VOGONS


Mechwarrior 2 Decomp/Recomp

Topic actions

Reply 100 of 114, by Mikeyy00

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
myne wrote on 2026-11-14, 14:58:
Didn't get into the game yet. Mercs +Titanium files. Something seems screwy with mech customisation. Pretty sure even the shit […]
Show full quote

Didn't get into the game yet.
Mercs +Titanium files.
Something seems screwy with mech customisation. Pretty sure even the shit box commando can go to 9 armor on the head.
Mouse is a bit floaty
F keys mostly don't work as usual. F5 I think it was, did. The rest didn't.
cannot read bwd id 1490

Sorry, is this Mercs acting busted?

Reply 101 of 114, by KHORG

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie

I've just fired up the MW2 recomp, some things I've noticed when comparing it to the DOS 1.1 version which I have running through dosbox:

  • The grey MW2 menu cursor seems to have been replaced with a default windows cursor?
  • If you click on the Archive Holoprojector, it cuts to a zoomed-in view of the "projection" animation, then cuts back again to the normal view. Usually it just runs this animation in the distance of the hall, then cuts to the display.
  • There's some kind of slim vertical red line on enemy target brackets when selecting enemies.
  • Using Z to zoom in immediately causes the 3D cockpit outline to be culled by the renderer. It only re-appears when you shift-zoom all the way back to default.
  • Funnily CTRL-Z has carried over the buggy behaviour from the original game. It was meant to reset your zoom, but in original MW2 had a bad tendency to bounce the camera around.
  • The Satellite View doesn't show a top-down view of your own mech, it also incorrectly carries over enemy targetting brackets from first-person view and puts them in random places.
  • The floatiness of the original targetting reticle seems to be gone. Now if you let go of a key it immediately stops.
  • There's a big frame-rate drop when turning on or off light amplification. Image enhancement is fine.
  • The turrets on wolf level 2 don't seem to be able to turn. They just start blazing away in whatever direction they were originally pointing at.
  • There are various 3D hill objects missing from wolf mission 2. They should be visible as soon as you drop in.
  • When you arrive at a Nav point, two things should happen; 1) the unselected nav icon on your radar for that location should dim slightly (this works) 2) the text for "Nav Alpha" in the bottom left of the screen should also dim (and stay dimmed even if you change to a different waypoint then back) to indicate you've already been there, this doesn't occur.
  • Satellite View doesn't show enemy buildings in red outline (particularly on Wolf 3), it just shows them as black outline.
  • Satellite View also doesn't show the enemy fire in yellow. Usually you can see incoming PPCs, lasers and missiles.
  • On your targetting MFD, (bottom left display) the helicopter on wolf mission 3 should show as a blue fuselage and a red circle for the blade above it, but only the fuselage appears in the MFD view.
  • The NPC vehicle (automobile) driving around on wolf 3 isn't there.
  • On wolf mission 3, the red or green roof-lights on the taller building aren't there. Usually they should fade in and out, being either green or red.
  • In Satellite View, 2D sprites like fires should appear as little fire images, but currently they only show as a black line.
  • In original or recomp MW2, when you're shooting the ground, there is a black puff of dust. However in the original game there is a semi-bug when shooting buildings, static vehicles etc. In this case it should show a weapon splash effect, but it didn't always, sometimes the angle on the building/object would be wrong and you would instead see a black puff of dust and wonder if you were hitting it. However, in the recomp it only shows the black puff of dush when shooting buildings/objects, not the weapon splashes.
  • F5-F6-F7-F8 should act as alternates for the right MFD, e.g. if you press F8, you can press F5 to cycle back to the default mode. This doesn't work in the recomp, instead.... F5 and F6 are linked to each other, F7 and F8 are also linked, you need to press F8 again before you can get back to F5 and all sorts of UXUI that makes my head hurt.
  • If you look down (CTRL up/down) in the Mad Dog cockpit, you can see the backs of the Mad Dog legs, which you shouldn't be able to. I haven't checked all the other mechs for this.
  • Wolf Trial 1, the first two mechs don't move until you're looking down on them from a hill, they should be moving towards you at about the 10 second mark (which is a couple of seconds after you're fully online).
  • Wolf Trial 1 again, the second two mechs should start moving towards you as soon as you destroy the Engagement Sphere. Instead the first only moves towards you when attacked, and his starmate follows him around like an AI with no attack orders.
  • Some of the original 'flight sim' controls seem to have changed? In the original game, UP aimed down and CTRL-UP looked down. In the recomp, UP aims down and CTRL-DOWN (not CTRL-UP) looks down.
  • Sable Flame is all kinds of busted. The Sensor Array Dome is opaque when it should be transparent and you should be able to see into it and through it.
  • Also on Sable Flame, the 2nd Mech group should power up after you destroy the 1st, and the 3rd should power up after you destroy the 2nd. But the the 2nd and 3rd come online at the same time after the 1st is destroyed. Also weirdly the 1st group doesn't appear on radar after betty announces Enemy Powerup Detected.
  • Still on Sable Flame, the third group of mechs get distracted by a Wolf dropship which is flying around above them and instead run around shooting at that.
  • Still on Sable Flame, the Falcon dropships have a Wolf logo on the side (I checked in the original, it's definitely the Falcon logo there).
  • Dropships seem not to be able to turn/aim their turret on top, so like the current problem with static turrets, they just shoot straight forwards when they see something.
  • Still on Sable Flame, there is some weird switcheroo going on with which mechs are in which group, it should be 3-2-2. But instead it's 2-2-3? One of the Mad Dog's from the first star ends up in the last and I feel like the Stormcrow changed group also.

That said, various niche functionality does work, e.g. Ammo dumping is fine, as is Autopilot. The dusk effect that kicks in at the start of Wolf 3 is identical to the original game.

I'll have a further look. It would be nice to be able to get it to optionally use cd audio, rather than ripped tracks.

Last edited by KHORG on 2026-11-17, 08:31. Edited 18 times in total.

Reply 102 of 114, by myne

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Mikeyy00 wrote on 2026-11-14, 19:23:
myne wrote on 2026-11-14, 14:58:
Didn't get into the game yet. Mercs +Titanium files. Something seems screwy with mech customisation. Pretty sure even the shit […]
Show full quote

Didn't get into the game yet.
Mercs +Titanium files.
Something seems screwy with mech customisation. Pretty sure even the shit box commando can go to 9 armor on the head.
Mouse is a bit floaty
F keys mostly don't work as usual. F5 I think it was, did. The rest didn't.
cannot read bwd id 1490

Sorry, is this Mercs acting busted?

Yes.
First mission : training patrol failed to load with cannot read bwd is 1490

I built:
Convert old ASUS ASC boardviews to KICAD PCB!
Re: A comprehensive guide to install and play MechWarrior 2 on new versions on Windows.
Dos+Windows 3.11+tcp+vbe_svga auto-install iso template
Script to backup Win9x\ME drivers from a working install
Re: The thing no one asked for: KICAD 440bx reference schematic

Reply 103 of 114, by Deffnator

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

i found another visual bug with the navcam when using satellite link, it is the same i reported earlier

The attachment 16730847756444237824_20261113130226_1.png is no longer available

Reply 104 of 114, by Mikeyy00

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
KHORG wrote on 2026-11-15, 02:50:
I've just fired up the MW2 recomp, some things I've noticed when comparing it to the DOS 1.1 version which I have running throug […]
Show full quote

I've just fired up the MW2 recomp, some things I've noticed when comparing it to the DOS 1.1 version which I have running through dosbox:

  • The grey MW2 menu cursor seems to have been replaced with a default windows cursor?
  • If you click on the Archive Holoprojector, it cuts to a zoomed-in view of the "projection" animation, then cuts back again to the normal view. Usually it just runs this animation in the distance of the hall, then cuts to the display.
  • There's some kind of slim vertical red line on enemy target brackets when selecting enemies.
  • Using Z to zoom in immediately causes the 3D cockpit outline to be culled by the renderer. It only re-appears when you shift-zoom all the way back to default.
  • Funnily CTRL-Z has carried over the buggy behaviour from the original game. It was meant to reset your zoom, but in original MW2 had a bad tendency to bounce the camera around.
  • The Satellite View doesn't show a top-down view of your own mech, it also incorrectly carries over enemy targetting brackets from first-person view and puts them in random places.
  • The floatiness of the original targetting reticle seems to be gone. Now if you let go of a key it immediately stops.
  • There's a big frame-rate drop when turning on or off light amplification. Image enhancement is fine.
  • The turrets on wolf level 2 don't seem to be able to turn. They just start blazing away in whatever direction they were originally pointing at.
  • There are various 3D hill objects missing from wolf mission 2. They should be visible as soon as you drop in.
  • When you arrive at a Nav point, two things should happen; 1) the unselected nav icon on your radar for that location should dim slightly (this works) 2) the text for "Nav Alpha" in the bottom left of the screen should also dim (and stay dimmed even if you change to a different waypoint then back) to indicate you've already been there, this doesn't occur.
  • Satellite View doesn't show enemy buildings in red outline (particularly on Wolf 3), it just shows them as black outline.
  • Satellite View also doesn't show the enemy fire in yellow. Usually you can see incoming PPCs, lasers and missiles.
  • On your targetting MFD, (bottom left display) the helicopter on wolf mission 3 should show as a blue fuselage and a red circle for the blade above it, but only the fuselage appears in the MFD view.
  • The NPC vehicle (automobile) driving around on wolf 3 isn't there.
  • On wolf mission 3, the red or green roof-lights on the taller building aren't there. Usually they should fade in and out, being either green or red.
  • In Satellite View, 2D sprites like fires should appear as little fire images, but currently they only show as a black line.
  • In original or recomp MW2, when you're shooting the ground, there is a black puff of dust. However in the original game there is a semi-bug when shooting buildings, static vehicles etc. In this case it should show a weapon splash effect, but it didn't always, sometimes the angle on the building/object would be wrong and you would instead see a black puff of dust and wonder if you were hitting it. However, in the recomp it only shows the black puff of dush when shooting buildings/objects, not the weapon splashes.
  • F5-F6-F7-F8 should act as alternates for the right MFD, e.g. if you press F8, you can press F5 to cycle back to the default mode. This doesn't work in the recomp, instead.... F5 and F6 are linked to each other, F7 and F8 are also linked, you need to press F8 again before you can get back to F5 and all sorts of UXUI that makes my head hurt.
  • If you look down (CTRL up/down) in the Mad Dog cockpit, you can see the backs of the Mad Dog legs, which you shouldn't be able to. I haven't checked all the other mechs for this.
  • Wolf Trial 1, the first two mechs don't move until you're looking down on them from a hill, they should be moving towards you at about the 10 second mark (which is a couple of seconds after you're fully online).
  • Wolf Trial 1 again, the second two mechs should start moving towards you as soon as you destroy the Engagement Sphere. Instead the first only moves towards you when attacked, and his starmate follows him around like an AI with no attack orders.
  • Some of the original 'flight sim' controls seem to have changed? In the original game, UP aimed down and CTRL-UP looked down. In the recomp, UP aims down and CTRL-DOWN (not CTRL-UP) looks down.
  • Sable Flame is all kinds of busted. The Sensor Array Dome is opaque when it should be transparent and you should be able to see into it and through it.
  • Also on Sable Flame, the 2nd Mech group should power up after you destroy the 1st, and the 3rd should power up after you destroy the 2nd. But the the 2nd and 3rd come online at the same time after the 1st is destroyed. Also weirdly the 1st group doesn't appear on radar after betty announces Enemy Powerup Detected.
  • Still on Sable Flame, the third group of mechs get distracted by a Wolf dropship which is flying around above them and instead run around shooting at that.
  • Still on Sable Flame, the Falcon dropships have a Wolf logo on the side (I checked in the original, it's definitely the Falcon logo there).
  • Dropships seem not to be able to turn/aim their turret on top, so like the current problem with static turrets, they just shoot straight forwards when they see something.
  • Still on Sable Flame, there is some weird switcheroo going on with which mechs are in which group, it should be 3-2-3. But instead it's 2-2-4? One of the Mad Dog's from the first star ends up in the last and I feel like the Stormcrow changed group also.

That said, various niche functionality does work, e.g. Ammo dumping is fine, as is Autopilot. The dusk effect that kicks in at the start of Wolf 3 is identical to the original game.

I'll have a further look. It would be nice to be able to get it to optionally use cd audio, rather than ripped tracks.

Wicked feedback. Thank you. I'll see if I can bang a bunch of these out.

100% I can bring back OG CD Audio support.

Reply 105 of 114, by Mikeyy00

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
Deffnator wrote on 2026-11-15, 12:32:

i found another visual bug with the navcam when using satellite link, it is the same i reported earlier

The attachment 16730847756444237824_20261113130226_1.png is no longer available

I'll tackle this after the laundry list above.

Reply 106 of 114, by Mikeyy00

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
myne wrote on 2026-11-15, 03:02:
Mikeyy00 wrote on 2026-11-14, 19:23:
myne wrote on 2026-11-14, 14:58:
Didn't get into the game yet. Mercs +Titanium files. Something seems screwy with mech customisation. Pretty sure even the shit […]
Show full quote

Didn't get into the game yet.
Mercs +Titanium files.
Something seems screwy with mech customisation. Pretty sure even the shit box commando can go to 9 armor on the head.
Mouse is a bit floaty
F keys mostly don't work as usual. F5 I think it was, did. The rest didn't.
cannot read bwd id 1490

Sorry, is this Mercs acting busted?

Yes.
First mission : training patrol failed to load with cannot read bwd is 1490

Try the build just posted, let me know if that solves the issue.(v.1.2.3)

Reply 107 of 114, by Mikeyy00

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
Mikeyy00 wrote on Yesterday, 01:24:
KHORG wrote on 2026-11-15, 02:50:
I've just fired up the MW2 recomp, some things I've noticed when comparing it to the DOS 1.1 version which I have running throug […]
Show full quote

I've just fired up the MW2 recomp, some things I've noticed when comparing it to the DOS 1.1 version which I have running through dosbox:

  • The grey MW2 menu cursor seems to have been replaced with a default windows cursor?
  • If you click on the Archive Holoprojector, it cuts to a zoomed-in view of the "projection" animation, then cuts back again to the normal view. Usually it just runs this animation in the distance of the hall, then cuts to the display.
  • There's some kind of slim vertical red line on enemy target brackets when selecting enemies.
  • Using Z to zoom in immediately causes the 3D cockpit outline to be culled by the renderer. It only re-appears when you shift-zoom all the way back to default.
  • Funnily CTRL-Z has carried over the buggy behaviour from the original game. It was meant to reset your zoom, but in original MW2 had a bad tendency to bounce the camera around.
  • The Satellite View doesn't show a top-down view of your own mech, it also incorrectly carries over enemy targetting brackets from first-person view and puts them in random places.
  • The floatiness of the original targetting reticle seems to be gone. Now if you let go of a key it immediately stops.
  • There's a big frame-rate drop when turning on or off light amplification. Image enhancement is fine.
  • The turrets on wolf level 2 don't seem to be able to turn. They just start blazing away in whatever direction they were originally pointing at.
  • There are various 3D hill objects missing from wolf mission 2. They should be visible as soon as you drop in.
  • When you arrive at a Nav point, two things should happen; 1) the unselected nav icon on your radar for that location should dim slightly (this works) 2) the text for "Nav Alpha" in the bottom left of the screen should also dim (and stay dimmed even if you change to a different waypoint then back) to indicate you've already been there, this doesn't occur.
  • Satellite View doesn't show enemy buildings in red outline (particularly on Wolf 3), it just shows them as black outline.
  • Satellite View also doesn't show the enemy fire in yellow. Usually you can see incoming PPCs, lasers and missiles.
  • On your targetting MFD, (bottom left display) the helicopter on wolf mission 3 should show as a blue fuselage and a red circle for the blade above it, but only the fuselage appears in the MFD view.
  • The NPC vehicle (automobile) driving around on wolf 3 isn't there.
  • On wolf mission 3, the red or green roof-lights on the taller building aren't there. Usually they should fade in and out, being either green or red.
  • In Satellite View, 2D sprites like fires should appear as little fire images, but currently they only show as a black line.
  • In original or recomp MW2, when you're shooting the ground, there is a black puff of dust. However in the original game there is a semi-bug when shooting buildings, static vehicles etc. In this case it should show a weapon splash effect, but it didn't always, sometimes the angle on the building/object would be wrong and you would instead see a black puff of dust and wonder if you were hitting it. However, in the recomp it only shows the black puff of dush when shooting buildings/objects, not the weapon splashes.
  • F5-F6-F7-F8 should act as alternates for the right MFD, e.g. if you press F8, you can press F5 to cycle back to the default mode. This doesn't work in the recomp, instead.... F5 and F6 are linked to each other, F7 and F8 are also linked, you need to press F8 again before you can get back to F5 and all sorts of UXUI that makes my head hurt.
  • If you look down (CTRL up/down) in the Mad Dog cockpit, you can see the backs of the Mad Dog legs, which you shouldn't be able to. I haven't checked all the other mechs for this.
  • Wolf Trial 1, the first two mechs don't move until you're looking down on them from a hill, they should be moving towards you at about the 10 second mark (which is a couple of seconds after you're fully online).
  • Wolf Trial 1 again, the second two mechs should start moving towards you as soon as you destroy the Engagement Sphere. Instead the first only moves towards you when attacked, and his starmate follows him around like an AI with no attack orders.
  • Some of the original 'flight sim' controls seem to have changed? In the original game, UP aimed down and CTRL-UP looked down. In the recomp, UP aims down and CTRL-DOWN (not CTRL-UP) looks down.
  • Sable Flame is all kinds of busted. The Sensor Array Dome is opaque when it should be transparent and you should be able to see into it and through it.
  • Also on Sable Flame, the 2nd Mech group should power up after you destroy the 1st, and the 3rd should power up after you destroy the 2nd. But the the 2nd and 3rd come online at the same time after the 1st is destroyed. Also weirdly the 1st group doesn't appear on radar after betty announces Enemy Powerup Detected.
  • Still on Sable Flame, the third group of mechs get distracted by a Wolf dropship which is flying around above them and instead run around shooting at that.
  • Still on Sable Flame, the Falcon dropships have a Wolf logo on the side (I checked in the original, it's definitely the Falcon logo there).
  • Dropships seem not to be able to turn/aim their turret on top, so like the current problem with static turrets, they just shoot straight forwards when they see something.
  • Still on Sable Flame, there is some weird switcheroo going on with which mechs are in which group, it should be 3-2-3. But instead it's 2-2-4? One of the Mad Dog's from the first star ends up in the last and I feel like the Stormcrow changed group also.

That said, various niche functionality does work, e.g. Ammo dumping is fine, as is Autopilot. The dusk effect that kicks in at the start of Wolf 3 is identical to the original game.

I'll have a further look. It would be nice to be able to get it to optionally use cd audio, rather than ripped tracks.

Wicked feedback. Thank you. I'll see if I can bang a bunch of these out.

100% I can bring back OG CD Audio support.

Most of these are fixed in 1.1.24.. CD audio can be played from BIN/CUE now too. I'll have physical disc CD audio on the next build.

Reply 108 of 114, by KHORG

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
Mikeyy00 wrote on Yesterday, 02:59:
Mikeyy00 wrote on Yesterday, 01:24:
KHORG wrote on 2026-11-15, 02:50:
I've just fired up the MW2 recomp, some things I've noticed when comparing it to the DOS 1.1 version which I have running throug […]
Show full quote

I've just fired up the MW2 recomp, some things I've noticed when comparing it to the DOS 1.1 version which I have running through dosbox:

  • The grey MW2 menu cursor seems to have been replaced with a default windows cursor?
  • If you click on the Archive Holoprojector, it cuts to a zoomed-in view of the "projection" animation, then cuts back again to the normal view. Usually it just runs this animation in the distance of the hall, then cuts to the display.
  • There's some kind of slim vertical red line on enemy target brackets when selecting enemies.
  • Using Z to zoom in immediately causes the 3D cockpit outline to be culled by the renderer. It only re-appears when you shift-zoom all the way back to default.
  • Funnily CTRL-Z has carried over the buggy behaviour from the original game. It was meant to reset your zoom, but in original MW2 had a bad tendency to bounce the camera around.
  • The Satellite View doesn't show a top-down view of your own mech, it also incorrectly carries over enemy targetting brackets from first-person view and puts them in random places.
  • The floatiness of the original targetting reticle seems to be gone. Now if you let go of a key it immediately stops.
  • There's a big frame-rate drop when turning on or off light amplification. Image enhancement is fine.
  • The turrets on wolf level 2 don't seem to be able to turn. They just start blazing away in whatever direction they were originally pointing at.
  • There are various 3D hill objects missing from wolf mission 2. They should be visible as soon as you drop in.
  • When you arrive at a Nav point, two things should happen; 1) the unselected nav icon on your radar for that location should dim slightly (this works) 2) the text for "Nav Alpha" in the bottom left of the screen should also dim (and stay dimmed even if you change to a different waypoint then back) to indicate you've already been there, this doesn't occur.
  • Satellite View doesn't show enemy buildings in red outline (particularly on Wolf 3), it just shows them as black outline.
  • Satellite View also doesn't show the enemy fire in yellow. Usually you can see incoming PPCs, lasers and missiles.
  • On your targetting MFD, (bottom left display) the helicopter on wolf mission 3 should show as a blue fuselage and a red circle for the blade above it, but only the fuselage appears in the MFD view.
  • The NPC vehicle (automobile) driving around on wolf 3 isn't there.
  • On wolf mission 3, the red or green roof-lights on the taller building aren't there. Usually they should fade in and out, being either green or red.
  • In Satellite View, 2D sprites like fires should appear as little fire images, but currently they only show as a black line.
  • In original or recomp MW2, when you're shooting the ground, there is a black puff of dust. However in the original game there is a semi-bug when shooting buildings, static vehicles etc. In this case it should show a weapon splash effect, but it didn't always, sometimes the angle on the building/object would be wrong and you would instead see a black puff of dust and wonder if you were hitting it. However, in the recomp it only shows the black puff of dush when shooting buildings/objects, not the weapon splashes.
  • F5-F6-F7-F8 should act as alternates for the right MFD, e.g. if you press F8, you can press F5 to cycle back to the default mode. This doesn't work in the recomp, instead.... F5 and F6 are linked to each other, F7 and F8 are also linked, you need to press F8 again before you can get back to F5 and all sorts of UXUI that makes my head hurt.
  • If you look down (CTRL up/down) in the Mad Dog cockpit, you can see the backs of the Mad Dog legs, which you shouldn't be able to. I haven't checked all the other mechs for this.
  • Wolf Trial 1, the first two mechs don't move until you're looking down on them from a hill, they should be moving towards you at about the 10 second mark (which is a couple of seconds after you're fully online).
  • Wolf Trial 1 again, the second two mechs should start moving towards you as soon as you destroy the Engagement Sphere. Instead the first only moves towards you when attacked, and his starmate follows him around like an AI with no attack orders.
  • Some of the original 'flight sim' controls seem to have changed? In the original game, UP aimed down and CTRL-UP looked down. In the recomp, UP aims down and CTRL-DOWN (not CTRL-UP) looks down.
  • Sable Flame is all kinds of busted. The Sensor Array Dome is opaque when it should be transparent and you should be able to see into it and through it.
  • Also on Sable Flame, the 2nd Mech group should power up after you destroy the 1st, and the 3rd should power up after you destroy the 2nd. But the the 2nd and 3rd come online at the same time after the 1st is destroyed. Also weirdly the 1st group doesn't appear on radar after betty announces Enemy Powerup Detected.
  • Still on Sable Flame, the third group of mechs get distracted by a Wolf dropship which is flying around above them and instead run around shooting at that.
  • Still on Sable Flame, the Falcon dropships have a Wolf logo on the side (I checked in the original, it's definitely the Falcon logo there).
  • Dropships seem not to be able to turn/aim their turret on top, so like the current problem with static turrets, they just shoot straight forwards when they see something.
  • Still on Sable Flame, there is some weird switcheroo going on with which mechs are in which group, it should be 3-2-3. But instead it's 2-2-4? One of the Mad Dog's from the first star ends up in the last and I feel like the Stormcrow changed group also.

That said, various niche functionality does work, e.g. Ammo dumping is fine, as is Autopilot. The dusk effect that kicks in at the start of Wolf 3 is identical to the original game.

I'll have a further look. It would be nice to be able to get it to optionally use cd audio, rather than ripped tracks.

Wicked feedback. Thank you. I'll see if I can bang a bunch of these out.

100% I can bring back OG CD Audio support.

Most of these are fixed in 1.1.24.. CD audio can be played from BIN/CUE now too. I'll have physical disc CD audio on the next build.

Thrown into Claude and fixed, or something else? I downloaded 1.1.24 and had a look in the first 3 wolf missions, but all 14 of the bugs I checked were still there.
A couple of the above bugs might need screenshots from me to better show what should be occurring. But halfway through it was starting to feel like my actual work, so I got lazy.

Reply 109 of 114, by KHORG

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie

On 1.1.24

  • Changing from Standard to Endo-Steel in the mechlab gives you extra criticals to assign, but doesn't free up weight.
  • Burning Chrome has gained some kind of strange 3D object, it's like a disassembled dropship (but your dropship, the enemy dropship and the solar array are all there and intact). You can walk through it and shoot through it.
  • Four of the turrets on Burning Chrome have changed position, I think one of them might be outside the icewall (e.g. outside the normal mission boundary).
  • My mech got shot up on Burning Chrome and 3 lasers were destroyed, so turned black in the weapon-selection. One turned red though, as though it had just been fired. It was destroyed, and couldn't be selected. I feel like this was an occasional bug in the original game also.

Reply 110 of 114, by Mikeyy00

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
KHORG wrote on Yesterday, 10:54:
On 1.1.24 […]
Show full quote

On 1.1.24

  • Changing from Standard to Endo-Steel in the mechlab gives you extra criticals to assign, but doesn't free up weight.
  • Burning Chrome has gained some kind of strange 3D object, it's like a disassembled dropship (but your dropship, the enemy dropship and the solar array are all there and intact). You can walk through it and shoot through it.
  • Four of the turrets on Burning Chrome have changed position, I think one of them might be outside the icewall (e.g. outside the normal mission boundary).
  • My mech got shot up on Burning Chrome and 3 lasers were destroyed, so turned black in the weapon-selection. One turned red though, as though it had just been fired. It was destroyed, and couldn't be selected. I feel like this was an occasional bug in the original game also.

These are fixed in 1.1.26.

Yes, firing stuff into Claude. I did give it shit though for not re-evaluating all of the missions for similar bugs, its doing another pass now.

While I'd like to pretend I know programming to look at the code, I don't. So, yeah I need to fire it into an LLM to fix.

I really appriciate the feedback on bugs though, you've clearly played the crap out of it to catch so many. I'll keep prodding it to fix what it can.

Edit, it's done it's pass. 1.1.27 is up.

Also, it can only verify the port against the DOS version. There's no easy way for the LLM to run Titanium so it can't like for like there. vs. DOS where it spins up a Dosbox instance to compare the port against. (gist is, expect more bugs when using Titanium).

Reply 111 of 114, by gerwin

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t

I just did a search and there is competition on the horizon.
https://combatace.com/forums/topic/101646-gam … -classic-games/
Not to discourage you. But no harm in being realistic.
Personally, I will eventually pick a project that does a 100% DOS binary matching as a side repo, and an enhanced ported repo next to it. If that luxury exist. I predict it soon will, for DOS things in general.

--> ISA Soundcard Overview // Doom MBF 2.04 // SetMul

Reply 112 of 114, by Deffnator

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
gerwin wrote on Yesterday, 17:43:
I just did a search and there is competition on the horizon. https://combatace.com/forums/topic/101646-gam … -classic-games/ No […]
Show full quote

I just did a search and there is competition on the horizon.
https://combatace.com/forums/topic/101646-gam … -classic-games/
Not to discourage you. But no harm in being realistic.
Personally, I will eventually pick a project that does a 100% DOS binary matching as a side repo, and an enhanced ported repo next to it. If that luxury exist. I predict it soon will, for DOS things in general.

I want Strike Eagle III and Fleet Defender, id kill for both as mainly 1942 TAW Gold

Reply 113 of 114, by KHORG

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie

I've struck out above what I've re-tested and found fixed. I haven't re-tested Burning Chrome yet.
1.1.28

  • Satellite View shows your own mech now, but if you walk over a 3D hill, satellite view renders the wireframe of your mech behind (underneath) the hill, not in front (on top) of the hill.
  • If you go straight to Nav Beta on Wolf mission 2, the enemy Stormcrow there comes online, but doesn't attack you, it just patrols (checked DOS, it behaves correctly there).
  • Similarly, the same Falcon Stormcrow has a Wolf insignia decal applied to it.
  • The Archive Holoprojector animation has been fixed, but the same problem is still present with the Mission Briefing projection from the Ready Room.
  • The Archive Holoprojector should play a "bing" noise when first activated, along with playing a voice sound "accessing".
  • There should be an ambient noise playing in the Clan Hall.
  • There should be an ambient noise playing in the Cadet Training room.
  • Mechs are changing to the first low-detail LOD at about 115m-120. In the DOS version of the game, this change occurs I believe outside 1000m.
  • Mechs look like they are changing to the second low-detail LOD at about 350m. I'm unsure where this occurs in DOS, but my guess is outside 1500m on maps with visibility that far out.
  • On Wolf Trial 1, Star2-Mech1 and Star2-Mech2 shouldn't respond to "nearby" weapons fire. E.g. you can fire an LRM over their heads and they don't wake up, but they will individually respond and attack if hit. However in the recomp, they will go into attack mode if there is weapons fire (e.g. stray LRMs overhead) too close to them.
  • On Sable Flame, the enemy Dropships(x2) should come online at about 1KM with no "Enemy Powerup Detected" notification. But instead they are powering up at 500m with the notification played.

Did you mention earlier there was an issue with the Radar you were aware of? It's slightly the wrong colour and is showing the FOV angle as the wrong shape.

I am interested in how some of these level/world problems came about and are being resolved. I don't know if Claude is just putting individual fixes into the how it handles maps, or is correcting how it actually interrogates the map files.

Essentially, at some point someone is going to vibe-code a MW2 level editor, people have already started some work on this. So the ability to for a MW2 recomp to be able to correctly read a map file (created 100% against the specs we have for the maps and bwd files) is going to be key.

Also, the original floatiness in the targetting reticle I mentioned above might be something you might want to consider a toggle for. I know in the GZdoom engine there are toggle/default settings for whether you want the original Doom floaty movement or not. Some people are fine with it, other people who are new-ish to Doom can't deal with the original style movement.

Reply 114 of 114, by Mikeyy00

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
KHORG wrote on Today, 06:37:
I've struck out above what I've re-tested and found fixed. I haven't re-tested Burning Chrome yet. 1.1.28 […]
Show full quote

I've struck out above what I've re-tested and found fixed. I haven't re-tested Burning Chrome yet.
1.1.28

  • Satellite View shows your own mech now, but if you walk over a 3D hill, satellite view renders the wireframe of your mech behind (underneath) the hill, not in front (on top) of the hill.
  • If you go straight to Nav Beta on Wolf mission 2, the enemy Stormcrow there comes online, but doesn't attack you, it just patrols (checked DOS, it behaves correctly there).
  • Similarly, the same Falcon Stormcrow has a Wolf insignia decal applied to it.
  • The Archive Holoprojector animation has been fixed, but the same problem is still present with the Mission Briefing projection from the Ready Room.
  • The Archive Holoprojector should play a "bing" noise when first activated, along with playing a voice sound "accessing".
  • There should be an ambient noise playing in the Clan Hall.
  • There should be an ambient noise playing in the Cadet Training room.
  • Mechs are changing to the first low-detail LOD at about 115m-120. In the DOS version of the game, this change occurs I believe outside 1000m.
  • Mechs look like they are changing to the second low-detail LOD at about 350m. I'm unsure where this occurs in DOS, but my guess is outside 1500m on maps with visibility that far out.
  • On Wolf Trial 1, Star2-Mech1 and Star2-Mech2 shouldn't respond to "nearby" weapons fire. E.g. you can fire an LRM over their heads and they don't wake up, but they will individually respond and attack if hit. However in the recomp, they will go into attack mode if there is weapons fire (e.g. stray LRMs overhead) too close to them.
  • On Sable Flame, the enemy Dropships(x2) should come online at about 1KM with no "Enemy Powerup Detected" notification. But instead they are powering up at 500m with the notification played.

Did you mention earlier there was an issue with the Radar you were aware of? It's slightly the wrong colour and is showing the FOV angle as the wrong shape.

I am interested in how some of these level/world problems came about and are being resolved. I don't know if Claude is just putting individual fixes into the how it handles maps, or is correcting how it actually interrogates the map files.

Essentially, at some point someone is going to vibe-code a MW2 level editor, people have already started some work on this. So the ability to for a MW2 recomp to be able to correctly read a map file (created 100% against the specs we have for the maps and bwd files) is going to be key.

Also, the original floatiness in the targetting reticle I mentioned above might be something you might want to consider a toggle for. I know in the GZdoom engine there are toggle/default settings for whether you want the original Doom floaty movement or not. Some people are fine with it, other people who are new-ish to Doom can't deal with the original style movement.

Thanks, v1.1.29 covers:

Satellite view: your mech now draws on top of hills.

Wolf insignia on Falcon mechs: fixed for every enemy, not just the Stormcrow. Low-detail models were losing their star’s insignia.

Mission Briefing projection: plays in the Ready Room now.

Shell sounds: the holoprojector chime is back; clips played inside a screen had lost their sound. The Wolf Clan Hall and Cadet Training ambient loops are added. The Jade Falcon hall has none in the original.

Detail distances: they now scale with resolution as the original’s do, e.g. about 160 m / 380 m / 1 km at 1080p. The DOS code uses the same thresholds, so I’ve followed that.

Trial 1: only a hit wakes the second star now, not a near miss.

Sable Flame: the dropships wake at about 1 km with no power-up call-out. Resting enemies now use their own wake-up range in every mission, as in the original.

I couldn’t reproduce the Wolf 2 Stormcrow. For me it patrols the HQ and attacks once you’re within 350 m. How did you approach Nav Beta, and did you wait near the HQ?

Far as goal here, it's to be as close to the original release as possible. After that, then we can start adding in QoL enhancements.. e.g. image enhancment on Mercs (or a floaty toggle.)