Ozzuneoj wrote on 2026-08-21, 05:58:Whew... boy... I am sorry to do this to you but I recently discovered this:
https://digital-archivist.com/capturing-analo … re-d […]
Show full quote
BitWrangler wrote on 2026-08-21, 00:05:
Dang, by the time I ACTUALLY get my VHS converted to digital, I will have bought 11 ways to do it 🤣
Whew... boy... I am sorry to do this to you but I recently discovered this:
https://digital-archivist.com/capturing-analo … re-differences/
https://github.com/oyvindln/vhs-decode
As far as I can tell, that is the end-all be-all of recording from VHS or other analog tape formations (like Video8).
I just stumbled upon all this a few weeks ago when I discovered a camcorder that was owned by a sibling of mine that passed away several years ago. There is a whole bunch of footage from the 90s that I'd totally forgotten about. I need a slightly higher end Sony camcorder with the proper pin connector to do one of these RF FM direct captures, but I plan to do it as soon as a find one. I was not at all impressed with the quality I was getting from a simple Elgato USB capture device I borrowed from a friend.
Anyway... if this is way number 12, at least you can tell yourself the search is over. It doesn't get better than this and it isn't even very expensive (assuming you have a decent device to actually play the tapes).
Hmmm, it does not seem very time or storage space efficient. I am not up for devoting a quarter of a terabyte per tape, then have conversion speeds equivalent to rendering a Pixar movie. I have got maybe two tapes it could be worth it on, but for the rest I'm looking for something that gives me something I can watch without annoying me too much, and takes only hours per tape not days.
Which USB convertors of all types and flavors will definitely not do, some of them only have 6 bit DACs. Few of them do full framerate/resolution, many of them overheat and crash from heavy use. Oddly, the general hardware and home electronic reviewer types seem fixated on them, like nothing else exists.
That may be a reason why that page reads like "If you want personal transportation, the choices are, roller skates, skateboard, or a Rolls Royce Phantom." missing a HELL of a lot in the middle there buddy. So since his range of comparison is strange to say the least, it is hard to know whether his solution compares more to the nailed together push scooter end, or a full fledged motor vehicle. I mean it's probably the cryoflux version of tape archival, but how many people here bother with that just to backup a floppy?
Hierarchy goes something like
1stgen USB < 2nd gen USB < best of the ISA capture cards < 1st gen consumer PCI 90s < 2nd gen consumer PCI 00s < later higher end consumer to prosumer stuff which there is a lot of arguing about < Full professional video workstations.
Of which, this PCI card should be in the higher end consumer bracket. (Yeah pinnacle also had a crappy USB dongle to sell cheap at BestBuy and that might have been the more familiar association)
Unicorn herding operations are proceeding, but all the totes of hens teeth and barrels of rocking horse poop give them plenty of hiding spots.