gaffa2002 wrote on 2026-09-04, 21:45:
bad news is... the CRT monitor stopped working two days after installing the computer 🙁. It seems to be stuck in a cycle where it tries to turn on, then it "clicks" and turns off, then it turns on again, forever.
It may be a simple issue to fix, but as I have zero knowledge on monitor repairs and zero patience for learning it, I decided to simply store it back into the closet
What brand and model is it?
Power-cycling is a sign that the monitor power supply is trying to start but something is preventing from doing so. Could be a bad cap (startup cap or output filter cap) or could also be a shorted HOT (horizontal output transistor). In more rare cases, the flyback could cause this too. And in extremely rare cases (the Sony GDM-FW900, for example) can have the tube lose vacuum and cause the same symptoms. But in 99% of the cases, it's either failed caps, bad solder joints, shorted output rectifier or shorted HOT - all of which are parts that can still be found for purchase today and replaced.
gaffa2002 wrote on 2026-09-04, 21:45:
That situation made me think... is it worth to keep CRT monitors around like this? Yes, their picture and response times are great for low resolution stuff, but you never know when they are going to break, and if they do, how are you supposed to fix/replace it? Not to mention they are heavy and huge (the 15 inches CRT took the whole desk barely leaving space for a keyboard while the 17 inches CRT just takes a fraction of that).
To me, every CRT is worth keeping and trying to repair. Most aren't that hard to fix. In fact, one of my more serious electronics repairs when I was just starting up (I think I was 18 at the time) was my family's old 17" CRT monitor. I had extremely basic electronics knowledge back then and nothing more than a super-cheap $5 multimeter. Eventually, I managed to find the problem - an open 560 kOhm resistor (surely can't forget that value due to all the excitement of getting it fixed back then). I didn't have anything close, but I had 2x 300 kOhm resistors from a cheapo ATX PSU... so I put those and voila! : monitor came back to life and still works today.
gaffa2002 wrote on 2026-09-04, 21:45:
So what's your experience on the matter? Do you still have CRTs around (and how do you keep them working)? Or did you already replace them by a more modern alternative and never looked back?
I have about... I'm not even exactly sure anymore, but something like 15 CRT monitors roughly. Yes, they take up space, but not that much if you think creatively how to organize your storage. FWIW, the room I'm in right now has space only for a single bed, a small desk, and a dresser. However, I designed and built the desk by myself. It's in the corner of the room. The desktop is cut at an angle in such a way that it makes the desk much deeper than the room would allow otherwise. As such, I can fit not one, but two CRT (17") CRT monitors! Currently I only have one 17" CRT and a 19" 5:4 LCD (the LCD is for non-gaming use mostly.) . But I might switch the 17" CRT for a 21" when the colder months of the year come.
Obviously, the other CRTs I have are not stored in this room - they are actually spread across storages in 3 different places. But back when I used to live in the US, they were all in one place, and most of them in the closet of my room, which wasn't anything like a walk-in closet - just a regular/standard -sized clothes closet in the US. But again, I had custom shelves that I made specifically to store those CRTs (and a bunch of PC towers), which is how I was able to fit everything, along a few clothes in between too. 🤣
As for keeping them working - that depends on the brands.
Sony and Panasonic -made monitors almost always use high-quality Japanese capacitors, and even after 20+ years, many of them should still be OK (in my case, they are.) Anything else: YMMV. The late era CRTs (2001-2005) are more likely to be Samsung or LG -made... or even "noname" Chinese OEMs like Chunghwa or Chi Mei, using even cheaper parts and capacitors - now those are more likely to need a recap or other servicing earlier in their life. But all in all, CRTs tend to be somewhat well-made and reliable equipment. Actually, one of the more worrisome things I have come to realize lately wrt CRTs is that some of them use plastic that gets very brittle over time and could make the entire tube break away from the front bezel and have the CRT "de-neck" itself.
jakethompson1 wrote on 2026-09-04, 22:09:
I have CRTs but basically assume the tube is a wear item
Unless you leave the CRT running 24/7 and always with the same image to cause phosphor burn-in, don't expect the tube to age anywhere near as fast as the rest of the electronics in the monitor.
The switches and buttons/knobs are likely the first thing to fail - especially if the monitor was stored in a dusty or damp place. I even have some old LCD monitors affected by this, and their OSD sometimes go crazy randomly, making the monitor difficult or impossible to use. The last two LCDs that did this on me, I just disconnected their front buttons. Now I can't change their settings until I open and reconnect everything again... but so far, I haven't had the need to anyways.
The electrolytic capacitors is the next item that's likely to wear out - for both CRTs and old LCDs alike. But again, with CRTs, it depends on the brand / manufacturer - the cheaper ones are more likely to use very cheap caps. And curiously enough, in most cases, it won't be the big filter capacitors that fail in the power supply, but the smaller ones on the neck board, due to all of the heat from the tube there. So for anyone that has a CRT with rather poor image, it might be time to change the caps on the CRT neck board.
Shponglefan wrote on 2026-09-04, 23:39:
I've yet to find a satisfactory replacement for CRT monitors.
Same.
Well, modern LCDs (2019 and onwards) have come a long way when it comes to ghosting / image motion blur. But anything 2015 and older - nah, still can't complete with CRT for motion clarity.
I mean, at the end of the day, it's not a total deal breaker and I still do fire up the occasional game on a system connected to an LCD (and most of my LCDs are old 2006-2010 stuff, so lots of ghosting and motion blurring.) But then every time I fire up one of my CRTs, I'm instantly reminded of their much cleaner looking motion rendering as soon as I see the Windows XP logo loading... never mind if I fire up a game. The fact that I can clearly read road signs in 90's racing games with potato-quality textures vs. just barely able to make stuff out in newer racing games in "HD" resolutions with much higher textures on an LCD monitor is telling that CRTs aren't just a nostalgia experience, but do actually have much better motion clarity.
As for CRT "shaders" on LCDs monitors - fucking gimmicks for folks that either have never experienced a CRT or clearly don't have enough attention to detail to notice what they are not seeing... but that's just my probably-worthless opinion. 😉
Shponglefan wrote on 2026-09-04, 23:39:
They are dangerous too, so you have to properly discharge them if you ever open one up.
Actually, they are a lot less dangerous than working on a car. So no need to worry that much, really.
Discharging of the CRT anode is not necessary, unless one will be replacing the flyback transformer or completely taking out the mainboard(s) (and neck board.)
Discharging the main/bulk input electrolytic capacitors on the power supply (typically a large round can, rated for 400-450V and 120 to 330 uF) may be necessary. I've zapped myself on a few of these, and not in a CRT monitor, but on LCD TVs and a few PC PSUs (with APFC). It's painful but not lethal. As long as the power cord is unplugged from the wall, there's nothing in a CRT that can cause a lethal shock. But a painful one - sure! The more dangerous part is if you have your hand(s) or finger(s) close to any sharp objects, as the (usually unexpected) shock may trigger a reaction from you to pull back your hand quickly... and inadvertently cut yourself on something. I've never done that myself, but perhaps because I'm aware of this and always make sure there's space around me when working on these things. It's similar to when working on cars and trying to undo a rusty bolt: you always have to watch where your hand/fingers will go if the bolt breaks loose suddenly, as that can cause you serious bruising. Been there and done that many times as a kid when I was repairing my bikes.
Shponglefan wrote on 2026-09-04, 23:39:I've tried maybe a dozen or so older 4:3 LCDs.
You mean 5:4 LCDs. 😉
The only native 4:3 LCDs I'm aware of are either very old 15" with 1024x768 resolution or the 21" now-kinda-unobtanium ones with 1600x1200 resolution.
1280x1024 is a 5:4 resolution, so 17 and 19" "square" LCDs are not technically a correct replacement for 4:3 CRTs. Close enough, though.
What ticks me off more is when people try to run their old 17" beat-up CRT at 1280x1024. Not only is it the incorrect aspect ratio, but most 17" CRTs simply cannot display that high of a resolution and will always look pretty blurry. The cherry on top is that most also won't allow more than 60 Hz refresh rate (especially the cheaper ones), making for a flickery, blurry, and geometry-incorrect image. Ugh!
Shponglefan wrote on 2026-09-05, 01:07:
This entirely depends on where you live whether you can find deals.
I just looked on Ebay and NOS monitors are approaching five hundred dollars in most cases and hundreds more to ship (from U.S. to Canada). Add in taxes and potential other fees and I'm probably looking at an even thousand for one of those.
Indeed.
Where I am right now, you can still find working 17" CRTs for about 10 Euro locally and maybe add another 10-15 Euro if you need it shipped from some other place within the country. But they are starting to get rare even here. Unfortunately, finding anything higher than 17" is very rare, since Bulgaria wasn't exactly a rich country (and still isn't, but that's for another topic) when CRTs were mainstream, so very few people actually bought 19" and 21" CRTs.