VOGONS


First post, by Knaxia

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie

I've got a little personal project for a very specific type of build, but I have a hard time picking between two motherboards. I won't go too much in details but the two options I have are pretty much identical, apart from the Chipset and CPU support. They are both the same brand, all the same options in ports, internal slots, and so on.

-One is a Socket 478 for Pentium 4 , with SiS 648 & 963 chipsets
-One is a Socket 462 for Athlon XP, with SiS 746 & 963L chipsets

The 478 supports max 533 FSB and DDR 333. I have a P4 2.8Ghz 533Mhz that I already have will likely be the CPU I put in there.
The 462 supports max 333 FSB and DDR 333. I have an Athlon XP 2800+ 333Mhz that will be the CPU that goes in it.

The boards only have 2x DIMM so it will likely run 2x 256MB or 2x 512MB DDR 333.

I guess at this point, it turns down to two things:
-The classic P4 vs A-XP at the same "rating". I am not home right now, so I cannot check or remember which version I have of the P4 (Northwood or Prescott) or the A-XP (Thoroughbred or Barton).
-Which of both platform was the SiS chipset better optimized for in term stability, performance, compatibility and so on.

The system will mostly be used for some benchmarking and testing parts, and some old 3D games, will be running with Windows XP. There is no AGP slot on the system due to a onboard chip, which is the base reason of the purchase and I do not want this to affect the final decision.

Reply 1 of 3, by dionb

User metadata
Rank l33t++
Rank
l33t++

The southbridge determines most of the compatibility and stability, and that's basically the same here - the 'L' doesn't support IEEE1394 Firewire, otherwise they're identical. So expect exactly the same stability and compatibility.

I am puzzled by your question about performance and wanting to do benchmarks if you are going to be using onboard video. That will be far more of a bottleneck than whatever influence the chipset has on CPU performance (which will be mainly related to the memory controller). Also, a lot of boards with onboard VGA/GPU are very low-end board which might come with their own stability issues. I'm very suspicious that you aren't open about the exact models of the boards you are talking about. This reeks of PC Chips... if so, check for known stability/quality issues with the specific boards. Stability will be far more impacted by board quality than by any difference between these two very similar chipsets. Same regarding compatibility, both with CPUs and other devices.

As always when comparing totally different CPU architectures there is no single answer about performance. Speed rating is a marketing tool and is not nor was ever an objective way to compare CPUs. A P4 is better at highly predictable loads (few branches in code) requiring high raw memory throughput. So P4 tended to dominate photoshop and video manipulation benchmarks. Any software that actually used SSE2 instructions also got a boost on the P4. The Athlon was good at raw FPU and less predictable loads, which made it better for gaming, although ranking could differ significantly from game to game. If you're not familiar with that kind of nuance, you might want to do a good deal of reading up (in the 2000-2002 tech literature) before choosing and definitely before benchmarking anything.

Neither of these chipsets were considered the fastest for their platform, even at time of introduction, but both were competent.

One consideration you don't mention is if you will be swapping the CPU a lot. If so, Socket A - with its exposed CPU dies - is not a great platform. Core crunch is a real risk and that would be a strong argument to go for the better protected So478. Conversely, So478 CPUs run a good deal hotter, so if you don't want to swap CPUs around, an SoA system will be able to run with a quieter fan than an So478 system, particularly if it's a Prescott.

Reply 2 of 3, by Matth79

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Since neither of those chipsets have an IGP, I deduce that you may be looking at a couple of ECS models that combine a Xabre 200 graphics onboard.
The "rating" of the Athlons can sometimes be over enthusiastic, while the P4 may under perform as it's 533 FSB is being driven with single channel DDR 333

Reply 3 of 3, by Knaxia

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie
Matth79 wrote on 2026-11-14, 18:06:

Since neither of those chipsets have an IGP, I deduce that you may be looking at a couple of ECS models that combine a Xabre 200 graphics onboard.
The "rating" of the Athlons can sometimes be over enthusiastic, while the P4 may under perform as it's 533 FSB is being driven with single channel DDR 333

That is exactly the case. I wanted to post earlier but got busy. I didn't want that to affect the result, but I had to mention the lack of AGP so I don't get choices based on the graphic card I might put in so it might have sold it. I always loved , the Athlon XP, had many main PCs with it in the past, and also got many retro Socket A builds here. I have a bit less Pentium 4 systems, but I wasn't sure if SiS were strongest or weakest on either platforms during that generation. I've always had either Via or nvidia for XP, and straight Intel for the P4.