First post, by Mondodimotori
- Rank
- Member
Got myself a PowerColor HD4870 PCS+1GB GDDR5 (the card I wish I had in 2008), arrived with the PCB sligtly bent towards the fan connector, and with issues both video and with driver. The image flickers and suffers from random black frames, even in Windows (XP SP3), while the driver crashes almost right away when starting any 3D application (like UNIGINE Heaven). Temps are normal, with max 60° on core and 70° on memory under load.
The system is my XP Rig with the E8600 at 4.0ghz, 4GB of ram and Lanparty DKP45 MOBO.
Here's what I did to troubleshoot it:
- Test multiple drivers: No success. Currently running Catalist 9.12
- Cleaning up the card and replacing thermal paste: UNIGINE takes longer to crash the first time, then it starts again like before. Flickering still there.
- Replacing VBIOS: No success. Card came with 011.013.000.002.000000 from 21 October '08 BIOS, changed it to 011.013.000.002.000000 from January'09, no change in behaviour. Then tested 011.013.000.002.000000 from july '09, cards presents heavy artifacts now. Currently I reinstalled the one from January '09, but I may reinstall the backup of the OG bios.
- Underclock the card with Catalist Control Center: The card comes with a factory OC of 780mhz core (from 750 stock) and 925mhz memory (from 900 stock), I reverted to stock HD4870 settings. Problems solved: Clocking the memory at 900mhz gets rid of flickering and black frames, clocking the core at 750mhz gets rid of the driver crashes. I was able to game for almost an hour without crashing at expected stock performances.
My question here: I've read some vintage reviews on Newegg and, apparenlty, several people did experience flickering issues with this particular model. I alredy got a refund for the card (without return) since it wasn't working as intended so, what can I do? Is there a way to edit the OG BIOS so that the card will reach max 750mhz on core and 900mhz on memory without using Catalist or MSI Afterburner? I noticed that the catalist control center is quite unreliable on Windows XP (I currently have a 6970 in the system, and Catalist will fail to install properly most of the times, no matter the driver revision), so I wanted to change max frequencies direclty at a BIOS level.
Or is it a pointless efforts, and those are signs of a dying card? I got another HD4870 (a reference model with blower design, which has a terrible fan curve that makes the card run at 80° core and 90° memory, requiring me to edit it in MSI afterburner anyway) and I wanted to test some Crossfire gaming. Should I just give up on this one and try another model?
PS: I'll ask it here since I'm alredy here: How do you cope with Catalist Control Center problems?
I have an HD6970 in this system as main GPU and the software fails to install properly lots of the times. I tested 12.1 and 12.3 drivers and I get the same result: The installation appears to go flawlessly, but then no matter how many times I click on "Catalist Control Center" it doesn't come up. I can see the process in task manager, but no show. No errors.
I know it can work becase before testing this 4870 it was working and I was using it to max out anisotropic filtering at the driver level. I even tried installing Catalist on its own, with video and audio installed separately, to no avail. Should I just give up Radeon for WIN XP gaming and just put in there the 560Ti I have as a spare?