I was never a big console gamer in the 8 an 16 bit era and still am not, although console games are becoming more PC-like and vice versa. I think the only old school console games I ever beat were Donkey Kong, Super Mario and Rygar.
The main reason I hated old-school console games were that some didn't really have any ending as such, they just sped up or repeated levels until you got sick of playing. Ones that did, like Contra, were so brutally difficult you practically had to cheat to beat them. And don't get me started on no save points.
My fondest memories of PC gaming were with games like Tie Fighter, X-Wing, Falcon 3.0, Doom, Quake, Descent, Diablo, Ultima 7, Pool of Radiance (and the countless SSI gold box games), Extreme Pinball, Command and Conquer and many more from the early and mid 90s. I like modern PC games but I just don't have time for a 100 or 200 hour epic RPG like I did when I was a teen, I've got too many other things to do. I also don't have time for crippling difficulty if I can't save, and random encounters are BS too (while I loved the Goldbox AD&D games at the time I'm not sure I could stomach the endless random encounters now).
I think everyone is going to have their own definition of what the "golden era" was for them, as well. For some people, that might be Nethack on an amber or green monochrome screen. Or maybe 16 color EGA games, or 320x200 256color 2d adventure games. PC gaming has such a long history that everyone is going to have their favorite era, as well as a favorite genre within that era.