MattRocks wrote on 2026-04-16, 20:47:What I have done is order my PSUs by cheapness, and then pair the more premium PSUs to CPUs matched by era: […]
Show full quote
What I have done is order my PSUs by cheapness, and then pair the more premium PSUs to CPUs matched by era:
AT/ATX transition MMX <-> 5V-focussed AOpen FSP300-60GT
AMD K6-2 ATX <-> 5v-focussed Delta DPS-400WB C
Athlon XP 2400+ <-> 5V/12V transition Antec TruePower Trio TP3-550
Athlon 64 2400+ <-> 12V-focussed Corsair RM750x
None of these systems, except possibly the Athlon XP 2400, need PSUs with really heavy 5V rails.
Really, the only systems that need 5V-heavy PSUs are Athlon/XP systems that don't have a 4-pin 12V CPU connector on the motherboard (most socket A motherboards), a few (very few) Pentium 4 systems that also lack a 4-pin 12V CPU connector on their motherboards, and any dual Pentium II/3 or Pentium Pro systems. For just about everything else, any PSU that can do 15 Amps on the 5V rail should be OK. Most single socket Pentium 2 and 3 systems will have a TDP of less than 60 Watts (typically less than 40W for the P3's), so 5V rail becomes relatively irrelevant.
With that said, the AOpen might be best relegated to the Athlon XP system if it doesn't have a 4-pin 12V CPU connector. Everything else should work in whatever other combination you like.
... well OK, some PSUs don't like to work with too little load and may not start, with the MMX and K6-2 systems most likely to be problematic here, as they tend to have pretty low power requirements.
MattRocks wrote on 2026-04-16, 20:47:
Having read the thread linked above, I feel somewhat... unsure... because I'm not an electrician.
Attached is a photo so you can see it has a fair number of expansion cards that I don't want to smoke. If the AOpen FPS PSU fails, is there any risk of damage to the components in my AT/ATX transition tower or is protecting?
TLDR about the AOpen PSU: it's 5VSB (5V standby) circuit could be potentially dangerous if any of its electrolytic caps fail. This can kill the motherboard and any attached hardware that directly draws power from the 5VSB rail... so possibly keyboards, mice, and/or LAN cards with WOL enabled. The cards that should be safe are anything not connected to the 5VSB rail - e.g. CPU, RAM, video cards, sound cards, HDDs, optical and floppy drives, just to name the most common stuff.
If recapped, though, that AOpen PSU should be a pretty solid 5V-heavy PSU.
cyclone3d wrote on 2026-04-16, 21:20:
If you get a high enough wattage ATX PSU, the 5v rails will generally be strong enough.
Yes, but then there's this possibility that some modern PSUs don't like to start with too low of a load, especially on the 12V rail.
Also, it really depends how the 3.3V and 5V rails are generated on modern PSUs.
Budget PSUs are more likely to use a group-regulated design, so they could still do very poorly when they are loaded more on the 5V rail than the 12V rail.
The better-designed PSUs will use buck-regulators to generate the 5V and 3.3V rails directly from the 12V rail... in which case, the PSU isn't going to care which rail you load it on the most, so long as you don't try to ask more than what the PSU is stated to provide on the label (in terms of the 3.3V and 5V rails.) Worth noting is that for such PSUs, there is usually no "combined" 3.3V and 5V power ratings to speak of, even if the label says there is. On PSUs that use buck-regulator cards/modules for the 3.3V and 5V rail, each of these can provide the current on the label independently from the other (since they both use the 12V rail for power.)
From MattRocks PSU list, I can tell you that the Antec Truepower and Delta are both ground-regulated units... so may not do too well on a 5V-heavy PC. However, they are also pretty sound PSUs and likely won't have problems starting even at very low loads.
The Corsair I'm not sure about. I have a similar one, though I don't remember if it was exactly an RM750.
MattRocks wrote on 2026-04-13, 17:03:
The one that blew up was a Mercury, which is one of the worst PSUs. I suspect Mercury may have been a high street store's own label for whatever was cheapest in the grey market.
If memory serves me right, Mercury was made by Leadman - the same company that makes the infamous PowMax PSUs. Real shoddy stuff at best. Even their old XT units were cutting corners like crazy... except the steel case for whatever reason.