Reply 56860 of 56880, by Trashbytes
- Rank
- Oldbie
gerry wrote on 2025-05-28, 14:12:Mandrew wrote on 2025-05-28, 13:49:Bought a pack of lightscribe DVDs before they disappear like lightscribe CDs did.
Nice, my CD-R's number the same now as they did years ago. I never use them now that USB memory sticks are around, and yet i know that older magnetic and optical storage may even outlast solid state devices
Depends on the quality of the media to begin with, most of the recordable optical media was garbage tier quality even if it was sold at a premium and the reality is the dyes used don't last that long even in controlled storage. Now the pressed discs last a lot longer but they too eventually fail due to the pressed recording medium debonding from the plastic disc or it gets bit rot pin holes through out the recording layer.
So no optical media wont outlive NAND, suffice to say there isn't any consumer grade fail proof long term storage unless you are willing to pay through the roof for it. Spinning Rust is as close as we get to any form of cheap long term storage that is fairly reliable if stored in controlled conditions.
That said modern Nand has come quite a long way and the life time and storage retention these days is likely far longer than you will ever need the stored data for, it is however stupidly expensive for that task and not as reliable or cheap as Spinning rust is nor does Nand have the huge capacity of HDDs.
So really its pick whats best for the storage situation you find yourself in, but optical is a really bad idea.