First post, by kotel
- Rank
- Oldbie
This project took me too long to finish.
Hopefully this went in the correct forum and the info will be used by someone.
Link to the result spreadsheet.
This is the ranking for the best AV vendor for low end XP machines.
!ALL TESTS WERE DONE ON REAL HARDWARE!
Specs:
Intel celeron M 1.4gHz; SATA I 5400RPM HDD; 512MB DDR2 PC2-4200; Integrated Intel i945GE GPU
These tests were to see which vendor combines effectiveness, lightweightness and ease of use.
All AV's couldn't be updated to latest defenitions due to their update servers being long dead
Avast v8 needs to be activated using this key Avast gave for free to their discontinued AV products: https://www.avast.com/registration-free-antivirus#pc
1. AV is disqualified when:
a) let's through the biggest ammount of sample viruses
b) Renders the PC unusuable due to being resource heavy
---------------------
The award for best Real Time detection rate goes to....
Avast! Free v8
Second: MSE 4.4.13 with Kaspersky Free 2018 and ESET NOD32 v6 (same % score)
Third: GDATA 14.1.1.54
Fourth: Avira antivir 13
The award for best Scan detecion rate goes to.....
Avast! Free v8 and ESET Endpoint protection v6.5 right behind it
Second: Kaspersky free 2018
Third: MSE 4.4.13 and GDATA Client 14.1.1.54
Fourth: ESET NOD32 v6
Personal award for lightweightness, effectiveness and ease of use (with configuration) goes to.....
MSE 4.4.13
Second: Avast! Free v8
Third: ESET Endpoint protection v6.5
Fourth: ESET NOD32 v6
-----------------------
ClamWin: too much RAM usage (512MB + ~120MB swap) when scanning and downloading defenitions
Norton AV 2009: broken scanner, not usable on these specs (lack of working installer to redo tests)
Trend PC cillin 2002: outdated defenitions (cannot update due to servers being long dead)
-----------------------
Overall, I though MSE 4.4.13 would be the worst, but turns out it's pretty darn good at being an AV!
Had higher hopes for ESET endpoint protection v6.5 tho.... It even let CIH launch when doing real time testing! None AV vendors let the CIH samples through beside eset endpoint.
"All my efforts were in vain...
Let that be my disappointment."
-Kotel