Alex827 wrote on 2024-08-19, 02:58:

Any reccomendations as to how to proceed would be appreciated. I have a general idea of what the issue may be but referring back to old threads and sorting through them for a generic slotket has proven difficult.

It is not generic but produced by SOYO. There is not much to be found on the web. If you can't make them work you could try to find a couple of slotkets with a good reputation for SMP usage.

1. are you using the same model of slotket for both slot?
2. are you sure that the slotket is validated to run with 100Mhz bus? may be, just may be they are only stable on 66Mhz?
3. there are four cap is missing on the slotket in the attached image, is it your second slotket?

Totally could but I think I'm pretty close to having them working so I'd rather not have to spend more money.

1. Both are identical models
2. They are validated at up to 133 MHz and I was able to pass memtest at bus speeds up to 112 MHz (cpu won't post at 133) but only with a single cpu
3. I re-capped the motherboard and sloket, to improve cpu cooler compatibility for what I want to install, the caps needed to be installed on the back of the pcb. This does not affect stability in any way.

What is the difference between dual cpu support on slokets when pin X2 is used vs N33? It seems some of the shared bus requests are working so the mod performed did something.

Memory wont even count up and detect correctly in dual cpu mode. I had to enable quick boot to even boot memtest to see the failure.

I never tried to mod a slotket for dual cpus but the other ones I got to work in dual for my supermicro was Asus S370-DL.

I never tried other slotkets like the later versions of MSI Master as I don't have those. I did try more "generic" ones that had a dual jumper, only the Asus ones worked for me.

FYI your board is a 440GX not 440BX, shouldn't make any difference at all just pointing that out.

I don't see it explicitly stated that you're either trying two of the celeron or two of the PIII-900 and not one of each.

BitWrangler wrote on 2024-08-19, 17:11:

I don't see it explicitly stated that you're either trying two of the celeron or two of the PIII-900 and not one of each.

I'm pretty sure any celerons past mendocino core can not be run in dual.

I have identical SL5BS Pentium III chips which I am attempting to run in a dual setup. They will post with the current mod and are detected at their correct speed and specs.

Also my bad about the GX vs BX. Totally forget sometimes and just call it BX. I have had a few of these Supermicro boards with both GX and BX chips with the lastest bios released with the same result being achieved on both.

I have this board maxed out at 2 GB of ram and when in dual cpu mode only will report sometimes half or less.

Again the issue is just that the memory is not properly detected and cannot be accesssed correctly when in dual setup pointing to the bus request signals not quite being processed correctly.

Maybe it's the wrong pin, maybe the resisor is not correct, could be a number of things.

Any difference if you use less RAM, like just a single stick?

I've tried different cofigs and every time it will report incorrectly or have stability issues. With only a stick of ram it will sometimes post and boot ok but stability is still bad and memtest reports issues.

Never had much luck dual running on either of my SM boards (P6DGU & P6DBU) even though I was using the 'better' slot 1 adapters (tried both ABit SlotKET !!! and MSI MS-6905 Master 2.x) though a single processor always ran without issue...gave up trying and switched to slot 1 procs.

Take it your board is a late enough version to have the uprated VRM chips (HIP6004BCB or HIP6004CB rather than HIP6004ACB) for both slots. Is your 2GB of memory buffered or unbuffered?

H3nrik V! wrote on 2024-08-20, 04:03:

Any difference if you use less RAM, like just a single stick?

Yeah I'd try that too, no telling if it's RAM flakiness once you use more than 128MB per module, 3 modules on those chipsets. If after it's working reliably in dual you can get more working, great, but at the moment, get it as simplified as possible.

Alex827 wrote on 2024-08-19, 02:58:

Before I move to Tualatin modding, I need to get the coppermine CPU's working (may just settle for dual 1 GHz).

Another member on vogons tried Tualatins.

Just acquired a SM P6DGE

PC Hoarder Patrol wrote on 2024-08-20, 19:51:

Never had much luck dual running on either of my SM boards (P6DGU & P6DBU) even though I was using the 'better' slot 1 adapters (tried both ABit SlotKET !!! and MSI MS-6905 Master 2.x) though a single processor always ran without issue...gave up trying and switched to slot 1 procs.

Take it your board is a late enough version to have the uprated VRM chips (HIP6004BCB or HIP6004CB rather than HIP6004ACB) for both slots. Is your 2GB of memory buffered or unbuffered?

Hmm.... never considered that it may be a board limitation. Do we know on Slot 1 PIII's which pin is used for the shared proc bus? I need to do some more tinkering to see which combo works. It doesnt make sense that with the same silicon and just a different socket that functionality would be lost completly.

My board is the final revision made in 2001. 6004BCB chips. The celeron I tested was 1.5 V I believe and ran fine. The 2 GB is unbuff non ecc dual rank. Each of the eight banks detects the 256 MB size correctly. If only single rank chips however it does not work if still 512 MB sticks.

Alex827 wrote on 2024-08-21, 01:48:

PC Hoarder Patrol wrote on 2024-08-20, 19:51:

Never had much luck dual running on either of my SM boards (P6DGU & P6DBU) even though I was using the 'better' slot 1 adapters (tried both ABit SlotKET !!! and MSI MS-6905 Master 2.x) though a single processor always ran without issue...gave up trying and switched to slot 1 procs.

Hmm.... never considered that it may be a board limitation. Do we know on Slot 1 PIII's which pin is used for the shared proc bus? I need to do some more tinkering to see which combo works. It doesnt make sense that with the same silicon and just a different socket that functionality would be lost completly.

My board is the final revision made in 2001. 6004BCB chips. The celeron I tested was 1.5 V I believe and ran fine. The 2 GB is unbuff non ecc dual rank. Each of the eight banks detects the 256 MB size correctly. If only single rank chips however it does not work if still 512 MB sticks.

While not a P6DGE I have gotten my P6DGS to run two 1.1 GHz using Asus s370-DL slotkets.

Well thats encouraging. Ultimately I would like to take a crack at tualatins on this board but I know from reading other threads that it has not worked. Even with microcode errors which this 900 MHz cpu has, it boots fine so I think there was alot of wasted time there in other threads.

Upon further research it seems the resistor setup I am using may be the culprit. When I have some time I will expiriment with some different setups. Wouldn't make sense that it detects fine and almost works except for some memory issues. Pin N33 must be correct so I will work on the lines around it.