Exploit wrote on 2026-05-26, 11:25:
Whether the Amiga was king depended heavily on the genres you wanted to play. The Amiga dominated when it came to side-scrollers. However, if you wanted to play 3D simulations or strategy games, you were better off with a PC. Even back then, this was because the 286 was usually clocked significantly higher than the Amiga, and pixel rendering in EGA and VGA was more direct, which was a huge advantage for 3D games and their performance. I once saw Falcon running on a friend's Amiga 500; it didn't just stutter, it looked terrible too. My F-19 Stealth Fighter game offered way more detail on my 286, ran smoothly, and still looked better as a result, even though it was only released with maximum EGA support.
Compared to all the home computers of the time, the PC was the king of 3D gaming from the 286 era onward, provided it had an EGA card or better installed.
1990 wasn't 1987... meaning when Amiga 500 launched, as the lower tier of the Amiga range, the lower tier of 286 were around 8mhz and had EGA, and probably cost you three times as much. 386 machines were "out" but at this time, stratosphere priced. I doubt those 286 machines felt any faster than A500s at all. The "big box" A2000 got rapidly faster with a 14mhz 68020, then a 25-33 Mhz 68030 expansion in the two subsequent years. 1988 the packard bell 286 were shipping as EGA still, but 1989 they offered VGA. In my PB 286 from early 89 it was a switchable OTI 037 based card.... which maybe meant you chose by which monitor you bought. However, this low tier 286 was still at least double A500 price by now and despite the 16mhz CPU, probably wasn't a spectacular gamer, due to slow first gen VGA, with which all similar machines at the time would also be cursed. I don't have this machine running at the moment, developed a fault, the 1989 machine from when F16 combat pilot was new, but I can say that Test Drive 2 the Duel wasn't a compelling experience on it vs the Amiga 500, which is the only game I have played on both. TBH it needs more speed on both platforms.
But you can put a better VGA card in the 286! ... but you can put fast RAM in the A500 and that gains smoothness and performance... but you can use a faster 286... but you can use a 68020 sidecar accelerator on the Amiga.. It's hard to get an apples to apples when spending $$$$$ on the PC side is allowed but the Amiga remains static as in most of these arguments. Also somehow the top tier hardware on PC side gets compared to lowest tier Amiga.
Anyway. It depended a lot on location too, PC Games were not imported into UK in much degree in 286 era, or the slim 386 era really. Where PCs were for sale in the chain electronics stores, you'd maybe see a flight simulator, a golf game, shitty PC/XT card games, then possibly wing commander a little while after it gained momentum and fans, but that was it until early in the 1990s when the flood started. The UK problem is that everything arrived 6 months late, and at direct 1:1 US/pound conversion with a 20% markup too.. effectively doubling the price on everything for PC. So PC was decidedly not king in the UK, only began to get a bit of notice after Wing Commander and the full bulk of the clone market finally noticed the UK home market. The 87-90 titles were primarily experienced as budget releases which suddenly flooded in when the dam broke. I think windows 3.0 was a factor too, home users wanted a simple interface. In this late 80s early 90s scenario, Commodore managed to keep the UK prices reasonable on the Amiga, and it was selling well and appeared to have an actual game catalogue. It was however duking it out with numerous machines for the old 8bit space which had been a huge thing, Atari ST, Acorn Archimedes etc. The affordable PC niche was getting filled by Amstrad in the PC1512 and PC1640 lines but they mainly appealed to SOHO market at the time... and would have seemed like you didn't want to get rid of your C64 if you wanted to enjoy some games. Though there were some that were nice on them, finding them might have been an issue.
Unicorn herding operations are proceeding, but all the totes of hens teeth and barrels of rocking horse poop give them plenty of hiding spots.