I didn't assume anything, you never flat out said this stuff was "FREE IN DALLAS!!!", did you? And I can tell you this much, Quoth would not have just dumped the stuff or sold it for profit, I know the guy personally, he is the one who showed me this forum, and I am the one who gave him the link to your thread, so really the only one going around making assumptions about anyone is you. For all you know he is a 3rd party trying to help get the stuff for a active member since he was local in your area. You really don't know, do you? Thats because your too busy nit picking people via your hidden qualifications list. Either way, you plan to give things away totally for free, advertise them as such.
You state you will have a list ready when there is interest, well, evidently due to what you said, there is clearly interest, and you did not, because of some form of incompetence plaguing you maybe? Regardless of that, if you had intentions to exclude certain members for any reason, you should also have stated the such instead of just stating "So I just want them to find good homes or parted out for future retro projects. I'm looking for locals, because I don't have the time to package and ship everything up.PM me if local + interested".
As far as I can see, from your initial post, Quoth qualified, being local, interested, and able to put the stuff to good use. But since you evidently have a hidden list of qualifications also, no actual detailed list of items, and don't know what the meaning of "private message" actually means, maybe you need to rethink the thread and reword it. Maybe it could read like the following :
"FREE OLD STUFF IN DALLAS"
"Got free old stuff. Local pick up only, it is free, I have no idea what all it is, I cant really say, I have no idea, maybe I will tell you later. Its free. Also, you have to have posted a bunch. If you didn't post a bunch you cant have my free stuff maybe, and I may never reply back to you evah. Did I mention I don't know what all I have yet? Also, be aware that any private messages you send to me I may never reply to directly, but I will freely and publicly post about, because I clearly don't know what private means. Did I mention its free?"
Either way, good luck with whatever this is you call a giveaway.