Thermalwrong wrote on 2021-03-26, 00:25:
I think the draw of the YMF724/744/754 is not so much where it's in late Pentium III laptops, but that they were fairly common in laptops. And as a PCI card, are one of the few PCI cards with a real OPL3. Probably nicer for installing into newer systems.
I agree with your issues with the Sony YMF audio too, getting the drivers to work with Windows 98 / ME is often impossible and something about how those audio chips are implemented in the Vaios makes installing the specific driver essential rather than optional.
It's not nearly as common as you might think (at least not the PCI based 724/44/54s) - during the PCI / 440 chipset era (probably anything after, say, P54C and before the rise of AC97) the major laptop vendors tended to include these:
Toshiba -
ESS Maestro or AC-XG, some DS-XG on Satellite Pro models. Their AMD budget line uses Ali chipsets that might have the embedded Trident 4dWave inside.
Dell -
Crystal CS4237B, Neomagic AC97 (no pure DOS SB support), then ESS Maestro/Allegro starting with the 3800/CPx models and going to AC97 after the C600/4100 or the C810/8100 (the next models have Crystal CS4205s)
IBM -
Mostly a Crystal shop, 3 mainline models and the Acer designed I-series have the ESS Solo-1. IBM went full AC97 with the X22/T23 via the CS4299s, if I remember correctly.
Compaq -
Mostly ESS based on the Intel side, some of the 1800T series are ESS Solo-1, then the rest are Maestro based up and until the n610c (which is right during the Carly Fiorina/HP merger). Their AMD models are similar to the Toshibas.
HP -
Mostly an ESS shop back on the Omnibook days. HP's laptop division were pretty much subsumed by Compaq's after merger.
NEC -
No idea, they are not that popular in the US, and their market segmentation is nearly as bad as Sony. Probably some Alis and SiS chipsets in their fleets.
Sony -
The Sony Vaio line (at least the PCG-SR/C1 series) are one of the few that seems to use Yamaha DS/AC-XG consistently, at least between its Intel and Transmeta machines.
(its on-brand considering that Sony named it VAIO to stand for Video/Audio, Input/Output) They do have a few AMD models that is the exception to the rule. They went full AC97 around the time their machines shipped with Mobile Radeons.
If you see a high number of Yamahas, think about whether they are the PCI (any YMF > 720), or ISA based (YMF 262/289/715/719). I tend to see the latter, especially when dealing with the older IBM I-series and Toshibas from back-in-the-days.
As for whether Yamaha YMF PCI models are a good idea in laptops? *eeeeeeeh* - it depends. The DS-XGs are slightly less compatible than the ESS Solo-1, at least in my experience when it came to hardware where you cannot shuffle cards (I have a YMF724 in one of my single PCI slot thin clients, an AOpen Cobra 744 in another, and the 754 in the Vaio SR9GK) and you have no idea whether someone actually ran lines between the southbridge to the sound chip to make it function like a PC-PCI link - it's also not something that can be remedied easily. Setupds also seem less stable than the esssolo/essaudio equivalent.
*ugh*. I really need to hunt down some Vaio laptop recovery CD ISOs...