I went down a bit of a rabbit hole here looking at Creative's lawsuit against Aureal. This is from Aureal's response on appeal, and the bits of the story it tells are fascinating. If you want to see the whole docket at the trial level it's here: https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/10838061 … -semiconductor/
Writeup from Brief
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Creative and Aureal are competitors in the personal computer sound card market. Creative filed this patent infringement lawsuit on February 26, 1998 against Aureal, alleging that Aureal’s innovative Vortex technology infringed U.S. Patent No. 5,342,990 (“the ‘990 patent”). Six months later, on August 14, 1998, Creative filed its Motion for Preliminary Injunction, which the district court denied on October 28, 1998. A22.
A. THE PARTIES
1. Creative
Creative is the behemoth of the sound card industry and has dominated the market since 1981. Creative currently employs approximately 5,000 people and reported revenues of $1.234 billion in fiscal year 1998. A670. Creative’s activities in the computer sound card industry have accounted for over sixty percent (60%) of all sound card sales in the past ten years. Id.
In 1985, David Rossum allegedly invented a musical synthesis keyboard that utilized “convolution” and “cache memory” to provide digital audio functions. Mr. Rossum’s invention had limited applications though, and for almost five years no one filed a patent application for this alleged invention. In 1990, an application was finally filed, creating the patent-in-suit. The patent was assigned to E-Mu Systems, Inc., a wholly-owned subsidiary of Creative.
Until February of 1998, the patent essentially lay dormant. It was never litigated or licensed, nor has anyone in the industry expressly supported it. The ‘990 patent issued on August 30, 1994.
2. Aureal
Aureal, on the other hand, is a relatively small company dedicated to advancing the frontiers of audio technology. Aureal was founded in 1995, and now employs 120 people and for the twelve month period ending September 1998, Aureal reported revenues of $14.7 million. The engineers that would come to form Aureal’s core technology group recognized early on that the technology at the heart of Creative’s empire could not keep pace with the market’s demand for enhanced speed, greater storage capacity, and affordability. A797. Thus, the company’s mission was to create innovative sound technology, superior to that available in the market, with the ultimate goal of competing for Creative’s large share of the market.
Aureal succeeded in developing the next generation of sound card technology. Today, Aureal’s main products are the PCI-based Vortex AU8820 and AU8830 audio semiconductor chips, which employ Aureal’s acclaimed A3D technology. Aureal sells the majority of its chips to sound card vendors, including Diamond Multimedia, Turtle Beach, and, in Europe, Teratec. A795. Aureal also has developed and licensed its 3-D audio technology, including algorithms for A3D Interactive™ and A3D Surround™, which accelerate and position audio streams in full 3D space. Aureal has invested over $25 million in independent research and development, and has received numerous patents relating to its award-winning A3D technology. A760; A792; A795.
B. HISTORY OF THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CREATIVE AND AUREAL
Creative admits that it was aware of the industry’s burgeoning interest in the type of sound technology Aureal now specializes in as early as 1994, the year in which the ‘990 patent issued. A676. By 1996, Creative had determined that PCI audio bus products, like Aureal’s, were essential to maintain its marketshare and portfolio; however, Creative had not yet developed its own new product. A676-77.
In June 1996, Aureal met with Creative’s representatives who were interested in Aureal’s A3D PCI-based technology. A792. According to the representatives, Creative had been “unsuccessful in convincing Microsoft to use [Creative’s own] 3D” technology and thus Creative was “now willing to use others’ technology.” Id. In fact, Microsoft’s announcement that it would no longer use the old Creative technology had forced Creative and others in the industry to develop PCI-based technology. A693. Creative represented that it was interested in purchasing Aureal audio semiconductor chips such as the ASP-301 chip-set (the precursor to the Vortex chips), or licensing Aureal’s A3D technology, all of which are PCI-based as Microsoft had specified. A792.
Three months later, Creative again met with Aureal, representing that it was considering purchasing Aureal’s ASP-301 chip-set to interface with Creative’s new 8010 chip. A793. In October 1996, at Creative’s request, Aureal gave Creative a demonstration and tutorial on its A3D technology. Id. Throughout this negotiation period, Aureal provided Creative with documentation regarding Aureal’s chips,² including the data sheet for the ASP-301 chip set, which contained a detailed description of what would come to be known as the Vortex chip. Id.
² This documentation reflects the very PCI-based architecture that Creative is complaining about in this lawsuit over two years later.
Because Creative’s own product development in PCI-based technology was delayed, Creative continued to express interest in purchasing and using Aureal’s ASP-301 chip-set to bring its products to market sooner. Id. Creative also expressed interest in licensing Aureal’s A3D technology, after the launch of the 8010/ASP 301 program. Id. On July 1, 1997, Aureal sent Creative its proposal for licensing Aureal’s 3D Interactive™ and 3D Surround™ technologies. A698. No agreement was reached regarding any licensing of Aureal’s technology.
In July 1997, Aureal introduced its Vortex product line, including the Vortex AU8820 PCI-based AC’97 Digital Audio Accelerator. A794. In late July, Creative met with Aureal again and stated, among other things, that it was interested in building authoring cards (utilizing an A3D license it would obtain from Aureal), and developing a sound card that would include Aureal’s now allegedly infringing chips. Creative represented again that “time to market” concerns attracted it to Aureal’s technology. Id.
On August 20, 1997, once more, at Creative’s request, Aureal shipped Creative an evaluation board containing Aureal’s 8820 Vortex chip. Creative kept the board for several weeks. Id. During this period, Creative apparently examined the operation, functionality, sound quality and cost of the board. A837-40. Creative’s General Counsel and other key personnel analyzed the pricing, performance and compatibility of Aureal’s Vortex technology. A652-53. By this time, Hawley was involved in project management for the E-Mu 10K1 chip, which Creative would include in its SoundBlaster™ Live! product. A652. Based upon this first-hand examination of Aureal’s Vortex technology, Creative’s in-house counsel apparently believed that Aureal might be infringing Creative’s ‘990 patent. A651. Creative did not tell or suggest to Aureal, however, that there might be any infringement.
Creative also contacted Aureal during 1997 about the possibility of buying the company to acquire all of its technology. A797. No transaction occurred, and Creative remained without a PCI-based product. Desperate for technical expertise and the ability to get product to market, Creative eventually purchased Ensoniq, another company specializing in digital sound technology, in the first quarter of 1998. A702.
In September 1997, Dell Computer requested bids for PCI-based sound cards to be installed in certain of its computers. Creative previously had supplied Dell with ISA-based sound cards, but it had to compete with many others in the industry for this new opportunity in PCI-based sound cards. A686. Moreover, Dell was concerned about Creative’s past service. A679-81. Thus, Creative knew (or should have known) that winning the Dell contract would not necessarily be easy. Creative submitted its AWE64D sound card, which would contain its 8008 chip. A678; A694. Dell chose ESS Inc.’s sound card over Creative’s.³ When ESS could not perform under Dell’s schedule, Dell looked for a company that could deliver technology on time. Dell chose Turtle Beach, who, in turn, had a long-standing relationship with Aureal. The Turtle Beach sound card carried by Dell contains Aureal’s 8820 chip.
³ Creative could not have won the Dell contract in any event, because its 8008 chip was not ready for market until March 1998, long after Dell’s due date. A679; A685.
Undaunted, Creative was still trying to sell a PCI-based sound card. Creative had planned its retail launch of SoundBlaster™ Live! for February 1998, but was unable to meet that release date because, among other things, its engineers had not completed the software support for the driver architecture. A626-27. Creative then planned to launch SoundBlaster™ Live! in June 1998, but once again could not do so because the driver architecture was incomplete. A626-28. Creative finally completed the necessary software work for SoundBlaster™ Live! in July 1998 (A644), and launched SoundBlaster™ Live! in August 1998. A207. Creative admits that its inability to meet its February and June 1998 launch dates adversely affected its reputation in the industry. A628-29.
The poor performance of its SoundBlaster™ Live! product continues to harm Creative’s reputation. Throughout at least late summer and early fall, SoundBlaster™ Live! suffered, in Creative’s own words, a “critical bug”—crashing and leaving the user with nothing but a blue screen. A646; A690-91. As of the date of the preliminary injunction briefing, SoundBlaster™ Live! still had not been released in any market except retail, and Creative had sold relatively few units. A641; A643.
Creative never mentioned to Aureal any issue of infringement until it filed this lawsuit in 1998, despite Creative’s examination of Aureal’s technology and its interest in licensing that technology from Aureal as early as 1996. A794-95. Aureal had no reason whatsoever to believe that Creative had any legal issues with Aureal’s technology or products. Id. After all, why would a large successful company such as Creative seek to buy or license technology to which it had superior patent rights? It wouldn’t. Thus, Aureal continued to develop its technology. A797. In fact, during the periods between Aureal’s first meeting with Creative in June 1996 and Aureal’s August 1997 shipment of the Vortex evaluation board and chip to Creative, and through the present, Aureal expended enormous resources in developing, refining and marketing its Vortex chips and A3D technology, including over $25 million in research and development alone. A760; A792.
By the first quarter of 1998, Creative believed that the proliferation of a Vortex-based sound card would irreversibly push down the price of at least some of its products. A632-33. Creative thus suspected infringement in 1997, filed an infringement lawsuit in early 1998, and believed it was being “irreversibly” harmed in early 1998, but did not bring its preliminary injunction motion for several months later, in August, 1998.