I think none of us here has such a large collection. So why don't you run some benchmarks yourself and tell us, which performs best? 😀 Would love to read a writeup on speeds, compatibility (games, monitors, Windows 3.x)...

excellent suggestion. My memory is a bit fuzzy. Did anyone even make any serious benchmarking software for CGA/EGA?

For VGA I am using Dr Hardware for quick benchmarking. Should work with EGA as well, I guess...

I also managed to acquire some 6 EGA cards last year, the fastest were the Paradise PEGA2A and an ATI EGA Wonder 800 - these were also the most compatible in my gaming tests.

this was the 3rd best choice

and these 2 where OK but nothing to brag about

the worst one for me was this TEVA card, too many hard lock-ups. I replaced the 74 series logic but did not improve things - actually the same as the TEVA above so maybe something is wrong with the main ICs

The fastest card was this OTI EGA/VGA one but even when jumpered to EGA-only some games insisted to detect it as VGA and either produced a garbage screen or locked up....

I haven't done any benchmarks , I just judge from Keen4 and Dangerous Dave's Risky Rescue scrolling speed + compatibility with EGA titles with Multisync monitors.

None of the EGA cards above have win3x drivers that support more than 640x350 - even the ones that do 800x600 only do it in win2x - or at least I did not find a way to do that in win3x . There was a thread by predator99 with some program to make the good cards work in vga 16 colors mode but nothing worked reliably for me.