retardware wrote on 2021-10-13, 18:11:
I got a retching feeling and my instant thought was "FSP".
This page confirmed my feeling.
Nothing wrong with later FSP designs... They're appropriate for old systems because they are 5V rail heavy designs (whereas newer PSUs are 12V heavy). The problem is that this is one of their older designs, with the two transistor 5VSB circuit, and it has brown cellulose glue that degrades and becomes conductive.
Later FSP models like ATX-350PN or ATX-350THN are much better, with the exception of early revisions which also use the old 5VSB circuit in the design. You can tell whether you have the newer 5VSB circuit by looking for a 8 or so pin DIP in the primary section
The "Low ESR" caps on that thingy aren't that low esr... from my datasheet sifting I believe that good low ESR electrolytics have ESR around 30, 40milliohms.
They are in fact low ESR. He's just written it wrong in the photo. For example, for the 12.5mm green Teapo (cheapo Teapo), he wrote "0.19", when he should have written 0.019.
Regarding the discussion on polys etc, these have ESR typically in the range of 5 to 15milliohms.
In good modern PSUs I regularl […]
Show full quote
Regarding the discussion on polys etc, these have ESR typically in the range of 5 to 15milliohms.
In good modern PSUs I regularly see some electrolytics and at least one poly for each voltage rail. So I suppose the polys are being used to eat up spikes.
Maybe it might be indeed bad to "polymod" PSUs, considering that it will cause the ESR drop from, say, 40milliohms, to, say, 5milliohms.
This could, for example, lead to much higher inrush currents, which maybe other parts don't take too well.
Considering that MLCCs can have ESR of around one milliohm, I guess these aren't suitable for all PSU designs...
Correct... New PSUs use polymer caps because they're specially designed for them... In old PSUs, you rarely use polymers because they usually cause enormous ripple when used in PI filters. I say 'rarely' because there are several exceptions to the rule. There's a particular thread about this very topic over at the badcaps forum.
I think the best advice I can give is not to waste money and time on this FSP garbage, and instead get a Seasonic, because you (probably) don't want to toast your drives with 14, 15volts.
I think it's a worthwhile project, if the glue were removed and if a proper 5vsb circuit was hacked in (details on how this can be done are available at the badcaps forum).
But yea, just get a Seasonic or something.