I would go for a motherboard with the following criteria:
1.) Socket 7 or Super Socket 7 Motherboard - Has the highest compatibility when it comes to CPU selection of the respective class.
2.) ATX Form Factor - AT form factor requires the hard power switch, the AT PSU and requires an AT casing. Though AT casing is not difficult to get, ATX casing is more common and there are many,many choices of casings available. It's much easier to replace an ATX PSU, than the AT's counterpart. if something happens to it. And ATX form factors have the PS2 keyboard and mouse ports built-in. Much easier to get a PS2 mouse/keyboard nowadays. You can use any usb mouse or keyboard with a USB-PS2 adaptor. And remember the keyboard connector "hole" drilled at the back of the AT casing? 😉
Additional Luxury - Socket 7 with AGP slot. Some early AGP versions were available. Can be expensive. Will be able to use early AGP cards. But since this is a first generation AGP, I'm not sure of it's efficiency and/or potential conflicts/problems and the voltage considerations, since I haven't used them yet.