VOGONS


Reply 21 of 40, by dr.zeissler

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t

To my eyes, the SLOT1 is the most perfect platform to use for a 3dfx/dos-highend hybrid. So put a voodoo1 in it with a very good AGP-Card (ATI/Matrox) and go for the late hires-vesa games in dos. To my eyes the later 3D stuff can be played better and much more detailed with actual ports for actual hardware. Take e.g. unreal ? I would never play unreal on a P2/3 500Mhz while I have seen it with 4/8GB Textures in 1080p on my Mac mini M1. That is a totally different game, but as I said that does not count for the very early stuff...respectively dosgilde.

Retro-Gamer 😀 ...on different machines

Reply 22 of 40, by dr.zeissler

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
kingcake wrote on 2026-11-11, 17:22:
dr.zeissler wrote on 2026-11-11, 16:48:

For the gfx, I avoid Nvidia Cards. My favorites are matrox mystique, matrox G200, ati-rage

this is the exact opposite of what you should recommend for dos games
https://gona.mactar.hu/DOS_TESTS/

you missed my point on that, who will play the old early EGA jittery games that even jitter on real early ega-cards. If playing these is you goal than go for a 286/386/486 with an ISA card. Who will play those games on a P2 even if downclocked. You should always consider what is the favorite software you would like to run and then build the machine for this software.

If you stretch the bar too wide then you will make those run on the fast P2 but that might come with a much worse image-quality, shitty win3x fonts and drivers...
I would prefer having a sharp clean image and a wide driver support (OS/2,Win3x,Win9x,WinNt, Amithlon, Linux, Nextstep etc.). But I can only speak for myself.

Retro-Gamer 😀 ...on different machines

Reply 23 of 40, by RetroPCCupboard

User metadata
Rank Oldbie
Rank
Oldbie

Intel i740 also has good quality video signal, and has OK DOS compatibility. I would prefer nVidia Riva 128 or TNT for 3D gaming in Windows though.

Reply 24 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
kingcake wrote on 2026-11-11, 16:24:

Some Aztech cards are pretty good. Many have real Yamaha OPL chips. Pretty comprehensive info on them over at DosDays: https://www.dosdays.co.uk/topics/Manufacturers/aztech.php

kingcake wrote on 2026-11-11, 16:27:

An ESS, Yamaha or older SB card would be much better for DOS. Again, people seem a little misguided here. AWE64s no longer have true OPL and emulate it. It sounds terrible. Look for demos on youtube vs ESSFM.

Yeah, True OPL would be the best. But if emulation is good or even decent, I may not mind options that emulates it. If the AWE64s have terrible emulation of it, then I'll skip them.

dr.zeissler wrote on 2026-11-11, 16:48:
I second that, but it depends what you want to play with the machine. If you are REALLY into early Dos-Gaming and need an authe […]
Show full quote

I second that, but it depends what you want to play with the machine.
If you are REALLY into early Dos-Gaming and need an authentic OPL3 sound, then go for a card with a real OPL3 or take the next best thing that is an ESS-Card with ESSFM.

These sound really different on different OPL chips. The "percussion" sounds terrible-sweeping on some chips.
https://www.pouet.net/prod.php?which=8447 https://www.pouet.net/prod.php?which=8448

If ESSFM would be natively supported this is possible on FM!
https://www.pouet.net/prod.php?which=96920

If you ask me, if you use a P2 machine (even down clocked to 133 Mhz), you are NOT! into early dos-gaming (286/386/486) and therefore do not require a card with a real OPL3! If so, one of the really best, very compatible and bugfree-midi-support and fairly cheap option is the CT4170. I really love it. It sounds very clean, but OPL-Sound depends on the game/demo. Can sound good, can sound bad but soundblaster in Dos works 100% with it and it sounds so much better than the early noisy cards from creative!

I won't recommend an Aztec card, there are a lot of them that have a real OPL3 chip (sometimes even a real on but rebranded) BUT! the SB sounds bad and it is not 100% compatible. The crystal-chips are better, but they do offer the worst OPL implementation. Yamaha is also a good option but I would recommend either a CT4170 or a ESS Card.

For the gfx, I avoid Nvidia Cards. My favorites are matrox mystique, matrox G200, ati-rage, or some really older VESA 1.2 supported cards, but for your P2 I would not use such old cards. Image quality and driver-support are my goals. It's a bit hard, it's neither "fish or flesh" as we call it here. Too slow for 3dfx in 133mhz mode but too fast for most dos-games. Yes I know the duke3d... but these can be played in hires in windows with a win32 port.

For a REAL dos machine think about a DX2/66...

That's a good chunk of info. Now, I probably won't play lots of early DOS games. It's unlikely that I will but not 100% impossible. So an ESS can be done, but I've also read good opinions about Opti cards, that appear to be good OPL3 clones. Aztec cards, as you said, it depends if they have the OPL3 chip, but if SB sound is bad then it may be good to skip them. And Crystal too I've read their OPL3 implementation is not great, but they are pretty good at SB emulation.

For CT4170... I dunnow, I haven't read really stellar opinions about them for the price I can find them. Mind you, they are cheap, but not cheaper than some ESS or Opti options with true OPL3 or good clone.

Yup, this is helping me clear the confution a bit, since I alredy said I'm looking for the best compromise for the cost, not the "overall best".

For video I refered to that spread sheet it was posted before (I had saw it alredy a few weeks ago). For now I just got a GF2 MX400 for very very cheap, 128bit bus for sure and thorughly tested by a local professional reseller. It's not stellar for DOS, being only decent, but if I go the Windows 95 route, it could be helpful in some early 3D accelerated windows game.
But for DOS and just pure output (without 3D acceleration), I think that some sort of S3 Virge is the way to go. They are cheap AF, can be installed on the PCI slot, meaning I don't have to constanlty swap out card when I wanna play in real DOS mode, and I don't really mind that their 3D reputation is more of "decelerators". At that point, since it's unlikely I'll ever play older speed sensitive DOS games, I can just get an even better CPU to really push the software renderer of early 3D DOS games.
And for actually early DOS games, a Socket 7 system may be my next step backwards in time.

kingcake wrote on 2026-11-11, 17:22:

this is the exact opposite of what you should recommend for dos games
https://gona.mactar.hu/DOS_TESTS/

Yup, that's why I fired alredy on an extremely cheap GF2 MX400 with a 128bit bus. Based on that list is a decent compromise for both Windows 3D and some DOS. Then I just need to pair an S3 Virge in a PCI slot for all the DOS stuff that won't work on the nVidia card.

dr.zeissler wrote on 2026-11-11, 17:26:

To my eyes, the SLOT1 is the most perfect platform to use for a 3dfx/dos-highend hybrid. So put a voodoo1 in it with a very good AGP-Card (ATI/Matrox) and go for the late hires-vesa games in dos. To my eyes the later 3D stuff can be played better and much more detailed with actual ports for actual hardware. Take e.g. unreal ? I would never play unreal on a P2/3 500Mhz while I have seen it with 4/8GB Textures in 1080p on my Mac mini M1. That is a totally different game, but as I said that does not count for the very early stuff...respectively dosgilde.

If it wasn't for the prices of Voodoo1s, I would get one. And if Voodoo Banshees and Voodoo3s had better 3D DOS compatibility, I would bite the bullet and get me one of those.
Unfortunatelly it appears that both are not really the case.
And about playing games on modern hardware... I alredy do. I just LOVE to also play stuff on the machines they were meant to be played, or at least close to it. Because I don't believe people just stopped entirely playing Doom II when 3D accelerated Quake dropped.

dr.zeissler wrote on 2026-11-11, 17:29:

you missed my point on that, who will play the old early EGA jittery games that even jitter on real early ega-cards. If playing these is you goal than go for a 286/386/486 with an ISA card. Who will play those games on a P2 even if downclocked. You should always consider what is the favorite software you would like to run and then build the machine for this software.

If you stretch the bar too wide then you will make those run on the fast P2 but that might come with a much worse image-quality, shitty win3x fonts and drivers...
I would prefer having a sharp clean image and a wide driver support (OS/2,Win3x,Win9x,WinNt, Amithlon, Linux, Nextstep etc.). But I can only speak for myself.

Don't worry, it's highly unlikely that I will play such old games on this sistem. If they run, ok, if they don't... I mean, I'm all covered from 1998 to today, so I can only go back with my next builds. And "non super" socket 7 boards can be had for relatively cheap.

RetroPCCupboard wrote on 2026-11-11, 19:43:

Intel i740 also has good quality video signal, and has OK DOS compatibility. I would prefer nVidia Riva 128 or TNT for 3D gaming in Windows though.

I actually never considered and Intel GPU for this build. But, as you said, nVidia is still a preferable alternative. I would've loved a full fledge TNT2, but only M64 can be had for cheap and, at that point, I just went and got a 128bit GF2 MX400 for really cheap.

Reply 25 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
kingcake wrote on 2026-11-11, 06:45:

For sound I prefer ESS Audio Drives. To my ear ESSFM sounds the best.

RetroPCCupboard wrote on 2026-11-11, 09:59:

ESS Audiodrive is a good card too, and also you can get generic Yamaha OPL3 ISA cards. My preference for SB16 is mostly based on nostalgia, and usually they just work.

RetroPCCupboard wrote on 2026-11-11, 10:18:

ESS Audiodrive, Yamaha and SB16 are all that I have used in the form of ISA cards.

Quick question to all the people that suggested ESS: I've found many barebone looking AudioDrive ES1868F, some of them from COMPAQ, barebone as missing headers and lots of chips on the PCB itself.
Also saw an AudioDrive ES688FC with a PCB packed full of stuff.

What's the deal with all these variants? Are they roughly equivalent or should I avoid like the plague some of them?

Reply 26 of 40, by H3nrik V!

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Mondodimotori wrote on 2026-11-11, 19:52:

And about playing games on modern hardware... I alredy do. I just LOVE to also play stuff on the machines they were meant to be played, or at least close to it. Because I don't believe people just stopped entirely playing Doom II when 3D accelerated Quake dropped.

I'm totally on your page on this one! If it wasn't that case, none of us would even be playing any retro games, as there are modern equivalents of most of them ..

If it's dual it's kind of cool ... 😎

--- GA586DX --- P2B-DS --- BP6 ---

Please use the "quote" option if asking questions to what I write - it will really up the chances of me noticing 😀

Reply 27 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
H3nrik V! wrote on 2026-11-12, 08:50:

I'm totally on your page on this one! If it wasn't that case, none of us would even be playing any retro games, as there are modern equivalents of most of them ..

Exactly!

BTW, I was lucky enough to find a seller here in Italy selling an ESS Audiodrive ES1868F with a pretty generic title for the listing. I found it because he was also selling a Sound Blaster Live! SB0060 that appeared in my feed, which shoul be good for my 9x retro system. So I got both of them.
The ES1868F is this model exactly, and it's nice to have some documentation about this specific model.

Now I gotta decide, since this one is not an OPL3 implementation, but ESS own great FM implementation, if it's worth to find cheap cards that comes with an actual Yamaha OPL3 chip.

Oh yeah, now all that's missing is a 2D card with good compatibility, either an S3Trio or S3 Virge.

Reply 28 of 40, by Intel486dx33

User metadata
Rank l33t++
Rank
l33t++

That bx440 motherboard with 333 Celeron was a popular combination back around 1997 / 98
It was popular with gamers and over clockers because it was inexpensive
The Pentium-ll @400 mhz was selling for about $300
This Celeron setup was about half the cost of the Pentium-ll
Setup.

I remember I had one of these Celeron builds
Before I bought the Pentium-ll

Last edited by Intel486dx33 on 2026-11-13, 11:10. Edited 1 time in total.

Reply 29 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
Intel486dx33 wrote on 2026-11-13, 06:03:
That bx449 motherboard with 333 Celeron was a popular combination back around 1997 / 98 It was popular with gamers and over cloc […]
Show full quote

That bx449 motherboard with 333 Celeron was a popular combination back around 1997 / 98
It was popular with gamers and over clockers because it was inexpensive
The Pentium-ll @400 mhz was selling for about $300
This Celeron setup was about half the cost of the Pentium-ll
Setup.

I remember I had one of these Celeron builds
Before I bought the Pentium-ll

Yeah, I can imagine, it's the second QDI board in my collection, and I see from the BIOS that you can tinker quite a lot. I bet it was popular with overclockers. You just needed to get an unlocked CPU to really have fun with it.

Reply 30 of 40, by H3nrik V!

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t
Mondodimotori wrote on 2026-11-13, 09:45:
Intel486dx33 wrote on 2026-11-13, 06:03:
That bx449 motherboard with 333 Celeron was a popular combination back around 1997 / 98 It was popular with gamers and over cloc […]
Show full quote

That bx449 motherboard with 333 Celeron was a popular combination back around 1997 / 98
It was popular with gamers and over clockers because it was inexpensive
The Pentium-ll @400 mhz was selling for about $300
This Celeron setup was about half the cost of the Pentium-ll
Setup.

I remember I had one of these Celeron builds
Before I bought the Pentium-ll

Yeah, I can imagine, it's the second QDI board in my collection, and I see from the BIOS that you can tinker quite a lot. I bet it was popular with overclockers. You just needed to get an unlocked CPU to really have fun with it.

You don't need an unlocked CPU to have fun. A lot of 333 celerons run 500 @100 MHz FSB a good bit of them even on stock voltage 😀

If it's dual it's kind of cool ... 😎

--- GA586DX --- P2B-DS --- BP6 ---

Please use the "quote" option if asking questions to what I write - it will really up the chances of me noticing 😀

Reply 31 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
H3nrik V! wrote on 2026-11-13, 13:39:

You don't need an unlocked CPU to have fun. A lot of 333 celerons run 500 @100 MHz FSB a good bit of them even on stock voltage 😀

I had this suspicion when, for testing slowing it down, I ended up overclocking it with 80 something mhz FSB and it happily posted.
Now, I currently don't see 100mhz in the BIOS, but I do see a jumper on the board that needs to be activated to run it at 100mhz.

Of course, an unlocked multiplier would be even more fun to tinker with.

Reply 32 of 40, by luk1999

User metadata
Rank Newbie
Rank
Newbie

Well, B0 Mendocinos (s370 only) should do 500 MHz easily but with slot 1 (usually A0 stepping) it will be much harder to achieve. 😉

P4 3.4E, P4C800-E Dlx, 1 GB, X800 PRO 256 MB, SB Audigy, XP SP2
A1.4, A7V133, 512 MB, R8500LE, FM801, ME
P3 600, AX6BC, 128 MB, GF2 PRO 64 MB, ALS100+, 98SE
K6/266, MS5149, 64 MB, Virge 4 MB, V1 4MB, ESS1868, 95 OSR2

Reply 33 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
luk1999 wrote on 2026-11-13, 21:14:

Well, B0 Mendocinos (s370 only) should do 500 MHz easily but with slot 1 (usually A0 stepping) it will be much harder to achieve. 😉

Yeah, it would be fun to try but, since I alredy have a 1000mhz P3 system on S370 (QDI board with one ISA slot) I don't really feel the need to push this Celeron hard at all.

Anyway, I'm now hunting for the final pieces, meaning an S3 card and a new floppy drive, since I don't have one free on my hands.

Reply 34 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member

First component has arrived, the video card: A geForce2 MX400 64mb 128bit

Works quite well and, in an Athlon 2600+ system + WinME, it benches well over 5700 points in 3dMark2000.
(for future reference, don't use 45.23 drivers on this card with 9x, it'll make the system unstable AF, extremely prone to hang and crashing. I used version 21.81 from september 2001 and they worked like a charm)

Just, I've noticed a quirk with it. In the Slot 1 system it makes the POST screens and BIOS quite choppy to visualize and navigate. Meaning: The components on screen appears in chunks, let's take the BIOS. It loads the blu background, then the lines and then the text of every section.
With the Blade3D it doesn't do anything of the sort.
So I took out my fuzzy TNT2 M64, plugged it in and, while it's better than the GF2, I can still see everything in BIOS and post screens to be slighty choppier and loading in chunks (and the fuzz on top of that).

Is this normal behaviour for these kind of cards on such hardware?

Anyway, here's a pic of the little guy:

The attachment GF2_mx400.jpeg is no longer available

Reply 35 of 40, by Warlord

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t

nope not normal. check to make sure the vid card is assigned an irq. There are some other settings you can check to see if there is any impact, like video bios caching and shadowing etc. check you have the latest bios. latest bios is from 1999 i think,

your board also has a sb-link header. while i skimed the thread i dont remember anybody recommending a pci sound card and connecting that way since thats also a valid option for sound. Outside of some boutique pci sound cards from like hoontech or guillemot theres really only 3 pci sound cards worth using with sb-link. Ess solo1, yamaha XG, and A3d. I still find ymf724 for sale every once in awhile with not to terrible prices.

Reply 36 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
Warlord wrote on Yesterday, 06:48:

nope not normal. check to make sure the vid card is assigned an irq. There are some other settings you can check to see if there is any impact, like video bios caching and shadowing etc. check you have the latest bios. latest bios is from 1999 i think,

EDIT: what about AGP aperture size? I have 64mb of ram and, IIRC, the aperture size is now set to 64mb with this GPU.

Will check the IRQ, because even the TNT2 does that to a lesser extent. The Trident doesn't.
About bios version, it's not the last one. And, if not needed, I would avoid to flash a new BIOS, since it's always a tiny risk to do so.
I will check all the options you mentioned in the BIOS and come back to you, since I've never messed with IRQs before. (so any suggestion is welcome)

If everything checks out, and this become an unbearable problem instead of a slight nuisance, I will go with the BIOS update route.

About SB-Link... I alredy got one ISA card on the was (ESS audiodrive) and, probably, will also get another with true OPL3 chip.

Reply 37 of 40, by Mondodimotori

User metadata
Rank Member
Rank
Member
Warlord wrote on Yesterday, 06:48:

check to make sure the vid card is assigned an irq. There are some other settings you can check to see if there is any impact, like video bios caching and shadowing etc.

Welp, performed all the tests. Nothing changes. For the sake of it, I've tested three other GPUs:

  • Trident Blade 3D: the fastest in BIOS
  • TNT2 M64: Slightly slower than the Trident in BIOS (not by much)
  • geForce4 MX440 SE: Slower than the TNT2 and choppier.
  • geForce2 MX400: the slowest and choppiest.

I've also noticed that the GF2 is the only card in that list that won't show it's own VGA BIOS splashscreen at boot. Every other card does show it, reporting the name of the card and memory available (the Blade3D also has some nice colored logo in it). The GF2 nothing, black screen with the monitor registering an input, POST beep, and there goes the POST screen.

For better understanding, I've made four videos, one for every card. In the GF2 video I opened every BIOS windows to show you every option. It appears to me that an IRQ is indeed assigned to the VGA, but even using the "automatic" assignment of every IRQ, nothing changes.

Under spoilers the video from my drive:

Every GPU tested in BIOS

geForce2 MX400
Trident Blade3D 9880 Turbo
TNT2 M64
geForce4 MX440 SE

Guess the only thing left to try is to update BIOS. Guess there's a first time for everything, including updating BIOS from a bootable floppy disc. I should get me new cables and a floppy drive in the next couple of days, I'll search how to perform a BIOS update on old MOBOs and a suitable flasher for this motherboard.

I'm still open to alternatives, though.

Reply 38 of 40, by Warlord

User metadata
Rank l33t
Rank
l33t

14 and 15 irq should not be legacy isa, both need to be pci/isa. Disable usb and don't assign irq for it if you don't need it, it could be irq sharing with the nvidia card. video bios cacheable and video ram cacheable should be enabled those boost performance.

what could be happening i dont know is setting irq 14 and 15 to isa, forces the ide controllers on to 10 and 11 along with the usb controller and the vga card which is not good.

IRQ	Standard Assignment	Notes
IRQ 0 System Timer Internal Intel 8253/8254 timer; cannot be reassigned.
IRQ 1 Keyboard Controller PS/2 or AT keyboard interface; cannot be reassigned.
IRQ 2 Cascade to Slave PIC Routes signals from IRQs 8–15 to the Master PIC.
IRQ 3 Serial Port 2 (COM2) Often shared with COM4.
IRQ 4 Serial Port 1 (COM1) Often shared with COM3.
IRQ 5 Parallel Port 2 (LPT2) / Sound Card Default choice for legacy ISA sound cards (e.g., Sound Blaster).
IRQ 6 Floppy Disk Controller Dedicated to floppy disk drives.
IRQ 7 Parallel Port 1 (LPT1) Primary printer port; occasionally used as an alternate sound card IRQ.


Slave PIC (IRQ 8–15)


IRQ Standard Assignment Notes
IRQ 8 Real-Time Clock (RTC) Internal CMOS clock; cannot be reassigned.
IRQ 9 Redirected IRQ 2 / ACPI Software-redirected to replace IRQ 2; used for ACPI on newer chipsets or open for peripherals.
IRQ 10 Available (Open) Commonly used by SCSI adapters, network cards (NICs), or USB controllers.
IRQ 11 Available (Open) Commonly used by SCSI adapters, NICs, or video cards.
IRQ 12 PS/2 Mouse Available for peripherals if no PS/2 mouse is installed.
IRQ 13 Math Coprocessor / FPU Handles floating-point unit errors; cannot be reassigned.
IRQ 14 Primary IDE / ATA Channel Controls primary hard drives and optical drives.
IRQ 15 Secondary IDE / ATA Channel

Reply 39 of 40, by Intel486dx33

User metadata
Rank l33t++
Rank
l33t++

I am pretty sure I was running windows 95 on my Celeron CPU’s build.
I also had a AMD k6-2@300 mhz build running windows 95
These were popular with budget Gamers.