VOGONS


MSI 845PE Neo (MS-6580 VER 3.0) no post

Topic actions

First post, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Hi

A while ago i got an MSI 845PE Neo (MS-6580 VER 3.0). Managed to get it to only post once. It also complained about a missing gpu (I didn't insert it) twice. Now its not posting (again). No codes on my post card. Whats weird is that cpu is in reset state unless i press down on it. I've tried different ram, gpu's, cpu's, power supplies, cmos batteries. Also, when i was pressing down on cpu it gave me an two tone siren which means voltage level issue or low fan speed. Any ideas?

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 1 of 22, by dominusprog

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Clean the slots (both RAM and PCI/AGP) with contact cleaner.

Duke_2600.png
A-Trend ATC-1020 V1.1 ❇ Cyrix 6x86 150+ @ 120MHz ❇ 32MiB EDO RAM (8MiBx4) ❇ A-Trend S3 Trio64V2 2MiB
Aztech Pro16 II-3D PnP ❇ 8.4GiB Quantum Fireball ❇ Win95 OSR2 Plus!

Reply 2 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Clean the slots (both RAM and PCI/AGP) with contact cleaner.

Tried it and no success. Anything else i could try?

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 3 of 22, by Horun

User metadata
Rank l33t++
Rank
l33t++

Post a good picture of the board please.

Hate posting a reply and then have to edit it because it made no sense 😁 First computer was an IBM 3270 workstation with CGA monitor. Stuff: https://archive.org/details/@horun

Reply 4 of 22, by Karbist

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

Does the clock LED on the post card turn on?

Reply 5 of 22, by dominusprog

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Check for broken solder joints around the CPU socket.

Duke_2600.png
A-Trend ATC-1020 V1.1 ❇ Cyrix 6x86 150+ @ 120MHz ❇ 32MiB EDO RAM (8MiBx4) ❇ A-Trend S3 Trio64V2 2MiB
Aztech Pro16 II-3D PnP ❇ 8.4GiB Quantum Fireball ❇ Win95 OSR2 Plus!

Reply 7 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie
Karbist wrote on 2024-02-18, 16:42:

Does the clock LED on the post card turn on?

Yes.

dominusprog wrote on 2024-02-18, 17:24:

Check for broken solder joints around the CPU socket.

Did not found any broken solder joints.

rasz_pl wrote on 2024-02-18, 17:33:

Socket 478 are usually bulletproof, if anything try pressing on the Chipset

Tried and didn't work.

Horun wrote on 2024-02-18, 16:40:

Post a good picture of the board please.

Here

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 8 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Measuring around the vrm, I found that C29 has 4 ohms, but C56 that looks the same has the same resistance. Also when i press down on the cpu now, it goes out of reset and stays the same even if i stop pushing on it. Whats weird is that the mobo is beeping corrupted-like two tone siren. Any ideas what might be the cause?

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 10 of 22, by momaka

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

If you can get the motherboard to reliably move through (some) POST codes when you press on the CPU vs. the motherboard doing absolutely nothing when you don't press on the CPU, then, you may have cracked joints under the BGA CPU socket. Some stock Intel coolers are notorious for warping the board when they are fully tightened. This can be made worse if the motherboard was shipped with the CPU cooler still strapped to the board or if the previous owner ever allowed the CPU to overheat (due to HS clogged with dust.)

But it could also be bad contacts / corrosion on the CPU pins... though you said you tried different CPUs, so that should have gotten rid of any in the CPU socket.

I also see the original United Chemicon KZG (brown) electrolytic capacitors around the CPU and OST RLX(?) (blue) capacitors are still present on the board, so there's always those to suspect as well. UCC (United Chemicon) KZG series are known to be problematic, especially 6.3V ones with capacity of 2200 and 3300 uF, even if they don't look bulging (though most frequently, they do bulge when they go bad.) OST RLX series are the in a similar boat, especially the smaller ones.

So try doing at least 10 tests where you try to power the board with pressure on the CPU and without to see how the POST codes behave.
It may also be worthwhile to try putting a heatsink on the CPU but *not* strapping it to the board (to prevent warping) to see if that changes anything. And also, make sure the CPU cooler fan is plugged in. Some boards will sound an alarm if they don't detect a plugged in fan.

Lastly, going from the last sentence in the above paragraph, also check for any missing or damaged SMD components near or on the CPU fan header. Also try some different 3-pin fans, just in case. Some socket A motherboards for sure will stay in RESET state / not POST if a CPU fan is not detected. With P4, this wasn't usually the case... but I always keep it in mind when testing motherboards, just in case.

Reply 11 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Got some time to work on this board.

rasz_pl wrote on 2024-02-29, 16:38:

diagram in attachment, start with power delivery map on page 3

Ill start measuring the cpu VRM first and let you how it goes.

momaka wrote on 2024-03-01, 18:08:
If you can get the motherboard to reliably move through (some) POST codes when you press on the CPU vs. the motherboard doing ab […]
Show full quote

If you can get the motherboard to reliably move through (some) POST codes when you press on the CPU vs. the motherboard doing absolutely nothing when you don't press on the CPU, then, you may have cracked joints under the BGA CPU socket. Some stock Intel coolers are notorious for warping the board when they are fully tightened. This can be made worse if the motherboard was shipped with the CPU cooler still strapped to the board or if the previous owner ever allowed the CPU to overheat (due to HS clogged with dust.)

But it could also be bad contacts / corrosion on the CPU pins... though you said you tried different CPUs, so that should have gotten rid of any in the CPU socket.

I also see the original United Chemicon KZG (brown) electrolytic capacitors around the CPU and OST RLX(?) (blue) capacitors are still present on the board, so there's always those to suspect as well. UCC (United Chemicon) KZG series are known to be problematic, especially 6.3V ones with capacity of 2200 and 3300 uF, even if they don't look bulging (though most frequently, they do bulge when they go bad.) OST RLX series are the in a similar boat, especially the smaller ones.

So try doing at least 10 tests where you try to power the board with pressure on the CPU and without to see how the POST codes behave.
It may also be worthwhile to try putting a heatsink on the CPU but *not* strapping it to the board (to prevent warping) to see if that changes anything. And also, make sure the CPU cooler fan is plugged in. Some boards will sound an alarm if they don't detect a plugged in fan.

Lastly, going from the last sentence in the above paragraph, also check for any missing or damaged SMD components near or on the CPU fan header. Also try some different 3-pin fans, just in case. Some socket A motherboards for sure will stay in RESET state / not POST if a CPU fan is not detected. With P4, this wasn't usually the case... but I always keep it in mind when testing motherboards, just in case.

I can't get it to POST nor to move through the POST codes. All i get is the siren some minutes after I keep applying pressure on the CPU. No idea whats the backstory of this board. All I can say is I got it as "scrap" with other boards. As I remember its the only broken one. I've tried 2 different s478 heat sinks with fans. Board is not beeping anything and not moving through POST codes when pressure isn't applied.

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 12 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Done some further diagnostics. On Q12, Q15, Q25, Q13 I get 1.5v on drain, 9.12v on gate, 0.03v on source. On Q14, Q11 I get 11.93v on drain, 1.5v on gate and 2.93v on source. NB and SB get warm. Noticed USB voltage is 5.2v, so its a little bit high. With an metal backplate installed it comes out of reset without me pressing on the CPU. Any ideas?

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 13 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Forgot to mention, when I got it to post, I pressed hard on the south bridge. It complained about keyboard not being detected (didn't think it would post). Plugged in a USB keyboard, but it wasn't responding, so I reset the MB. After that it went dead again. Also shorted gate with source on Q11, but it seems like the short is now gone. Any ideas?

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 14 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Pulled out 1 1500uF 16v cap in the VRM. There wasn't any signs of leaking so I guess the rest of them should be fine too. Any ideas?

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 15 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

I got another board. Same model and revision. And same problem too. Two tone siren after sometime. I have no idea what is wrong here. It just looks like a plague on these MSI boards.

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 16 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Finally fixed my MSI diagnostic bracket aaand guess what? All red LED's (CPU not initialized)! Who would have guessed... Weird how it says CPU hasn't initialized but it still does the siren. This only points to the VRM being bad. I guess I gotta go buy another board for comparison...

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5

Reply 17 of 22, by PC@LIVE

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Well reading what you wrote, the card gave some sign of operation, only when you pressed on the southbridge, and so I think it could be somewhere there the problem, if you have a way to observe enlarging that area, you could see if there is any welding to redo, maybe that's the problem.

AMD 286-16 287-10 4MB HD 45MB VGA 256KB
AMD 386DX-40 Intel 387 8MB HD 81MB VGA 256KB
Cyrix 486DLC-40 IIT387-40 8MB VGA 512KB
AMD 5X86-133 16MB VGA VLB CL5428 2MB and many others
AMD K62+ 550 SOYO 5EMA+ and many others
AST Pentium Pro 200 MHz L2 256KB

Reply 18 of 22, by ElectroSoldier

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Did you swap the PSU?

Reply 19 of 22, by kotel

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie
PC@LIVE wrote on 2024-12-14, 22:10:

Well reading what you wrote, the card gave some sign of operation, only when you pressed on the southbridge, and so I think it could be somewhere there the problem, if you have a way to observe enlarging that area, you could see if there is any welding to redo, maybe that's the problem.

I also thought that at first, but I've tried using thermal manipulation (hot-air station) on the SB/NB, EEPROM (I think?), Super IO chip and some others, but this didn't result in any changes (maybe I didn't do it enough?). Then I remembered the time when I shorted one of the VRM mosfets. I think its a primary side one. The short is gone now but the board is still as useful as an rock...

ElectroSoldier wrote on 2024-12-15, 01:05:

Did you swap the PSU?

First thing I did 😀

"Sent on a mission, to protect the last treasures. Through struggle and strife we can see the light. Even if our mission is partially complete, Our efforts are not in vain.
Let that be our legacy."
-Stronghold 5-5