nathanieltolbert wrote on Today, 03:23:
I really wish I had taken those Electronic Engineering courses when I went back to school.
I'm not sure if this topic here is something that is taught in Electronic Engineering courses 😉
Anyway, it would be a huge coincidence to me if the newly bought EEPROM would have the exact same failure than the one you had.
IIRC you could program the "new" EEPROM and the board works as before, right? That tells me the problem must be elsewhere.
Still the question stands if the NVRAM within the southbridge really holds the CMOS data, i. e. the settings you make in the BIOS. I think this can only be answered by an ASUS BIOS engineer or someone you could have a look into the BIOS routines and understand what's done there. Things change over time and ways to do things too. Like the RTC, that was for long time an external component, getting part of the chipset the CMOS memory could also have moved into the chipset for whatever reason.
But what does that tell us? If the no-NVRAM failure message relates to the NVRAM within the southbridge then there must be a problem anywhere around there. Since all NVRAM accesses are allegedly totally internal to the southbridge there can't be any external components or buses involved which rules out any passive parts defect imho. Looking at the board there also aren't many components around the BIOS chip itself that could be damaged and if so the symptoms might be worse.
I don't know... I don't like pointing towards something without beeing at least half way sure. But what let's me wonder are the other things you described (slow system, drive problems, no boot with an ISA card installed). These all could have to do with the southbridge or anything around it... I guess you already inspected all components in this area as well as looked for board/trace damages of any kind? The battery is inserted and working correctly? Did you try any other ISA card and have you inspected the ISA slot thoroughly (contacts and solder joints)?
Very tricky case...
RetroPC: K6-III+/400ATZ @6x83@1.7V / CT-5SIM / 2x 64M SDR / 40G HDD / RIVA TNT / V2 SLI / CT4520
ModernPC: Phenom II 910e @ 3GHz / ALiveDual-eSATA2 / 4x 2GB DDR-II / 512G SSD / 750G HDD / RX470