PC@LIVE wrote on 2024-11-07, 19:53:
Very interesting, forgive me but I also have some motherboards, which I would like to clean, before I thought a little alcohol was enough, but sometimes it doesn't work, and recently I saw on some YouTube videos, which are washed with (hot) water ?), and there are those who use soap or other cleaning products.
I was thinking of using a container, but I think the plastic ones are not good, they could release some electrostatic charge, in short, if you want to share, how to clean and what to use, personally I would appreciate it very much, but once the cleaning is finished, it should be dried in rush.
Plastic container is fine, so long it has water in it (especially soapy water, which is a rather decent electrical conductor.) Thus, dipping a board in such would be like dipping a board in a liquid anti-static bag - basically, all charge will be equalized among all pins and points on the board, so there won't be any static charge build up anywhere.
Also, as others pointed, modern boards are indeed a lot more robust than one might imagine (there's even a good collab video between Electroboom and LTT where they abused a bunch of boards with a static discharge gun.)
As for cleaning of electronics...
Again, as the others stated here, soap (dish detergent) + water is my recommended method too.
I use a variety of brushes for the actual cleaning: a tootbrush for the memory slots and pins inside the expansion slots, a medium hair length paint brush for general cleaning and in areas where the tootbrush bristles are too short to reach into (i.e. nuks and crannies between rear IO ports), and a long-bristle paint brush for cleaning heatsinks and coolers (after taking off fan, of course.)
In regards to drying... I suppose I'm luckier than others here, living in Southeastern Europe currently, where we have a lot of bright and sunny days. In the summer, I can leave a board under the sun and it's typically dry in just a few hours, especially if there is a bit of a breeze. Lately, I leave out my electronics for a day or two, now that the day is much shorter and the sun not as strong (plus, humidity actually goes up in the late fall and winter months here, so drying takes longer.) The rinse with distilled water is indeed a good idea, especially if you're going to let a board dry "naturally" / without assistance of any power tools (hair dryer, hot air, or compressed air). Speaking of drying with compressed air... be careful with the nozzle strength / airflow speed - really high airflow can cause static buildup discharge, from what I've read. Could also knock out marginally-solder components (that were perhaps compromised from physical stress/damage.)
Finally, since I know this has been discussed here before: using a dishwasher to wash electronics - that one's a big NO-NO, at least according to some technical guides. Reason being is that when PCBs are exposed to water at higher temperatures, at higher pressures, and for a more extended period of time, that could lead to moisture ingress in the PCB, which could cause partial short-circuits and/or conductive paths over time. In short, it could wreck hardware over time. So I don't recommend it, even though I know there are a few members that have done it here and didn't have any negative experience from it (so far.)
PC@LIVE wrote on 2024-11-07, 22:10:
some time ago I tried to detach a large SMD from it, it's not good, I guess it doesn't heat up enough.
Yeah, a hair dryer won't get hot enough for that. IIRC, most will only go up to about 60-70-ish Celsius very near the tip, if even that high - and that's by design, to prevent scalding. In contrast, most SMD components need to get to about 190-220C minimum before the solder on their leads will melt and allow for removal (depending if Leaded or Lead-free solder was used.)
PC@LIVE wrote on 2024-11-07, 22:10:
Although before using the hot air, it is advisable to give it a vigorous downward move, which should release the water remaining in the cracks.
Yes, if you feel like it. 😀
Just be careful not to hit the board / piece of hardware you're doing this to into something else. I did once, but it was with an old beige keyboard that was built like a tank. Made huge noise, though... and glad it didn't punch a hole through the (dry)wall. With PCBs, it's worse - anything slipping from your hand could give you bad cuts... though I suppose you already know that, having worked on computers long enough. 😉
Tiido wrote on 2024-11-07, 21:37:
Actual production cleaning methods can involve much harsher stuff than soap+water
Indeed.
Not only that, but proper drying of PCBs before reworking is usually to have the PCB go into a drying oven for 4+ hours at 105C - now that's quite hot! Apparently safe for the hardware, though (except for batteries, of course, which should be removed not only for drying but also prior to washing too.)