)
GPU3 (XP32+W10x64): Geforce GTX 960 (PCI-e)
SC1 (DOS): ?
SC2: SB Audigy 2 ZS
FDD: SuperDisk LS-240
NIC: Intel 1000MT
DoS-games:
---------------
Commander Keen 3-5
Crusader: No Remorse/Regret
Doom 1-2
Duke Nukem II
Duke Nukem 3D
Dune 2
Shadow Warrior
Quake
UFO: Enemy Unknown
Loom
Indiana Jones & The Fate of Atlantis
Rise of the Triad
The Dig
Oregon Trail
System Shock
EDIT:
Right, so I've been checking into this, and I might have passed over cards which I shouldn't, since apparently there are more, and GOOD cards which are either compatible with sb/sbpro/sb16/WSS/MPU401 or having every compatibility except sb16 - but still being capable of 16-bit sound in their native mode. Any suggestions? Honestly... This is starting to make my head spin! I need ONE card to rule them all... Is it too much to ask?
----
This is something I've been going over a lot recently - I never realized how complex of a topic this is!
I myself only recently got into Retro-computing and retro pc games, so I don't have the same opinions about the cult value of certain brands, so I've been trying to instead select according to what gives either most compatibility or the most features. (sadly, the two are not exclusive)
First, I sorted the cards based on chipsets - using Gerwin's ISA sound card overview.
Sound cards - from best to worst
This then showed me which chipsets have the greatest amount of compatibility - which let me remove quite a few cards. Then, I sorted the remaining cards based on features, and came up with an ever shorter list. Still, this meant I had quite a few cards left to chose from... Enter the final steps:
Using Great Hierophant's Points-system I was then able to come up with 4 final cards, as the best picks for a newbie like me:
Vintage ISA DOS Gaming Sound Card Rankings System
MS 64 Home Studio Pro
SC-8000 PnP v3.31
ESS AudioDrive 1869
Audio Excel CMI8330
The above are the cards in question. Using his system I came to the conclusion that the Audio Excel CMI8330 was the best pick.
However, I felt that Hierophant's system was a bit too simple, so as an experiment I added another dimension: PERFORMANCE. Cards which feature Ram-slots can provide quite a bit more horse-power if one puts in a bit of extra coin - if one takes this into account, then the Maxi Sound 64 Home Studio Pro becomes the winner instead.
All this, and I'm still not quite certain which one to pick.
If it helps any, the ISA soundcard will be used in a system meant for DoS/Win98, with a minimum of 4 gb ram, Core2Quad CPU, FreeDos and in tandem with an Audigy 2 ZS or an Aureal Vortex 2.
So... what do you think? Did I sort the cards in the right way? Do you have a better suggestion(s)? Have I scored the remaining 4 cards accurately? I must admit, some of it was guesswork...
Matrix:
1. MS 64 Home Studio Pro ES1868, WBH, Dream SAM9407 Wavetable + 4MB ROM + 72-Pin RAM Slot (16MB), Daughterboard for S/PDIF […]
1. MS 64 Home Studio Pro
ES1868, WBH, Dream SAM9407 Wavetable + 4MB ROM + 72-Pin RAM Slot (16MB), Daughterboard for S/PDIF Input/Output.Compatibilities: Controller+Codec 16-bit 44KHz, SB/SBPro/WSS/MPU-401 compatible, Integr. OPL3 clone, PnP, dual joystick, Full-duplex, IDE
Points:
Gameport 1.25 (dual joy)
MIDI Hardware Interface 2.50
Music Synthesizer 2.25
Digital Audio Output 4.00
Performance 4.00Total: 10/14
2. SC-8000 PnP v3.31
CS4236B, WBH, Dream SAM9233/8905 Wavetable + 1MB ROM + 72-Pin RAM Slot, IDE, volume wheelCompatibilities: Controller+Codec 16-Bit 48KHz, SB/SBPro/WSS/MPU-401 compatible, Integr. OPL3 clone, PnP, WT digital interface, IDE
Points:
Gameport 1.00
MIDI Hardware Interface 2.50
Music Synthesizer 2.25
Digital Audio Output 3.50
Performance 4.00Total: 9.25/13.25
3. ESS AudioDrive 1869
ES1869, WBH, line-in, microphone, CD-m, amplifier, IDECompatibilities: Controller+Codec 16-bit 48KHz, SB/SBPro/WSS/MPU-401 compatible, Integr. OPL3 clone, PnP, dual joystick, Full-duplex, IDE, Spatializer 3-D VBX.
Points:
Gameport 1.25 (dual joy)
MIDI Hardware Interface 2.50
Music Synthesizer 2.25
Digital Audio Output 3.75
Performance 2.00Total: 9.75/11.75
4. Audio Excel CMI8330
CMI8330, WBH (PCB-ID: AV310)Compatibilities: Controller+Codec 16-bit, SB/SBPro/SB16+WSS+MPU-401 compatible, Integr. OPL3 clone, PnP, S/PDIF input/output.
Points:
Gameport 1.50
MIDI Hardware Interface 2.50
Music Synthesizer 2.25
Digital Audio Output 4.00
Performance 1.00Total: 10.25/11.25