Jo22 wrote:This may vary all over the world, but general speaking, institutions like archives and libraries are protected by law.
In simple […]
Show full quote
This may vary all over the world, but general speaking, institutions like archives and libraries are protected by law.
In simple words, they -or rather culture itself- stand(s) higher than the copyright.
Anyway, I'm speaking highly under correction here and provide no warranties for whatsoever.
This matter sure is very debatable. Normally, though, a copyright holder can peacefully request the removal of its content.
I'm not saying you're wrong, of course, but if for argument's sake, archive.org is protected by law, then presumably they wouldn't have to take down an item even if it's copyright holder requested that it be taken down, or even threatened to sure the archive? That does seem morally wrong, true, but if the archive is protected by law BUT also has to take down anything requested to be taken down by the copyright holder, then how is that different from a pirate putting up a copy of the item for download from his own site, and the pirate being willing to take down the item from his site if the copyright holder does ask for it to be taken down?
I mean, say archive.org puts up say DOOM (the 2016 game) for download, and I also put up the same game on my pirate website too, for download, and we both are willing to remove it if the copyright holder says so, then there's no real difference between me and archive.org in practise, even if archive.org's taking down of the game is due to their wanting to respect the wishes of DOOM's makers, whereas my taking the game down is because I'm scared that the game's makers, who have e-mailed me to say remove it from your website, might well take me to court?
See what I mean? If archive.org are protected by law but would still be willing to remove any item that the copyright holders then gets in touch and says "Remove that from the download page", then there's no practical difference between archive.org and a pirate site, at least until the take down e-mail is sent.
BTW, I don't have a pirate site, nor even any other sort of web site (or a twitter account even), I'm just saying that the situation with sites like archive.org does seem a little strange.