Ozzuneoj wrote on 2024-05-05, 06:08:
I'm all for fixing things, and I know it has been a few weeks since your original post, but I would recommend returning it if you still can, then getting something else. Problems like these can take many hours to diagnose and in the end may not be fixable (bad GPU for example), so think about how much your time is worth.
+1
Those are indeed valid considerations.
Personally, I often try to fix just about everything I get, even stuff that isn't worth it. But not everyone likes doing those kinds of repairs (or has the time for it)... so if the seller has a return policy and the card wasn't listed for parts / as is, then let the seller know. It could also help the next person on Ebay, if for example, the seller takes a little more time to test the hardware next time before putting it for sale... or listing it as "untested" and willing to sell at a reasonable / reduced price.
Ozzuneoj wrote on 2024-05-05, 06:08:
A Radeon 9200 SE with a 64bit memory bus is practically the least desirable AGP card you could find, so unless you have a very specific need for this card (there shouldn't technically be any since these have no special features that other cards don't have) you could probably get something better that already works.
...
If you can find even a 64bit FX 5200 it would be a significant improvement in most cases...
I don't know about that.
In my own tests with my 9200 SE (64-bit) and a 64-bit FX5200, both are pretty terrible cards for any games past 2001 time frame, especially at resolutions above 800x600. The 128-bit FX5200 is only slightly better, but not by much, since nVidia didn't include the memory bandwidth features that are present in the FX5600 (and yes, I also have a 128-b FX5200 and a FX5600. 😉 )
For late 90's games, though, I find the 9200 SE and FX5200 to be just fine... well, at least if you don't mind gaming at 1024x768 max. Seems like both of these cards choke really badly with any higher resolutions. Perfect for a "high-end" Pentium II / low-end Pentium 3 build, IMO. 😀
Ozzuneoj wrote on 2024-05-05, 06:08:A Radeon 9550, 9600 or 9600 Pro (stay away from all 9xxx SE models or cards with only 2 memory chips) are fairly common and affordable and will run circles around 64bit cards.
+1
I think the Radeon 9550/9600 cards are really the best from the 9k series, particularly because they don't need much power and are easy to cool down, thus allowing them to be much more reliable compared to the 9700/9800 series. Just point a slow-turning fan towards your 9550/9600 card (at least the ones with a passive cooler) and it will run nice and cool. Moreover, Radeon 9550/9600 cards are still relatively easy to find and don't usually cost too much ($15-20 shipped, or cheaper if you're patient / find one at a time when people aren't looking for them.)
Ozzuneoj wrote on 2024-05-05, 06:08:Or, for a tiny bit better backward compatibility with 90s games at the cost of some performance, an FX 5500 (make sure it is actually 128bit) is a solid option.
FX5500 is essentially the same thing as the FX5200.