I used to play modern games c. 2020 with a Gateway ev910 (may be wrong on the model number). It's a fairly nice 19" model from around 2000. I had it primarily for period correct games, but used it sometimes on modern games for the novelty.
How useable it was depended on the game. Virtually nothing scaled right to 1024x768, my preferred resolution, so I was at 1600x1200. This gives a soft but smooth image, but many games were hard to read.
Birds-eye view strategy games like Wargame were unpleasant and hard to play; I just found it too hard to read the playing field. War Thunder RB air was frustrating, RB ground battles were okay; this was probably the most fun I had with this setup. Destiny 2 was fairly easy to read the playing field but I found it similarly unpleasant.
In comparison, I find period correct games like Ground Control, UT, and the ilk to look great at 1024, with no problems like a hard to read UI, lack of contrast in the playing field, or anything like that.
I generally do not play modern games today, but when I do, I always run then on a 21.5" LCD. I don't like big screens 😉
I wouldn't recommend anyone seriously consider playing most modern games with a CRT. Maybe a high end 21" would do okay, but my Gateway never cut the mustard, and I can only imagine what a 17" is like.
GA-M61SME-S2 + Athlon 64 x2 4400+ + 2GB DDR2-800 + ATi 3870
GA-6BXC + Pentium II 300 + 512MB PC-133 + nVidia TNT
GA-686BX + Pentium III 550 + 256MB PC-133 + nVidia TNT2 M64
Soon -> Socket A, Socket 7