VOGONS


Childhood deficiencies

Topic actions

Reply 80 of 135, by dormcat

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie
chinny22 wrote on 2024-10-04, 03:03:

I'm playing GTA SA on a quad core 2.50Ghz with GTX590 at max settings without issue
Your proposed build of a dual core 3Ghz with a 750ti is much faster than mine, you'll be fine.

Interesting: TechPowerUp has GTX 590's scores to be 83.5% higher than GTX 750 Ti's, yet PassMark G3D Rating has GTX 590 to be 14.4% lower than GTX 750 Ti, even though GTX 590 has higher framerates under DirectX 9-11. Perhaps only actual games can decide which one works better (methinks GTX 590 would be the winner), although both should be perfectly fine for GTA:SA.

BTW GTX 590's 365W TDP is really a power-hungry beast; even higher than RTX 4080's 320W.

Reply 81 of 135, by Kocyk

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie

What do you think about these sets?

Core2Duo E8500
Asus P5G41T-M
8 GB DDR3 1333

GTX 750 Ti I doubt that the processor will use the full power of the graphics card. Maybe we can find something cheaper i without a bottleneck for the cpu?

i5 2400
gigabyte-ga-h61m-s2v-b3-CID99
GTX 750 Ti or GTX 960 Is it worth paying extra?

Reply 82 of 135, by VivienM

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-06, 20:30:
What do you think about these sets? […]
Show full quote

What do you think about these sets?

Core2Duo E8500
Asus P5G41T-M
8 GB DDR3 1333

GTX 750 Ti I doubt that the processor will use the full power of the graphics card. Maybe we can find something cheaper i without a bottleneck for the cpu?

i5 2400
gigabyte-ga-h61m-s2v-b3-CID99
GTX 750 Ti or GTX 960 Is it worth paying extra?

I am still cringing a bit at those motherboards/chipsets. Maybe I shouldn't be, but those are bottom of the barrel motherboards/chipsets (from very good manufacturers, to be fair) for those platforms.

Not sure where you are, but here, I was seeing someone selling an i7-3770 or 3770k, a nice Z77 motherboard, and some RAM for $100CAD + shipping. Almost felt like buying it but I already have a microATX 3570k system...

Reply 83 of 135, by dormcat

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-06, 20:30:
What do you think about these sets? […]
Show full quote

What do you think about these sets?

Core2Duo E8500
Asus P5G41T-M
8 GB DDR3 1333

GTX 750 Ti I doubt that the processor will use the full power of the graphics card. Maybe we can find something cheaper i without a bottleneck for the cpu?

i5 2400
gigabyte-ga-h61m-s2v-b3-CID99
GTX 750 Ti or GTX 960 Is it worth paying extra?

Looks like that you haven't taken my advice, mate.

Bought
Asus P5G41T-M LX + C2Q Q8300 + 4GB DDR3 + Asus EN210 SILENT/DI/1GD3/V2(LP) (GeForce 210) + 500GB HDD + DVD Multi + some crappy 400W PSU + ATX case
for NT$1600 (~US$50).

Bought
Gigabyte GA-P31-ES3G + C2D E7400 + 4GB DDR2 + Sound Blaster X-Fi Xtreme Audio (SB0790)
from a friend for NT$1000 (~US$31).

Bought
Asus H61M-K + Celeron G1620
for NT$600 (~US$19).

Picked up
ECS MCP73VT-PM + Pentium E5700 + 2GB DDR2 + PowerColor AX4350 512MD2-H (Radeon HD 4350) + 500GB HDD + DVD Multi + Delta 250W PSU + microATX case
on a sidewalk for FREE!

Picked up
GA-965P-DQ6 + C2D E6300 + 2GB DDR2 + Gigabyte GV-R455HM-512I (Radeon HD 4550) + 2x 160GB HDD + DVD Multi + Seasonic 430W PSU + ATX case
on a sidewalk for FREE!

Picked up
K9A2 Platinum + Athlon 64 X2 5000+ + DVD Multi
on a sidewalk for FREE!

Received
Asus P5GDC-V Deluxe + Pentium 4 520 + 1GB DDR + Pioneer DVD-multi + EMACS 500W PSU + a huge Gigabyte 3D Aurora water cooling-ready ATX case
from a neighbor for FREE!


Why am I listing those above? Because all of them could run WinXP and GTA:SA. Unless your friends had loaded wallets and bought a Pentium D or Athlon 64 X2-based system in 2005, it was more likely that they had a system comparable with the last one above (Asus P5GDC-V Deluxe + Pentium 4 520 + 1GB DDR), which was considered high-end in 2004 and was still quite capable in 2005. Yet any other system in the list could kick its butt with ease.

So the real question is: how much do their respective sellers offer, and how much do you want to spend on your "childhood deficiencies"?

Reply 84 of 135, by Kocyk

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
dormcat wrote on 2024-10-07, 00:52:
Looks like that you haven't taken my advice, mate. […]
Show full quote
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-06, 20:30:
What do you think about these sets? […]
Show full quote

What do you think about these sets?

Core2Duo E8500
Asus P5G41T-M
8 GB DDR3 1333

GTX 750 Ti I doubt that the processor will use the full power of the graphics card. Maybe we can find something cheaper i without a bottleneck for the cpu?

i5 2400
gigabyte-ga-h61m-s2v-b3-CID99
GTX 750 Ti or GTX 960 Is it worth paying extra?

Looks like that you haven't taken my advice, mate.

Bought
Asus P5G41T-M LX + C2Q Q8300 + 4GB DDR3 + Asus EN210 SILENT/DI/1GD3/V2(LP) (GeForce 210) + 500GB HDD + DVD Multi + some crappy 400W PSU + ATX case
for NT$1600 (~US$50).

Bought
Gigabyte GA-P31-ES3G + C2D E7400 + 4GB DDR2 + Sound Blaster X-Fi Xtreme Audio (SB0790)
from a friend for NT$1000 (~US$31).

Bought
Asus H61M-K + Celeron G1620
for NT$600 (~US$19).

Picked up
ECS MCP73VT-PM + Pentium E5700 + 2GB DDR2 + PowerColor AX4350 512MD2-H (Radeon HD 4350) + 500GB HDD + DVD Multi + Delta 250W PSU + microATX case
on a sidewalk for FREE!

Picked up
GA-965P-DQ6 + C2D E6300 + 2GB DDR2 + Gigabyte GV-R455HM-512I (Radeon HD 4550) + 2x 160GB HDD + DVD Multi + Seasonic 430W PSU + ATX case
on a sidewalk for FREE!

Picked up
K9A2 Platinum + Athlon 64 X2 5000+ + DVD Multi
on a sidewalk for FREE!

Received
Asus P5GDC-V Deluxe + Pentium 4 520 + 1GB DDR + Pioneer DVD-multi + EMACS 500W PSU + a huge Gigabyte 3D Aurora water cooling-ready ATX case
from a neighbor for FREE!


Why am I listing those above? Because all of them could run WinXP and GTA:SA. Unless your friends had loaded wallets and bought a Pentium D or Athlon 64 X2-based system in 2005, it was more likely that they had a system comparable with the last one above (Asus P5GDC-V Deluxe + Pentium 4 520 + 1GB DDR), which was considered high-end in 2004 and was still quite capable in 2005. Yet any other system in the list could kick its butt with ease.

So the real question is: how much do their respective sellers offer, and how much do you want to spend on your "childhood deficiencies"?

My friend I feel resignation and frustration.

I am terrified and furious. I read that it is better to choose a C2D processor than a Pentium4 because it is only a 2 year difference, but the difference in performance is huge. The problem is that some socket775 motherboards have damaged condensators, some motherboards are poor, as you wrote about, and these good motherboards are expensive. I've heard that the price of socket775 motherboards has increased due to the popularity of Xeon processors.

I found these motherboards

ASUS P5B DELUXE
Asus p5k pro
Asus P5Q3

but I don't know there are good or not. For sure their price is high.

For this reason, I became interested in the i5-2gen. But there are problems here as well.

Choice of RAM. The 2nd/3rd generation of inteli processors supports modules with 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 organization and the maximum size of the memory chip on the memory module is 512 MB (4 Gb). For an 8GB memory module, it must have 16 chips, and it cannot have 8. You need to check if the ram memory fits the processor, and not only the speed and voltage, but also the arrangement of the 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 modules.

The box cooling system in Intel from I5 processors is suitable for office work. Under higher CPU loads, it gets hot and noisy. All the more reason to use a different cooling system for gaming. You have to play around with the cooling system.

Another problem is the choice of power supply. The biggest load on the power supply is the graphics card. You need to know the model of the graphics card and calculate whether the power supply will do the job.
Only then can you buy a power supply.

From the older graphics cards, you can consider the GTX750/750Ti/950/960/1050/1050Ti. These are graphics cards with low power consumption and not so terribly vintage yet. Do you agree that old graphics cards "heaters" are not worth buying? In my opinion at this point, they are potentially very faulty, and they heat up mercilessly.

It all seems complicated that I feel resigned.

Reply 85 of 135, by rasz_pl

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

I am terrified and furious.

🙁

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

The problem is that some socket775 motherboards have damaged condensators

no, its Pentium 4 motherboards that have mostly blown capacitors, boards past 2006-8 are fine.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

some motherboards are poor, as you wrote about

as _he_ and only _he_ wrote 😀

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

Choice of RAM. The 2nd/3rd generation of inteli processors supports modules with 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 organization and the maximum size of the memory chip on the memory module is 512 MB (4 Gb). For an 8GB memory module, it must have 16 chips, and it cannot have 8. You need to check if the ram memory fits the processor, and not only the speed and voltage, but also the arrangement of the 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 modules.

my reaction to this is WHAT? They all take ordinary DDR3 and you wont have any problem with ram, DDR3 ram is dirt cheap and you wont need more than 4GB anyway for XP

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

The box cooling system in Intel from I5 processors is suitable for office work. Under higher CPU loads, it gets hot and noisy. All the more reason to use a different cooling system for gaming. You have to play around with the cooling system.

meh non problem unless you upgrade to 8 core i7/Xeon, but that would be ~2015 XP computer, something that pretty much didnt exist in nature https://www.reddit.com/r/windowsxp/comments/1 … rig_intel_xeon/

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

Another problem is the choice of power supply. The biggest load on the power supply is the graphics card. You need to know the model of the graphics card and calculate whether the power supply will do the job.

yes if you buy >200W top model, not with 750ti

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

It all seems complicated that I feel resigned.

You read and worry too much. Find a cheap whole used P4/C2D computer in your local classifieds/FB marketplace or in a recycling center, something <=$50. Then you can see if its enough for your needs or if you want to upgrade. $50 is not a life and death choice, low stakes no stress.

https://github.com/raszpl/FIC-486-GAC-2-Cache-Module for AT&T Globalyst
https://github.com/raszpl/386RC-16 memory board
https://github.com/raszpl/440BX Reference Design adapted to Kicad
https://github.com/raszpl/Zenith_ZBIOS MFM-300 Monitor

Reply 86 of 135, by Kocyk

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
rasz_pl wrote on 2024-10-07, 10:50:
:( […]
Show full quote
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

I am terrified and furious.

🙁

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

The problem is that some socket775 motherboards have damaged condensators

no, its Pentium 4 motherboards that have mostly blown capacitors, boards past 2006-8 are fine.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

some motherboards are poor, as you wrote about

as _he_ and only _he_ wrote 😀

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

Choice of RAM. The 2nd/3rd generation of inteli processors supports modules with 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 organization and the maximum size of the memory chip on the memory module is 512 MB (4 Gb). For an 8GB memory module, it must have 16 chips, and it cannot have 8. You need to check if the ram memory fits the processor, and not only the speed and voltage, but also the arrangement of the 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 modules.

my reaction to this is WHAT? They all take ordinary DDR3 and you wont have any problem with ram, DDR3 ram is dirt cheap and you wont need more than 4GB anyway for XP

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

The box cooling system in Intel from I5 processors is suitable for office work. Under higher CPU loads, it gets hot and noisy. All the more reason to use a different cooling system for gaming. You have to play around with the cooling system.

meh non problem unless you upgrade to 8 core i7/Xeon, but that would be ~2015 XP computer, something that pretty much didnt exist in nature https://www.reddit.com/r/windowsxp/comments/1 … rig_intel_xeon/

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

Another problem is the choice of power supply. The biggest load on the power supply is the graphics card. You need to know the model of the graphics card and calculate whether the power supply will do the job.

yes if you buy >200W top model, not with 750ti

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

It all seems complicated that I feel resigned.

You read and worry too much. Find a cheap whole used P4/C2D computer in your local classifieds/FB marketplace or in a recycling center, something <=$50. Then you can see if its enough for your needs or if you want to upgrade. $50 is not a life and death choice, low stakes no stress.

Unfortunately, motherboards for C2D have become much more expensive and many of them are damaged. This is what many people wrote on various forums.

Your nickname ends in "pl", does that mean you are from Poland?

Reply 87 of 135, by Shponglefan

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 12:09:

Unfortunately, motherboards for C2D have become much more expensive and many of them are damaged. This is what many people wrote on various forums.

I don't know who has been saying this, but it's wrong. I just searched for Core2Duo motherboards on Ebay, and there are loads of them available. Many of them are under $100 (some as little as $20) and many also include processors and RAM.

Also not sure where this idea that many of them are damaged (?) is coming from? Many Core2 motherboards were manufactured at the end of the capacitor plague, so they're more likely to be reliable than motherboards from the early 2000s.

Pentium 4 Multi-OS Build
486 DX4-100 with 6 sound cards
486 DX-33 with 5 sound cards

Reply 88 of 135, by Shponglefan

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

It all seems complicated that I feel resigned.

I think part of feelings of this being complicated are stemming from some misconceptions about hardware. For example, the claim about needing to wait to buy a power supply isn't necessarily true if you pair a modern PSU with enough wattage with vintage hardware.

Or the comment about worrying about graphics cards overheating, which again, not an issue for running a lot of those GPUs with 2005 era games. Case in point, I have a 980 Ti in my own Windows XP machine. It rarely heats up enough to even trigger the fans spinning.

If it feels too complicated and frustrating to build a system from scratch, the next best thing is to buy a pre-built system. Take a look at thrift stores, recycling centres, local ads, etc.

By getting a pre-built system, you can always take it apart and replace individual components later if it doesn't fully do what you want. But it's a lot easier than trying to piece together a system from scratch, especially if you haven't done that before.

Pentium 4 Multi-OS Build
486 DX4-100 with 6 sound cards
486 DX-33 with 5 sound cards

Reply 89 of 135, by BitWrangler

User metadata
Rank l33t++
Rank
l33t++

It's funny what goes short and unobtanium from place to place. Inside the period of this thread, I have for $40CDN picked up enough hardware to put together a complete high end P4 system unit and a first gen i7 system, and have 1GPU, 3CPU and a pile of memory left over, potentially resalable for more than $40. BUT, I have been tearing my hair out trying to find a simple LCD widescreen for under $50 that has HDCP, i.e. fully digital connectivity path, they all just "disappeared" locally, or more correctly it seems local demand is strangely high and they're all selling super quick.

edit: whoops, sorry I lied, it was 2 days prior to this thread starting I got some of the parts.

Last edited by BitWrangler on 2024-10-07, 16:11. Edited 1 time in total.

Unicorn herding operations are proceeding, but all the totes of hens teeth and barrels of rocking horse poop give them plenty of hiding spots.

Reply 90 of 135, by Kocyk

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
Shponglefan wrote on 2024-10-07, 13:03:
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 12:09:

Unfortunately, motherboards for C2D have become much more expensive and many of them are damaged. This is what many people wrote on various forums.

I don't know who has been saying this, but it's wrong. I just searched for Core2Duo motherboards on Ebay, and there are loads of them available. Many of them are under $100 (some as little as $20) and many also include processors and RAM.

Also not sure where this idea that many of them are damaged (?) is coming from? Many Core2 motherboards were manufactured at the end of the capacitor plague, so they're more likely to be reliable than motherboards from the early 2000s.

I don't understand one thing.

Earlier I mentioned several Gigabyte motherboards. You wrote that it's crap.
"High-end" L775 motherboards are expensive, they cost around $100.

I don't understand why "low-end" motherboards are worse than more expensive ones?
After putting the E8400 processor to low-end motherboards pc won't run? What is it about?
Gigabyte p31 - es3g is average motherboard and still can use gtx 1050 ti without bios update.

And I don't know what about video cards. Probably for E8400 gtx 1050 ti, the graphic card is wasted. What would you recommend that is cheaper and uses the full power of the E8400?

Reply 91 of 135, by dormcat

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

My friend I feel resignation and frustration.

I am terrified and furious.

Easy, bro. Relax. Retro computing is a hobby and should be enjoyable.

I apologize if I've been bit harsh on you. The point is, however, that you haven't specified your budget. You kept saying "expensive" in different replies but you gave no number. In addition to average income and abundancies of used computer hardware, other factors such as environment regulations in different cities, counties, states / provinces, or countries, can affect the cost of acquiring vintage hardware as well.

Cupertino, CA is a city with homeless tents a block away from Apple Park; I'd say most VOGONS users are in between two extremes, but even that is a very big margin. Even the same amount of a certain currency, say, US$100, can be felt very differently by different individuals living in the same city.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

I read that it is better to choose a C2D processor than a Pentium4 because it is only a 2 year difference, but the difference in performance is huge. The problem is that some socket775 motherboards have damaged condensators,

As rasz_pl and Shponglefan wrote: the capacitor plague was almost over in the early C2D era (65 nm). The plague affected mostly P4 Prescott era (90 nm) motherboards. Besides, LGA775 motherboards with good capacitors are not too hard to find, and bulging capacitors can be replaced with relative ease.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

some motherboards are poor, as you wrote about, and these good motherboards are expensive.

Woah, hold it right there. I gave examples of differences between an entry-level and a flagship motherboards, but I didn't say an entry-level MB must be a poor MB. Many entry-level MB were retired from office computers, sitting in air conditioned rooms running mundane office suites software in their lifetimes, so their conditions can be quite nice. Heck, I've seen office computers in e-waste with protective film still attached on plastic! Sure, some features were limited due to low-end chipsets (such as providing fewer and/or slower SATA and USB ports), but if those features don't matter to you then why not.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:

I've heard that the price of socket775 motherboards has increased due to the popularity of Xeon processors.

Never heard of that. Care to share your source please?

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:
I found these motherboards […]
Show full quote

I found these motherboards

ASUS P5B DELUXE
Asus p5k pro
Asus P5Q3

but I don't know there are good or not. For sure their price is high.

I do own an Asus P5B Deluxe so I'll use it as an example: after checking eBay I found seven items. Two of them feel fishy with only stock photos (I never buy used items, computer hardware or whatnot, from any seller using stock photos taken from the original manufacturer), one has bulging (but not too bad) capacitors. The rest four are priced between US$50-100, some with CPU and RAM bundled. Again, I don't know if those prices are "expensive" to you; it's very subjective.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 09:22:
Choice of RAM. The 2nd/3rd generation of inteli processors supports modules with 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 organization and the maximum size […]
Show full quote

Choice of RAM. The 2nd/3rd generation of inteli processors supports modules with 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 organization and the maximum size of the memory chip on the memory module is 512 MB (4 Gb). For an 8GB memory module, it must have 16 chips, and it cannot have 8. You need to check if the ram memory fits the processor, and not only the speed and voltage, but also the arrangement of the 1Rx8 and 2Rx8 modules.

The box cooling system in Intel from I5 processors is suitable for office work. Under higher CPU loads, it gets hot and noisy. All the more reason to use a different cooling system for gaming. You have to play around with the cooling system.

Another problem is the choice of power supply. The biggest load on the power supply is the graphics card. You need to know the model of the graphics card and calculate whether the power supply will do the job.
Only then can you buy a power supply.

From the older graphics cards, you can consider the GTX750/750Ti/950/960/1050/1050Ti. These are graphics cards with low power consumption and not so terribly vintage yet. Do you agree that old graphics cards "heaters" are not worth buying? In my opinion at this point, they are potentially very faulty, and they heat up mercilessly.

Wait, did you copy the four paragraphs above from someone else's reply at some other forum? Because they don't sound like your words. Rather, they sound like someone else talking to you instead.

Asus P5B Deluxe accepts 4 strips of DDR2 (up to 2 GB each), making total of 8 GB max. It would be difficult to explain RAM Ranks in a few words and I'm sure it would only add your frustration; just follow the compatibility list provided by MB maker. If you buy an MB with RAM bundled then you can set the problem aside (assuming the seller has tested the system).

The stock cooler of any Intel CPU would be adequate under most situations. Should you really feel the need to replace it with a better cooler, options are cheap and plenty for LGA775.

"Only then can you buy a power supply." Nonsense. I don't think you can buy any 80 Plus-certified ATX PSU with less than 350W nowadays; 350W is enough to handle GTX 960 (TDP = 120 W) with ease, let alone any GPU with less TDP. You wouldn't want 10 series as Nvidia provided no WinXP driver for them.

Reply 92 of 135, by Shponglefan

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 13:49:

I don't understand one thing.

Earlier I mentioned several Gigabyte motherboards. You wrote that it's crap.

I haven't said anything about any specific motherboards. I think you are confusing me with other posters.

When I look for motherboards, my primary criteria is determining an appropriate chipset and socket type for the era of processor I might want to use. The secondary criteria are specific features of the board including what slots it has, ports, built-in controllers, etc. From there, I'll search for available motherboards and see what is available. I don't tend to worry about specific models or brands unless I have very narrow criteria.

I don't classify boards as "high end" or "low end". To me those are useless descriptors that don't really mean anything. I would only ask two questions. 1) Does the board have the features I want? 2) Does it perform well for how I intend to use it?

To answer those questions, I would look up historical reviews of specific motherboards or groups of motherboards from sites like Tom's Hardware, Anatech, old issues of Maximum PC, etc.

And I don't know what about video cards. Probably for E8400 gtx 1050 ti, the graphic card is wasted. What would you recommend that is cheaper and uses the full power of the E8400?

10xx series of graphic cards aren't compatible with XP. The last officially supported nVidia graphic cards under XP was the GTX 970. Though it's also possible to use GTX 980 / 980 Ti by editing the driver files, which is how I got my 980 Ti working under XP.

Pentium 4 Multi-OS Build
486 DX4-100 with 6 sound cards
486 DX-33 with 5 sound cards

Reply 93 of 135, by dormcat

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 13:49:
Earlier I mentioned several Gigabyte motherboards. You wrote that it's crap. "High-end" L775 motherboards are expensive, they co […]
Show full quote

Earlier I mentioned several Gigabyte motherboards. You wrote that it's crap.
"High-end" L775 motherboards are expensive, they cost around $100.

I don't understand why "low-end" motherboards are worse than more expensive ones?
After putting the E8400 processor to low-end motherboards pc won't run? What is it about?

As far as I can see, only VivienM wrote about "low-end chipsets," and neither rasz_pl nor I agreed.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 13:49:

Gigabyte p31 - es3g is average motherboard and still can use gtx 1050 ti without bios update.

I happened to own this MB (bought from a friend; mentioned above). I wouldn't suggest using GTX 1050 Ti on it for two reasons:
1) The P31 chipset only supports PCIe 1.1, while GTX 1050 Ti has PCIe 3.0. Sure, the 2016 GPU can run on this 2008 MB but it's a bloody waste.
2) Your purpose is to run WinXP on this system, and GeForce 10 series is not compatible with WinXP.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 13:49:

And I don't know what about video cards. Probably for E8400 gtx 1050 ti, the graphic card is wasted. What would you recommend that is cheaper and uses the full power of the E8400?

I've got an Asus EAH5670/DI/1GD5 (Radeon HD 5670) picked up from e-waste for NT$150. Any mid-level PCIe 2.0 x16 GPU would do.

Reply 94 of 135, by Kocyk

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
dormcat wrote on 2024-10-07, 15:12:
As far as I can see, only VivienM wrote about "low-end chipsets," and neither rasz_pl nor I agreed. […]
Show full quote
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 13:49:
Earlier I mentioned several Gigabyte motherboards. You wrote that it's crap. "High-end" L775 motherboards are expensive, they co […]
Show full quote

Earlier I mentioned several Gigabyte motherboards. You wrote that it's crap.
"High-end" L775 motherboards are expensive, they cost around $100.

I don't understand why "low-end" motherboards are worse than more expensive ones?
After putting the E8400 processor to low-end motherboards pc won't run? What is it about?

As far as I can see, only VivienM wrote about "low-end chipsets," and neither rasz_pl nor I agreed.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 13:49:

Gigabyte p31 - es3g is average motherboard and still can use gtx 1050 ti without bios update.

I happened to own this MB (bought from a friend; mentioned above). I wouldn't suggest using GTX 1050 Ti on it for two reasons:
1) The P31 chipset only supports PCIe 1.1, while GTX 1050 Ti has PCIe 3.0. Sure, the 2016 GPU can run on this 2008 MB but it's a bloody waste.
2) Your purpose is to run WinXP on this system, and GeForce 10 series is not compatible with WinXP.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-07, 13:49:

And I don't know what about video cards. Probably for E8400 gtx 1050 ti, the graphic card is wasted. What would you recommend that is cheaper and uses the full power of the E8400?

I've got an Asus EAH5670/DI/1GD5 (Radeon HD 5670) picked up from e-waste for NT$150. Any mid-level PCIe 2.0 x16 GPU would do.

Yes, that statement came from another forum.

My Friend It's hard for me to set a budget, because I'm from Poland and prices of PC components are different.

I browsed the Polish equivalent of eBay, site Allegro
There I found some cheap motherboards for my wallet on the L775.
Here they are:
Asus P5KPL-AM
ASUS P5GC-VM
Asus P5E-VM SE
Asus P5KPL-AM
ASUS P5G41-M

I was deliberately looking for Asus motherboards because I noticed that you recommend them.

For i5-2400 I found ATX Dell optiplex 990

What do you think about these motherboards?

I wanna the motherboard to support the E8400 and E8500 processors.
I expect the motherboard to have 2 ram slots to use dual channel.
DDR2 RAM is ok for me. I don't need DDR3.
It is important that the motherboard supports at least 4gb of memory.
It would be good if the motherboard bus was fast for the processor, so that the processor worked at 100% of its potential.

Reply 95 of 135, by rasz_pl

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 08:19:

My Friend It's hard for me to set a budget, because I'm from Poland and prices of PC components are different.

$40 https://allegrolokalnie.pl/oferta/zestaw-komp … mgs-radeon-4870
e8400, fancy 4GB ram, fancy Zalman Z9U3 case, psu, radeon 4870, mobo still has IDE for older drives. Tested to post screen but Im pretty sure it will be all ok, worst case scenario GPU might be glitchy and need replacement.
plug SSD, keyboard, mouse, install XP and play anything you want maxed.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 08:19:

For i5-2400 I found ATX Dell optiplex 990

$100, Win10 era. Be careful not to buy slim case by accident, cant fit normal height graphic card.

https://github.com/raszpl/FIC-486-GAC-2-Cache-Module for AT&T Globalyst
https://github.com/raszpl/386RC-16 memory board
https://github.com/raszpl/440BX Reference Design adapted to Kicad
https://github.com/raszpl/Zenith_ZBIOS MFM-300 Monitor

Reply 96 of 135, by Kocyk

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
rasz_pl wrote on 2024-10-08, 10:23:
$40 https://allegrolokalnie.pl/oferta/zestaw-komp … mgs-radeon-4870 e8400, fancy 4GB ram, fancy Zalman Z9U3 case, psu, radeon 48 […]
Show full quote
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 08:19:

My Friend It's hard for me to set a budget, because I'm from Poland and prices of PC components are different.

$40 https://allegrolokalnie.pl/oferta/zestaw-komp … mgs-radeon-4870
e8400, fancy 4GB ram, fancy Zalman Z9U3 case, psu, radeon 4870, mobo still has IDE for older drives. Tested to post screen but Im pretty sure it will be all ok, worst case scenario GPU might be glitchy and need replacement.
plug SSD, keyboard, mouse, install XP and play anything you want maxed.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 08:19:

For i5-2400 I found ATX Dell optiplex 990

$100, Win10 era. Be careful not to buy slim case by accident, cant fit normal height graphic card.

Thanks for the answer but I wanna build retro pc myself.

Apart from that, this pc set has a problem with the power button and I want a different graphics card and a pc without a case

Reply 97 of 135, by Shponglefan

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 11:24:

Thanks for the answer but I wanna build retro pc myself.

Apart from that, this pc set has a problem with the power button and I want a different graphics card and a pc without a case

You can still build a PC yourself even if you buy a pre-built one. You just take it apart, keep the parts you want, and replace the parts you don't want.

I buy pre-built systems all the time, since I find it a good way to get a lot of useful parts for other builds.

It can also be good to have a pre-built system as a starting point, because it gives you something you can test out and use to better determine what you really need or want.

And finally, pre-built systems will typically be a less expensive way to get a working system than buying parts individually. You've repeatedly mentioned certain parts being expensive, which suggests price is a concern.

Pentium 4 Multi-OS Build
486 DX4-100 with 6 sound cards
486 DX-33 with 5 sound cards

Reply 98 of 135, by dormcat

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 08:19:
I browsed the Polish equivalent of eBay, site Allegro There I found some cheap motherboards for my wallet on the L775. Here they […]
Show full quote

I browsed the Polish equivalent of eBay, site Allegro
There I found some cheap motherboards for my wallet on the L775.
Here they are:
Asus P5KPL-AM
ASUS P5GC-VM
Asus P5E-VM SE
Asus P5KPL-AM
ASUS P5G41-M

You listed P5KPL-AM twice. 😅

They had similar specs, but if I could choose any of them with the same price, I'd pick P5E-VM SE. It supports up to 8 GB RAM (4 x 2 GB DDR2 strips) so if you pair it with a C2Q then it can even run Win10 with reasonable speed.

P5GC-VM is much older than other three and has limited support to Core series CPU; it was designed for NetBurst in mind instead of Core.

P5KPL-AM is not very different from P5E-VM SE but only has two RAM sockets, limiting its RAM to 4 GB max. While P5G41-M supports up to 8 GB RAM, it too has only two RAM sockets like P5KPL-AM, and 4 GB DDR2 DIMM are more expensive and rare than 2 GB DDR2 DIMM, which are very cheap and abundant on used markets.

I was deliberately looking for Asus motherboards because I noticed that you recommend them.

Eh, no, I didn't. I only mentioned that I own several (11 out of 26 desktop motherboards in my life). It's the biggest MB maker anyway so there's nothing wrong buying one. You don't have to limit yourself to Asus, though.

For i5-2400 I found ATX Dell optiplex 990

With Q65 chipset? That's quite nice and not often found on retail motherboards. It can take up to 4 x 4 GB DDR3 RAM strips, making it an excellent XP/10 hybrid system.

If that OptiPlex 990 is working fine and cost about the same then I'd just grab it instead of only a motherboard. A problem of those OEM boards is that its front panel connector is integrated and unmarked, forcing user to use a case from the same company.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 11:24:

Thanks for the answer but I wanna build retro pc myself.

Apart from that, this pc set has a problem with the power button and I want a different graphics card and a pc without a case

Well...... I agree with rasz_pl's recommendation. It's a very nice WinXP build with CPU and GPU better than my equivalent build. You can have the GPU and case as spare parts (having sufficient spare parts handy is very important in retro computing) or sell / gift them to others.

Shponglefan wrote on 2024-10-08, 11:53:
You can still build a PC yourself even if you buy a pre-built one. You just take it apart, keep the parts you want, and replace […]
Show full quote

You can still build a PC yourself even if you buy a pre-built one. You just take it apart, keep the parts you want, and replace the parts you don't want.

I buy pre-built systems all the time, since I find it a good way to get a lot of useful parts for other builds.

It can also be good to have a pre-built system as a starting point, because it gives you something you can test out and use to better determine what you really need or want.

And finally, pre-built systems will typically be a less expensive way to get a working system than buying parts individually. You've repeatedly mentioned certain parts being expensive, which suggests price is a concern.

Well said! 👍

Reply 99 of 135, by Kocyk

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
dormcat wrote on 2024-10-08, 12:07:
You listed P5KPL-AM twice. :sweat_smile: […]
Show full quote
Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 08:19:
I browsed the Polish equivalent of eBay, site Allegro There I found some cheap motherboards for my wallet on the L775. Here they […]
Show full quote

I browsed the Polish equivalent of eBay, site Allegro
There I found some cheap motherboards for my wallet on the L775.
Here they are:
Asus P5KPL-AM
ASUS P5GC-VM
Asus P5E-VM SE
Asus P5KPL-AM
ASUS P5G41-M

You listed P5KPL-AM twice. 😅

They had similar specs, but if I could choose any of them with the same price, I'd pick P5E-VM SE. It supports up to 8 GB RAM (4 x 2 GB DDR2 strips) so if you pair it with a C2Q then it can even run Win10 with reasonable speed.

P5GC-VM is much older than other three and has limited support to Core series CPU; it was designed for NetBurst in mind instead of Core.

P5KPL-AM is not very different from P5E-VM SE but only has two RAM sockets, limiting its RAM to 4 GB max. While P5G41-M supports up to 8 GB RAM, it too has only two RAM sockets like P5KPL-AM, and 4 GB DDR2 DIMM are more expensive and rare than 2 GB DDR2 DIMM, which are very cheap and abundant on used markets.

I was deliberately looking for Asus motherboards because I noticed that you recommend them.

Eh, no, I didn't. I only mentioned that I own several (11 out of 26 desktop motherboards in my life). It's the biggest MB maker anyway so there's nothing wrong buying one. You don't have to limit yourself to Asus, though.

For i5-2400 I found ATX Dell optiplex 990

With Q65 chipset? That's quite nice and not often found on retail motherboards. It can take up to 4 x 4 GB DDR3 RAM strips, making it an excellent XP/10 hybrid system.

If that OptiPlex 990 is working fine and cost about the same then I'd just grab it instead of only a motherboard. A problem of those OEM boards is that its front panel connector is integrated and unmarked, forcing user to use a case from the same company.

Kocyk wrote on 2024-10-08, 11:24:

Thanks for the answer but I wanna build retro pc myself.

Apart from that, this pc set has a problem with the power button and I want a different graphics card and a pc without a case

Well...... I agree with rasz_pl's recommendation. It's a very nice WinXP build with CPU and GPU better than my equivalent build. You can have the GPU and case as spare parts (having sufficient spare parts handy is very important in retro computing) or sell / gift them to others.

Shponglefan wrote on 2024-10-08, 11:53:
You can still build a PC yourself even if you buy a pre-built one. You just take it apart, keep the parts you want, and replace […]
Show full quote

You can still build a PC yourself even if you buy a pre-built one. You just take it apart, keep the parts you want, and replace the parts you don't want.

I buy pre-built systems all the time, since I find it a good way to get a lot of useful parts for other builds.

It can also be good to have a pre-built system as a starting point, because it gives you something you can test out and use to better determine what you really need or want.

And finally, pre-built systems will typically be a less expensive way to get a working system than buying parts individually. You've repeatedly mentioned certain parts being expensive, which suggests price is a concern.

Well said! 👍

You are probably right. In the sets, you can find various parts, which sometimes cost more individually.

I think I understand these limitations of motherboards.
One MB has a maximum limit of 4gb of ram.
Other MBs support 8GB of ram, but they only have two slots for ram and this narrows down the possibilities because 2+2 is only 4, and when you wanna 8 you have to put in the more expensive 2x4.

Ok, I understand that I need to check on the manufacturer's website MB compatibility with processors and supporting ram.

Why are the 8400 and 8500 so much cheaper than the E8600? Is it because of the last model of the series?

Power supply, what do you recommend for the E8400/E8500 and the 750Ti graphics card? Are there any that should be avoided? Is it true that modern power supplies are good even for Pentium4?