Testbench 19:
- Gigabyte GA-MA770-UD3 v2.0
- Phenom II X4 955 BE 3.2Ghz HDZ955FBK4DGM (Deneb, stepping C3, released in 2009)
- PNY GeForce GTX 780 OC 3GB (1006/1059 GPU, 1552 memory, released in 2013). NVidia driver 368.81
- 4x 2GB DDR2 800 unganged running at 4 4 4 12
Phenom II X4 955 BE represents an OCed Phenom II X4 940 BE to 3.2Ghz which is a realistic scenario. 940 BE is an early stepping C2 and has less overclocking potential than C3. Un-core is running at 2Ghz vs 1.8Ghz on 940 BE. This can be adjusted in BIOS as Northbridge multiplier. Raising un-core frequency improves memory controller and L3 cache bandwidth. Un-core at 2Ghz is a realistic target for 940 BE.
We couldn't run 4x 2GB sticks at 1066 similarly to Phenom X4 9950 BE 2.6Ghz. Only 2 memory sticks can run at that speed but we need 8GB RAM for Vista era.
PNY GeForce GTX 780 OC is a really powerful GPU that deserves at least FX-8370 or i7-3770K. Phenom II X4 955 BE is vastly underpowered for it.
3DMark 2006
3DMark 2006 is a DirectX 9 benchmark for Windows XP.
Windows XP
3DMark 2006 breakdown, 1024x768:
- Return To Proxycon - 54 fps
- Firefly Forest - 55 fps
- Canyon Flight - 124 fps
- Deep Freeze - 70 fps
3DMark 2006 breakdown, 1600x900:
- Return To Proxycon - 53 fps
- Firefly Forest - 55 fps
- Canyon Flight - 120 fps
- Deep Freeze - 70 fps
3DMark 2006 breakdown, 1600x1200:
- Return To Proxycon - 53 fps
- Firefly Forest - 55 fps
- Canyon Flight - 118 fps
- Deep Freeze - 70 fps
Negligible improvement over GTX 770, results are within margin of error. We are CPU bottlenecked.
Windows 7
3DMark 2006 breakdown, 1024x768:
- Return To Proxycon - 57 fps
- Firefly Forest - 59 fps
- Canyon Flight - 130 fps
- Deep Freeze - 74 fps
3DMark 2006 breakdown, 1600x900:
- Return To Proxycon - 57 fps
- Firefly Forest - 60 fps
- Canyon Flight - 127 fps
- Deep Freeze - 73 fps
3DMark 2006 breakdown, 1600x1200:
- Return To Proxycon - 57 fps
- Firefly Forest - 60 fps
- Canyon Flight - 124 fps
- Deep Freeze - 73 fps
Windows 7 score is a little bit higher. The reason is unknown, it could be better thread schedulling in Windows 7. The score is very close to Core 2 Duo E8600 in Windows XP, see Re: Any love for AM2? . Phenom II X4 965 BE would be needed to match it.
3DMark Vantage
3DMark Vantage is a DirectX 10 benchmark for Windows Vista.
Windows 7
3DMark Vantage breakdown, 1024x768:
- GPU test 1 (Jane Nash) - 97 fps
- GPU test 2 (New Calico) - 140 fps
3DMark Vantage breakdown, 1600x1200:
- GPU test 1 (Jane Nash) - 76 fps
- GPU test 2 (New Calico) - 81 fps
3DMark 2011
3DMark 2011 is a DirectX 11 benchmark for Windows 7. Custom preset was used. The only option changed was resolution.
Windows 7
3DMark 2011 breakdown, 1024x768:
- Graphics test 1 - 89 fps
- Graphics test 2 - 98 fps
- Graphics test 3 - 114 fps
- Graphics test 4 - 55 fps
- Physics test - 12 fps
- Combined test - 18 fps
3DMark 2011 breakdown, 1600x1200:
- Graphics test 1 - 44 fps
- Graphics test 2 - 45 fps
- Graphics test 3 - 66 fps
- Graphics test 4 - 31 fps
- Physics test - 12 fps
- Combined test - 18 fps
Games tested:
Windows XP
- F.E.A.R. (2005) - in 1600x1200 with max settings we get 212 average fps in built-in benchmark.
- Call of Duty 4 Modern Warfare (2007) - in 1600x1200 we get 250-500 fps (330 when aiming at tower with scope) in the initial mission outside of shooting room.
- World in Conflict (2007) - in 1600x1200 we then get 48 average fps in built-in benchmark with the best visual quality settings.
- Crysis (2007) - in 1600x1200 average fps in benchmark is 60 without full screen anti aliasing. Everything else was set to max. When 4x anti aliasing is enabled, we get 58 average fps.
- S.T.A.L.K.E.R. (2007) - in 1600x1200 with max details we get 70-230 fps outside in the first mission
- Far Cry 2 (2008) - with max settings, in 1600x1200 we get 80 fps in the built-in "Demo Ranch" benchmark and 41 fps in the "Action Scene" benchmark.
- Need for Speed: Undercover (2008) - in 1600x1200 we get 40-65 fps in the city at the main menu. Not enough for enjoyable experience due to lows.
- Colin McRae: Dirt 2 (2009) - with ultra settings, in 1600x1200 we get 97 average fps in the built-in benchmark.
- Tom Clancy's H.A.W.X. 2 (2010) - with max settings, anti aliasing set to 4x, in 1600x1200 we get 148 average fps in the built-in benchmark
Windows 7
- Crysis (2007) - in dx10 mode in 1600x1200 we get 47 average fps with very high quality and 4x anti aliasing in built-in benchmark. In dx9 mode with high details and 4x anti aliasing we get 58 fps.
- Grand Theft Auto IV (2008) - in 1600x1200 we get 49 average fps in the built-in benchmark with very high quality, view distance 50, detail distance 60, vehicle density 51 (double values from defaults). 11 FPS less than GTX 580.
- Resident Evil 5 (2009) - in 1600x1200 with max details and 4x anti aliasing we get 80 fps in fixed benchmark and 152 fps in variable benchmark.
- S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Call of Pripyat (2009) - in 1600x1200 with max details (ultra) except for full screen anti-aliasing, dx11 mode we get the following results in the standalone benchmark: day 135 fps, night 151 fps, rain 181 fps, sun shafts 128 fps.
- Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War II (2009) - with ultra settings, in 1600x1200 we get 54 average fps in the built-in benchmark.
- Metro 2033 (2010) - in 1600x1200 we get average 47 fps with very high quality except for SSAA and PhysX. With SSAA enabled we get average 36 fps. With PhysX enabled we get average 23 fps. With both SSAA and PhysX we get average 20 fps.
- Mafia II (2010) - in 1600x1200 we get average 108 fps with max settings including antialiasing, 16x anisotropic filtering but without Apex PhysX. With medium PhysX we get average 34 fps. With high PhysX we get average 32 fps.
- Aliens vs. Predator (2010) - in 1600x1200 with max details except for full screen anti-aliasing we get 147 fps
- Batman: Arkham City (2011) - in 1600x1200 we get average 121 fps with very high quality and FXAA high anti-aliasing without PhysX. With PhysX set to normal we get average 58 fps. With PhysX set to high we get average 49 fps.
- Sniper Elite V2 (2012) - in 1600x1200 with max details except for supersampling we get 141 fps
SiSoft Sandra 2013:
- memory bandwidth 9.75GB/s, 77% bandwidth efficiency
- cache bandwidth L1: 248GB/s, L2: 122GB/s, L3: 42GB/s
Conclusion about Phenom II X4 955 BE 3.2Ghz with GeForce GTX 780 and DDR2 800:
- it is a good choice for Windows XP era games (2002-2006)
- decent coverage of Windows Vista era (2007-2009)
- decent coverage of Windows 7 era (2010-2012), but some titles may have to be played with reduced settings, especially PhysX which needs to be off. Usage of PhysX probably requires a much stronger CPU.
- minimal benefit over GTX 770 even in late games. It seems GTX 680/770 is more than sufficient for Phenom II X4 955.
- it makes sense to use GTX 770 if the intention is to play early Windows 7 games as well without full screen anti-aliasing / PhysX.
- we saw a noticable regression in Grand Theft Auto IV. 11 fps less than GTX 580.
- I can recommend this AM3 4 core CPU for AM2+ systems even though it is a bit of a stretch as the top AM2+ only CPU is Phenom II X4 940 BE, which can be recommended as well.
- note: Phenom II X4 945/955/965 is not compatible with all AM2+ boards, it requires a dual power-plane. If not available, the CPU will run at 800Mhz. It is not resolvable via BIOS update. If your board doesn't have this feature, use Phenom II X4 940 BE.
- users considering Phenom II X4 965 or later will be better off in an AM3 board which introduced DDR3, SATA 3.0, USB 3.0.
Although I do have a GeForce 980 (Ti) available for testing, since we have already hit a wall it would be meaningless.
Initially, based on a few Vista era (2007-2009) titles it looked like AM2+ may struggle, but with Phenom II X4 955 BE coupled with a good GPU, it actually improves in Windows 7 era as dx11 games start to take advantage of more than 2 cores. The only pre-requisite is PhysX being off. It is thus able to cover a long period spanning Windows XP, Windows Vista and Windows 7.
Pentium III 900E, ECS P6BXT-A+, 384MB RAM, GeForce FX 5600 128MB, Voodoo 2 12MB, Yamaha SM718 ISA
Athlon 64 3400+, Gigabyte GA-K8NE, 2GB RAM, GeForce GTX 275 896MB, Sound Blaster Audigy 2 ZS
Phenom II X6 1100, Asus 990FX, 32GB RAM, GeForce GTX 980 Ti