VOGONS


Socket A: Nvidia vs Via - battle of the platforms!

Topic actions

Reply 80 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

13. Aqua mark 3 1600*1200 max
nforce2:

The attachment AM3-1600-NOSOUND_07012021_172359.jpg is no longer available
The attachment AM3-1600-NOSOUND-DETAILS_07012021_172403.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment AM3-1600-NoSound_29122020_175312.jpg is no longer available
The attachment AM3-1600-NoSound-DETAILS_29122020_175316.jpg is no longer available

Reply 81 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

14. Aqua mark 3 1600*1200 max + sound
nforce2:

The attachment AM3-1600-HSOUND_07012021_171742.jpg is no longer available
The attachment AM3-1600-HSOUND-DETAILS_07012021_171748.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment AM3-1600-HSound_29122020_174940.jpg is no longer available
The attachment AM3-1600--HSound-DETAILS_29122020_174944.jpg is no longer available

Even at this extreme resolution having hardware accelerated sound helps - nforce2 wins by 8%!

Reply 82 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

15. 3d mark 2000 default 1024*768 default
nforce2:

The attachment 2000_1024_09022017_194521.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2000_1024_03032018_155909.jpg is no longer available

I considered using 3d mark 99 however that test is more suited for a Pentium 3/ geforce 4 platform and not at this level of performance!

Last edited by nd22 on 2021-03-07, 14:35. Edited 2 times in total.

Reply 83 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

16. 3d mark 2000 1280*1024 max settings
nforce2:

The attachment 2000_1280_09022017_201505.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2000_1280_03032018_153611.jpg is no longer available
Last edited by nd22 on 2021-03-07, 14:35. Edited 1 time in total.

Reply 84 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

17. 3d mark 2000 1600*1200 max settings
nforce2:

The attachment 2000_1600_03012021_191524.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2000_1600_20102018_114140.jpg is no longer available

Nforce2 continues to lead in this DirectX7 benchmark at all resolutions!

Reply 85 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

18. 3d mark 2001 1024*768 default
nforce2:

The attachment 2001_1024_19122016_221831.jpg is no longer available

kt880

The attachment 2001_1024_05032018_154531.jpg is no longer available

In this DirectX benchmark which is considered one of the best system test for this era nforce2 wins by 6.69%. Anything over 5% I consider to be significant and have an impact in games.

Reply 86 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

19. 3d mark 2001 1280*1024 max settings:
nforce2:

The attachment 2001_1280_26122016_095632.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2001_1280_09022018_231800.jpg is no longer available

Reply 87 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

20. 3d mark 2001 1600*1200 max settings:
nforce2:

The attachment 2001_1600_03012021_184428.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2001_1600_11102018_101035.jpg is no longer available

Another test, another victory for nforce2!

Reply 88 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

21. 3d mark 2003 1024*768 default:
nforce2:

The attachment 2003_1024_20122016_065010.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2003_1024_03032018_080346.jpg is no longer available

It would seem that the video card is already the bottleneck in this test however, as you will see, the devil is in the details!

Reply 89 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

22. 3d mark 2003 1280*1024 max settings:
nforce2:

The attachment 2003_1280_28122016_165204.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2003_1280_02032018_162811.jpg is no longer available

Reply 90 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

23. 3d mark 2003 1600*1200 max settings
24. 3d mark 2003 1600*1200 max settings no sound test
25. 3d mark 2003 max settings 24 sounds test
nforce2:

The attachment 2003_1600_04012021_200047.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2003-1600_30122020_140709.jpg is no longer available

The score seems pretty close, only a difference of 0.67% which is meaningless in practice however 3d mark 2003 ONLY takes into account the game tests when calculating the score! However I decided that I will take into account the sound tests as a separate result! Please note that only AN7 can do the test with 60 sounds as KW7 can not perform it so I did not include that in the final score!
The difference between nforce2 and kt880 in the sound tests is absolutely HUGE: 16.13% with no sound and 34.09% with 24 sounds! And keep in mind that it was performed at 1600*1200!

Reply 91 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

26. 3d mark 2005 1024*768 default
nforce2:

The attachment 2005_1024_13022017_074331.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2005_1024_03032018_073416.jpg is no longer available

Reply 92 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

27. 3d mark 2005 1280*1024 max settings
nforce2:

The attachment 2005_1280_25022017_104530.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2005_1280_03032018_070225.jpg is no longer available

28. 3d mark 2005 1600*1200 max settings
nforce2:

The attachment 2005_1600_06012021_174358.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment 2005_1600_21102018_181957.jpg is no longer available

IMHO 3dmark 2005 is too powerful and too new for this system in general and the geforce 7800gs in particular. This is the first time KT880 scores a win at 1280*1024 resolution, very small but still a victory!

Reply 93 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

29. Tom 2d benchmark:
nforce2:

The attachment TOM2D_09012021_164623.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment TOM2D_03062018_083620.jpg is no longer available

In this test which was requested by swaaye VIA has serious problems in 2d and is strongly limiting the geforce 7800gs. Web browsing on the VIA system is much slower than on Nvidia; this could be a serious drawback for some users.

Reply 94 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

30. PC mark 2002 – CPU
31. PC mark 2002 – RAM
nforce2:

The attachment PCMark2002_07012021_170453.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment PcMark2002.jpg is no longer available

In the CPU test the difference is within the margin of error however in the RAM test 6.47% is significant and has effects in the "real world". FYI I also tested a KV7 - VIA KT600 system with the rest being the exact same hardware and software and there is practical no difference between it and the KT880 - dual channel does not bring any tangible improvements!

Reply 95 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

32. PC mark 2004 – CPU
33. PC mark 2004 – RAM
34. PC mark 2004 – GPU
nforce2:

The attachment PCMark2004_07012021_164055.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment PcMark2004.jpg is no longer available

nforce2 continues to march on adding 3 more wins to its tally! The total score should not be taken into account because the 2 system drives are NOT identical and in this particular benchmark I tested the SSD attached as a storage drive on the AN7 by mistake!

Last edited by nd22 on 2021-03-07, 16:39. Edited 1 time in total.

Reply 96 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

35. PC mark 2005 – CPU
36. PC mark 2005 – RAM
37. PC mark 2005 – GPU
nforce2:

The attachment PCMark2005_09022017_222411.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment PcMark2005.jpg is no longer available

Please note in this test the large difference between the GPU scores. VIA platform is limiting the video card.

Reply 97 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

I decided to publish all synthetic benchmarks first so let's jump to:
47. Super pi 1m
nforce2:

The attachment SuperPi_07012021_170801.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment SuperPI_31122020_113540.jpg is no longer available

For the first time VIA has an advantage over nforce2 - 5.76%!

48. Cine bench 2003
nforce2:

The attachment CB2003_09012021_175520.jpg is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment CB2003_31122020_164630.jpg is no longer available

Back to usual: nforce2 wins in Cinebench 2003.

Reply 98 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

The first of the game tested is Doom 3. This particular games is exceptionally GPU bound therefore I disabled AA in order to obtain meaningful results but all other settings are at the highest level. As with the other tests the first 2 runs have been discarded and the third has been saved.
44. Doom 3 1024*768 max settings - no AA
nforce2:

The attachment image021.png is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment image007.png is no longer available

Reply 99 of 819, by nd22

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

45. Doom 3 no AA 1280*1024 max settings no AA
nforce2:

The attachment image019.png is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment image005.png is no longer available

46. Doom 3 no AA 1600*1200 max settings no AA
nforce2:

The attachment image017.png is no longer available

kt880:

The attachment image009.png is no longer available

First game test, first win for nforce2!