ssokolow wrote on 2024-02-25, 09:01:
Kahenraz wrote on 2024-02-25, 06:09:
FFXIhealer wrote on 2024-02-25, 05:05:
Today I went ahead and hooked up my Windows 98 gaming PC again. I recently got an original copy of Baldur's Gate 1 and wanted to install it, only to not be able to install due to the CD-ROM drive not being able to read certain files. I looked at the first disc and of course, it has lots of minor use scratches on it. All the discs do. I gotta take them to the local used game store tomorrow. Those guys have one of those CD polisher things that can make it look brand new again.
Disc error correction os actually very, very good. I've never had a disc error due to scratches on the plastic side. However, the label side hides the reflective layer underneath, and I have lost many discs due to extremely minor damage there.
It's not the scratches on the plastic but on the label, which often destroys a disk. And these cannot be repaired.
However, if a bit of grit got under the disc and then it was rotated, that's a very easy way to repairably kill the error correction by producing a scratch which follows the data track rather than cutting across it.
I have ripped so many music CDs over the years, with EAC in picky mode, to be able to give a simple test.
Hold the CD up to a light, and any pin points of light are regions of lost data-carrying layer. No amount of polishing can fix that.
But as for polishing out scratches, yes. I have had good results with a small amount of toothpaste, water and fingertip. You can feel the scratch with bare skin, and often just rounding off the edges of the tiny groove that is the scratch is enough for the CD to be read. It doesn't need to be brought back to a good shine, or a scratch polished out completely. Only polish/scuff as small an area as possible, going round in tight little circles and some back and forth, but not parallel for long: keep the CD moving too.
Maybe have a practice on some CD you don't care about, because this process does scuff the surface and it can look worse afterwards. I haven't ever made anything worse, but I guess going too far is also possible.
Using EAC in secure mode, dumping to a bin/cue, might also get data off the disk that otherwise one simple read errors on. No doubt there are other tools that do the same basic thing as EAC, re-reading sectors to make sure they are good.