Adventure remakes poll

Getting old DOS games working on modern hardware. (DOSBox topics belong in DOSBox areas below, not here).

Adventure remakes poll

Postby robertmo » 2018-5-31 @ 12:19

Can you arrange these games in order of how much you would like them to be modernised with point and click interface. (No gfx/audio/story improvements)

Les Manley 1 In: Search For The King
Larry 3
Codename: Iceman
Space Quest 3
Conquest of Camelot
Police Quest 2
Laura Bow 1: Colonel's Bequest

If for some reason you don't want them to be modernised write in this thread: viewtopic.php?f=7&t=60391
User avatar
robertmo
l33t
 
Posts: 4581
Joined: 2003-6-18 @ 10:35

Re: Adventure remakes poll

Postby collector » 2018-5-31 @ 16:34

There is no *active* KQ4 P&C remake.
User avatar
collector
l33t
 
Posts: 4334
Joined: 2003-1-15 @ 10:39

Re: Adventure remakes poll

Postby robertmo » 2018-5-31 @ 16:41

User avatar
robertmo
l33t
 
Posts: 4581
Joined: 2003-6-18 @ 10:35

Re: Adventure remakes poll

Postby collector » 2018-5-31 @ 16:57

I said active. That one has had little done in the past few years. Even the website has a js holiday snowfall script that has been running for the past couple of years. Latest update on their forums is from 2016. It is effectively dead. Can't say I care much for the 3D pre-rendered artwork anyway. I expect it to be abandoned before too much longer.

The Magic Mirror Games KQ4 remake has stopped as well. They could not find a sprite artist.
User avatar
collector
l33t
 
Posts: 4334
Joined: 2003-1-15 @ 10:39

Re: Adventure remakes poll

Postby robertmo » 2018-6-01 @ 06:54

It's like an open project. Anybody can join at any moment, make some animations and leave. But the base of animations is constantly growing. They already have about half of them if not more. And they already have all the background images. So even if anyone would like to continue, he would have some work already done.
User avatar
robertmo
l33t
 
Posts: 4581
Joined: 2003-6-18 @ 10:35


Re: Adventure remakes poll

Postby robertmo » 2018-12-26 @ 17:23

User avatar
robertmo
l33t
 
Posts: 4581
Joined: 2003-6-18 @ 10:35

Re: Adventure remakes poll

Postby Spikey » 2018-12-27 @ 13:24

PQ2 or Laura Bow 1, both struggle with the parser interface IMO, and all the rest actually do quite well with it. PQ2 needs updates beyond the parser change, though.
Iceman would be the next, but only if it had gameplay changes and tweaks on top of the P/C interface.

Larry 3, SQ3 and Camelot are all perfect as is. I would just want more music in SQ3, and marginally more in Camelot- and have no artists in mind who would be worthy of doing it, MusicallyInspired would be the only one in the frame.

As for Les Manley, the first game is quite good. It would need changes beyond just parser->P/C to properly update it, like changing some idiotic game designs (see: dead ends and excessive walking) which crop up once or twice.

When I say changes beyond, I mean if all you do is remove parser and make it P/C, you have made the game only slightly more accessible but not really addressed the issues that make it a hard game to play in 2018/9. Take Iceman for example, it has the makings of an amazing game, but the sub sequence, some other sequences and some insanely hard puzzles make for a game not many want to revisit. Simply changing the interface would make it slightly easier to look at things and use inventory items, but doesn't stop the bad game design from being a major barrier. You would need at least a 'lite remake' to make it playable in a real sense.

I don't see many advantages of a 'remake' which only removes parser. Usually, the switch from parser to P/C is cited as a negative by adventure game fans! (For me, and probably I am one of the few who thinks the following, Colonel's Bequest and PQ2 were horribly made games in terms of playing them, and have lots of conversation trees which most players won't ever see all of. P/C would go a long way to helping with that, even though it doesn't solve CB's timing/Act issues and PQ2's occasionally obtuse, annoyingly optional and hard to fathom puzzles.)

To end on a positive, I think Larry 3, SQ3 and Camelot are actually the best 3 EGA Sierra games ever made. Probably 3 of the best EGA games ever made total.
User avatar
Spikey
Member
 
Posts: 241
Joined: 2003-2-04 @ 10:36
Location: South Australia

Re: Adventure remakes poll

Postby root42 » 2018-12-27 @ 14:22

I play the SCI EGA games solely with keyboard. Mouse support is minimal anyway, and keyboard input is pretty effective. I also don't care much about the VGA remakes. What I'd rather see is new games, like Thimbleweed Park. But the old games are good as they are. :)
Soldering, retro game reviews and more on YouTube and Bonus videos
Me playing games on my 286 and on my Sega MD2 on Twitch
80386DX@25 MHz, 8 MiB RAM, Tseng ET4000 1 MiB, schlae AdLib, PC MIDI Card + SC55MkII, XT CF Lite, OSSC 1.6
User avatar
root42
Oldbie
 
Posts: 983
Joined: 2018-1-27 @ 13:23


Return to DOS

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: knowledge [bot] and 1 guest