dr_st wrote on 2026-11-19, 08:54:
All gamepads suck. Joysticks make sense if you need analog precision. Fighting sticks make sense for, well, fighting games, but even those could be better with a keyboard if programmers actually programmed it properly.
https://cloakedthargoid.wordpress.com/keyboards-vs-gamepads/
Your blog was more sensible than your post.
First, yes, obviously it all comes down to what is most comfortable for each individual.
Regarding fighting games, which is what you seem focused on: although arcade sticks are very popular, many players prefer the "hit box" controller (buttons only - no stick), which is similar to using a keyboard like you prefer. One big difference, though, is that the hit box controller will have separate buttons for each finger for movement. It is less than ideal to use your middle finger for both up and down (finger travel = bad), although as with any control method you can get used to it. So, for that reason, I wouldn't call the keyboard better, all else equal.
Regarding gamepads, the main advantage of which is comfort or possibly intuitiveness for some players, you really have to try some better gamepads if you want a good dpad. None of the gamepads on your blog are focused on dpad-based gaming. It's not really fair to say "I tried all these cheap Logitech gamepads and I couldn't do diagonals well. Therefore, all gamepads suck."
The best dpad ever created was the one on the Japanese Sega Saturn controller (in my and many others' opinions), and it is faithfully recreated on the 8bitdo m30. You will not miss diagonals. And it has 6 face buttons which works great for games like SFII.
A gamepad may not offer the most precision, but for many people it offers the most comfort, so blanket statements like "all gamepads suck" is just off the mark in my opinion.