First post, by Nemo1985
Hello fellow vogonians, over the internet, there is conflicting information about what the best chips are. Every experience is subjective and biased, and some are completely BS.
What I decided to do is test modules (mostly 1GB, but not only) to find out which ones are able to support the holy grail of timings!
Motherboard: DFI NF4 SLI-DR Expert (EX041106 Merlin BIOS)
Notes:
Drive Strength: Leaving DRAM/Data Drive Strength on AUTO can severely limit modules at 250MHz due to poor signal integrity. Setting these manually (8/4 is the best setting for 250 or 8/2 is the best setting for 200) is mandatory to unlock the true potential of these chips.
Modules with * are tested in dual channel configuration.
All modules are tested with 1T CPC unless stated otherwise; a 2T setting indicates that 1T was not stable.
For all the tests, voltage will be increased up to a maximum of v2.80 (which was the historical warranty limit for most high-end DDR1 modules). The only exceptions are Winbond BH5/CH5-based kits, which are excluded from this limit as they notoriously require much higher voltages (v3.20+).
A result is only validated after a complete pass of Memtest without any error.
1GB modules:
Hynix HY5DU12822DTP-D43:
750A (Year 2007 week 50):
200: 2-3-2-4 v2.70 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
250: 3-3-3-4 v2.60 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
008S (Year 2010 week 8) Corsair BP808:
200: 3-3-2-4 v2.50 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
250: 3-4-3-4 v2.52 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
Micron -5B F (MT16VDDT12864AY-40BF2) 2008 week 36:
200: 2.5-3-2-5 v2.80 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
250: 3-3-3-5 v2.80 (Drive Strength: 8/4)
Nanya/Elixir CS-5T:
200: 2-3-2-5 2T v2.52 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
250: 2.5-4-3-5 2T v2.63 (Drive Strength: 8/4)
Qimonda HYB25D512800DE-5 (0848 & 0902 datecodes)*:
200: 2-3-2-5 v2.50 (Drive Strength: 8/2)
250: 3-3-2-5 v2.50 (Drive Strength: 8/4)
Samsung TCCC BGA 746 (Year 2007 week 46) FAKE*:
200: 2-3-2-5 v2.31 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
250: 2.5-3-2-5 v2.60 (Drive Strength: 8/4)
Samsung LCCC 940 943 (Year 2009 week 40 and 43)*:
200: 2.5-3-2-5 v2.40 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
250: 3-3-3-5 2T v2.40 (Drive Strength: 8/4)
512MB modules:
Corsair Value Select (unknown chips) VS512MB400 (8 chips):
200: 2.5-2-3-3 v2.53 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
250: 3-3-3-3 v2.53 (Drive Strength: AUTO)
Infineon HYB25D512800BE-5 (8 chips) datecode 614:
200: 2-3-2-5 v2.50 (Drive Strength: 8/2)
230: 2.5-3-2-5 v2.50 (Drive Strength: 8/2)
250: CRASH
Infineon HYB25D256800CE-5 (16 chips) datecode 624:
200: 2-3-2-5 v2.50 (Drive Strength: 8/2)
250: CRASH
