Completed Stonekeep! Much better RPG than I expected it to be. I often see RPG rankings where this is quite low, and games like Anvil of Dawn outrank it. But having played both, Stonekeep is much better than AoD. Where SK excels at is drawing the player into the game world. Technically, it's one of the best-sounding General MIDI implementations I've heard, with well-composed scores as well. Graphics, despite being VGA, were extremely impressive. On the downside, what was probably most frustrating was the lack of a good inventory identification system. When you pick an item for the first time, it is recorded in your journal with a black-and-white depiction and name of item. In your actual inventory, it is displayed in color with no name. Some items look very similar, so it becomes a guessing game to figure out which orb is which, or ax, sword, dagger, etc. Simply labeling the items with a single word on mouse-over would've solved this.
I'm more of a fan of isometric perspectives and turn-based combat, but I still rank this fairly high on my list of RPGs I've completed in the last few years:
1 System Shock 2
2 Ultima Underworld II
3 Ultima VII Pt. 2 Serpent Isle
4 System Shock
5 Baldur’s Gate 1
6 Lords of Xulima
7 Eschalon Book 1
8 Stonekeep
9 Ultima Underworld I
10 Realms of Arkania I
11 Might and Magic 4: Clouds of Xeen
12 Lands of Lore: The Throne of Chaos
13 Legend of Grimrock 1
14 Anvil of Dawn
I consider all of these games to be very good, but this list differentiates them a bit according to the impression they left on me.
All told, the game took me 44 hours over the course of 48 days.
The attachment stonekeep-1.jpg is no longer available
The attachment stonekeep-2.jpg is no longer available