PCBONEZ wrote:@SSTV2
I'm sorry that you've never encounter it.
Your lack of experience is not my responsibility.
I have expected at least a constructive argument from you @PCBONEZ about the incompatibility issue of early stepping 440BX chipsets with PIII CPUs, that you have claimed, but istead of receiving one, I got insulted personally due to my "lack of experience". We can both play this game, buddy.
PCBONEZ wrote:
That's right, and Asus company was and still is known for not being a slacker in motherboard designing and manufacturing field, OPs motherboard was already made future proof, because a 440BX chipset was never meant for mendocino Celerons only, in the first place. Check its FSB selection table, why would they bother including a 133MHz FSB option for Celeron only MB at the time before PIII even officially supported it? OP only needs to check for continuity between RESET pins on the socket and this argument of PIII CPUs being incompatible with it will be officially laid to rest.
PCBONEZ wrote:You might try reading the original spec instead of the update that came out a year later.
That doesn't make any sense, what will you have to compare the earliest documentation to, back when the PIII CPUs didn't even exist yet, that's just genius... I'd provided you the latest specifications change document for i440BX chips that I could find, which list all the differences between B1 and C1 stepping chips.
PCBONEZ wrote:If it could support P3 later on it would be out of character for Asus not to come out with a BIOS update with the P3 microcode.
There is none.
That might be true, but it can be checked anytime by inspecting CPU uCode table in its latest BIOS, even if it's not there, that is the least issue of the mod procedure for the proper CPU support.
PCBONEZ wrote:Additionally with all the die-hard Asus fanatics out there if it were possible to upgrade it there would articles or posts online telling how.
There are none.
The how-to mod guides for PPGA only motherboards to support FCPGA CPUs are universal and are all over the place to this day...
About your experience with Intel server board, it would not surprise me at all if the original chipset creator would make older boards incompatibe with newer CPUs intentionally, it's not the first and the last time Intel pulled such stunt on consumers, but your case of artificially-incompatible-made motherboard does not prove that early steppings of a 440BX chipset were incompatible with PIIIs. The table you'd attached doesn't show clear motherboard revisions for both PII-only and PII/PIII N440BXs, they had to change something in hardware level to make MB compatible with PIII, but I'm sure you already know all of this.
PCBONEZ wrote:The 370 board I mentioned was a different brand but specs wise identical to the OP's.
It came original with a 533 Mendocino and […]
Show full quote
The 370 board I mentioned was a different brand but specs wise identical to the OP's.
It came original with a 533 Mendocino and yes it had the ATI chip too.
No boot with a P3 or even a higher Celeron.
No interest in that one then. It went in a junk box and was replaced with a P4.
I experienced it first hand and I can care less if you believe it or not.
You clearly lacked the experience back then, but I'm sure you'd figure out how to tackle such issue now 😉
PCBONEZ wrote:If you are so certain I'm wrong then put your OWN money where you mouth is, snag one off ebay (there are several) and you show me.
Short of that you are just blowing smoke about something you have no experience with.
I won't waste nor my time, nor my money on some low-end motherboard just to please you, but I've cared enough and made some screenshots and photos of an ACER V66XA OEM motherboard, that is based on an early B1 stepping 440BX chipset with a working PIII Katmai on it.
The attachment 1.jpg is no longer available
You can't directly see the SSPEC on the northbridge due to the glued heatsink, but a sticker nearby provides all the info needed.
The attachment 2.jpg is no longer available
The attachment Acer.jpg is no longer available
The attachment B1.jpg is no longer available
The attachment PIII.jpg is no longer available
This motherboard is based on a B1 stepping 440BX, it's OEM, never had BIOS updates for PIII CPU support from either of three companies that used it (ACER, Siemens and IBM), yet a proof of a working system of such config is in front of your eyes. Your arguments are invalid.