VOGONS


First post, by sdz

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

Someone kindly gave me this card some time ago, and since I got the 5500 PCI working, I thought to give this one a shot.

It looks bad, but the PCB is in quite good shape:

20231216_143739.jpg
Filename
20231216_143739.jpg
File size
1.76 MiB
Views
990 views
File license
Public domain
20231216_143800.jpg
Filename
20231216_143800.jpg
File size
1.36 MiB
Views
990 views
File license
Public domain

First step is to give it a proper wash (IPA followed by soapy water) and see what we're working with:

20231216_174001.jpg
Filename
20231216_174001.jpg
File size
1.39 MiB
Views
990 views
File license
Public domain
20231216_174009.jpg
Filename
20231216_174009.jpg
File size
1.04 MiB
Views
990 views
File license
Public domain

Not that bad, next step is to clean any solder short (right VSA),add the missing 14.318MHz crystal for the master VSA, replace that "aftermarket" inductor, and add the missing RAM for the master VSA (the existing bottom one also needs resoldering as someone attempted to remove it at some point), add missing Q5/Q6, the two ceramic caps underneath the PMIC and various missing resistors on the card.

Reply 1 of 15, by sdz

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

Did all that and all that it does is preventing the system to boot.

20231216_184834.jpg
Filename
20231216_184834.jpg
File size
1.6 MiB
Views
968 views
File license
Public domain
20231216_184843.jpg
Filename
20231216_184843.jpg
File size
1.5 MiB
Views
968 views
File license
Public domain
20231216_185257.jpg
Filename
20231216_185257.jpg
File size
1.85 MiB
Views
968 views
File license
Public domain

Reply 2 of 15, by sdz

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

Power rails were Ok, measured all resistors on the card and they were OK, eventually I discovered that the flash had two data pins shorted together, and after fixing that:

20231216_200744.jpg
Filename
20231216_200744.jpg
File size
1.55 MiB
Views
957 views
File license
Public domain

Signs of life!

Reply 4 of 15, by sdz

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

Thanks!

There's still a bit of work to be done, but at the moment the card works in single VSA mode:

20231216_205220.jpg
Filename
20231216_205220.jpg
File size
1001.68 KiB
Views
935 views
File license
Public domain
20231216_205251.jpg
Filename
20231216_205251.jpg
File size
1.83 MiB
Views
935 views
File license
Public domain

Image is a bit wonky, but that's due to all those missing caps. It's also very bright, but that's normal for a V5 AGP/PCI on VGA output when the slave VSA is missing.
The master VSA and memory appear to work fine.
Time to add all the missing caps, VSA and 2 RAM ICs.

Reply 7 of 15, by sdz

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

I really couldn't wait until tomorrow, so I soldered the VSA.

20231216_224812.jpg
Filename
20231216_224812.jpg
File size
1.41 MiB
Views
877 views
File license
Public domain
20231216_224821.jpg
Filename
20231216_224821.jpg
File size
1.33 MiB
Views
877 views
File license
Public domain
20231216_223358.jpg
Filename
20231216_223358.jpg
File size
1.6 MiB
Views
877 views
File license
Public domain

Good news: both VSAs appear to be working fine
Bad news: VGA output is still too bright and extremely nosiy at some resolutions.

Reply 8 of 15, by weedeewee

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t

Very nice work. How do you clean the flux off? Which flux do you use ?

Right to repair is fundamental. You own it, you're allowed to fix it.
How To Ask Questions The Smart Way
Do not ask Why !
https://www.vogonswiki.com/index.php/Serial_port

Reply 9 of 15, by sdz

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

Thanks! I use Chipquik NC191.
For cleaning I soak the board in IPA for a bit, then brush it, and while it's still wet I wash it with hot water(tap) and a brush. After you properly dry it, it looks perfect (unlike the card in my pictures, I'll give it a proper clean after I get it working).

Sometimes I also ultrasonic clean them, but filling and emptying the big ultrasonic cleaner is a pain.

Reply 10 of 15, by sdz

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

Added cooling and ran some benchmarks:

Single VSA:

20231217_010759.jpg
Filename
20231217_010759.jpg
File size
210.63 KiB
Views
814 views
File license
Public domain

Dual VSA:

20231217_011459.jpg
Filename
20231217_011459.jpg
File size
185.42 KiB
Views
814 views
File license
Public domain

During the benchmark the image is perfect, just way too bright. I'll check the VSA databook, there has to be some voltage/current reference for the integrated RAMDAC.

Edit:
Well, fixed the brightness issue.

20231217_014157.jpg
Filename
20231217_014157.jpg
File size
1.7 MiB
Views
808 views
File license
Public domain

R543 should be 31R not 5R.

What remains in noise in 2D and 3D mode.
1024x768, 1920x1080 and 1600x1024 are perfect, but anything else has horizontal jitter.
Could also be the crappy Dell LCD.

Edit 2:
It's the crappy Dell. It does the same thing with other VSA cards, and the image looks perfect at any resolution through a VGA to HDMI converter.

So it looks like the card works fine and can be considered fixed. I'll manufacure a PCI bracket for it and replace the 2.54mm pin header & VGA connector, as someone previously melted them, as well as the power connector, which looks quite nasty.
Also need to add some heatsinks/fans.

Reply 14 of 15, by analog_programmer

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Impressive work. What equipment did you use for reballing and soldering of the missing VSA chip?

from СМ630 to Ryzen gen. 3
engineer's five pennies: this world goes south since everything's run by financiers and economists
this isn't voice chat, yet some people, overusing online communications, "talk" and "hear voices"