I've opened the battery up and I've been measuring the cells directly. it's rated for 14.8v and it has 8 cells in 4 pairs. Each pair is measuring 3.7v. Using a bunch of computer fans I was able to put it under a 1.5A load and the voltage didn't drop below 14.5v until I had been running them for quite some time. So the cells seemed ok, and it would charge and power the computer, but it would keep flashing the error lights. I desoldered the controller board in the battery in hopes that it might force a recalibration routine or something by losing all power, but I think I killed that board as it no longer will charge or power the computer (still good voltages though).
I'd buy a new battery, but all the reasonably priced ones are on eBay and are US shipping only. I'm in Canada so the ones available to me range from $50-150 with shipping. It's a bit steep for me to pay for a 20 year old laptop. Especially if I had a US address less than an hour away from me it would be 1/3rd-1/2 the price.