TrashPanda wrote on 2022-02-12, 09:50:Newspaper carries very little risk of ESD far less risk to the system than a loose HSF does, I've even asked sellers to remove t […]
Show full quote
Tetrium wrote on 2022-02-12, 09:36:That may do more harm than good. It could cause ESD damage even though the vast majority of packages are unaffected by HSFs comi […]
Show full quote
TrashPanda wrote on 2022-02-12, 08:14:
That poor CPU and cooler 🙁
You would think they would at least pack the inside of the case with newspaper or something else cheap to pad the interior.
That may do more harm than good. It could cause ESD damage even though the vast majority of packages are unaffected by HSFs coming off of the motherboard. People may start using other mats to fill the insides. I'd rather they put nothing in there, not even take off the dust so I know (sometimes stupid) people won't be handling it any more than needed 😜
Even though these 'modern' HSFs are a lot heavier than the earlier stuff like s370 and s7, the mounting mechanism is usually quite secure.
It would probably have been better to have taped the HSF to the bottom of the case, just in case and especially since the board is µATX there is lots of spare room on the bottom anyway.
Newspaper carries very little risk of ESD far less risk to the system than a loose HSF does, I've even asked sellers to remove the HSF and package it separate from the PC since it doesnt matter how damn secure you think it is, its less secure than the postal service is at handling the package. As Linus has proven it takes a phenomenal amount of static to destroy or damage components far more than you'll ever encounter from packaging materials, yes its good to take precautions and one always should but overstating the risk is also wrong. (You get the same crap from people who think magnetic screwdrivers will damage a PC, they wont, they are not even close to being strong enough to do that)
Only time I wouldn't bother with packaging mats in the case is if I was picking it up myself, if its going by post .. then it needs the protection against the mail handling.
The only time I expect the risk to be greater from ESD is with older sensitive components which do require more delicate handling, but you wouldn't be buying them from stupid people.
I think you misinterpreted what Linus has proven. This was all modern components and we here are mostly into older components. And it wasn't exactly scientific either. Iirc he didn't even claim it to be anything scientific but it's been a while since I watched it so I may misremember some of the details.
It works (vastly) different compared to back then. He was handling hardware which is more modern than the most modern hardware I am even using 🤣.
And ESD damage may not be apparent at first, but it's a proven fact that it exists and that it damages. I'm not taking any unnecessary risks with my precious parts but I can fully understand if a few others want to be more careless. It's their stuff in the end. They can do whatever they want but I'd prefer they don't go understating the importance of facts but anyway this is a separate subject.
And I think you're not getting what I was trying to say regarding the packaging as the usage of newspaper is not the main issue I tried to convey.
The issue for me is that if people start making this way of packaging into a habit, not only will padding with newspaper probably not work anyway (a few blobs of crumbled up newspaper will still not do much vs a 700g metal heatsink anyway except give a false sense of security). And secondly if it turns into a well known and standardized habit, people will start using other packaging materials which will cause a lot more ESD damage compared to newspaper or may ruin the internals in some other way.
Asking to send separately is of course the best option for this 😀
But many sellers probably just can't be bothered or you won't get as good as a deal out of it. Or they will sell it to someone else or cancel the deal or cause other obstacles.
Personally I never bothered to have complete systems send, I always asked if I could go pick it up. It may be more hassle for me, but it's usually less hassle for the seller so they are inclined to agree with me or to even sell it to me at a lower price (or sell to me at all instead of to someone else). Also I can do all the packaging myself so it won't arrive with extra scratches, dents or more severe damage which can hamper the functionality of the items in question.
I even bought a full system a few times and had to CARRY it back home xD
But god dammit I wanted it 🤣! 😜
But anyway, mailing complete systems (or even things such as CRT monitors) can be quite risky. I once even ordered a simple whiteboard and it arrive with a dent in it. It gets handled like a bunch of football balls.
Communicating with potential sellers is key. Just try to be nice, offer some extra if it means they will be sending the package in a more secure way. For all I know offer to give a nice feedback even.
It's a real shame the cooler came off. The damage to the motherboard heatsink looks hefty as well. The CPU looks quite hopeless alas.
The motherboard may still work (it probably does if it worked when it was send) but I'd just unmount and remount the motherboard heatsink just in case.
I still think this motherboard is nice. Well except for the now damaged heatsink of course 😜